Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Sarah Palin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sarah Palin. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Can fear of change in Alberta change Canada?

Red Tories haven’t had a good election for a generation and they had every right to celebrate last night.
However, like others who weather bad times, they can be small, too. Allison Redford had good reasons to be small last night: she was expected to lose the last standing dynasty of progressive conservatism to a conservative upstart, and she had already worked for the vanquished Joe Clark and seven failed states on behalf of the UN. So, just for the record, last night, she was a little nasty.
“Every Albertan knew that this election was about choice. A choice to put up walls or to build bridges. A choice about Alberta's future,” Ms. Redford said in her victory speech. “Tonight, Alberta chose to build bridges.”
It's a gleeful iteration of a campaign of fear, but hardly a reliable guide for Western politics or the last word on her opponent, Danielle Smith.
When you’re rich and you’re thinking about throwing out a regime that’s been in office for over 40 years—and the alternative has been ahead in the polls for nearly three weeks—the alternative, not change or the brutes you’ve known for a life time, becomes the ballot issue.
Danielle Smith was crudely accused of being Sarah Palin and suspected of being easy on the Counter-Reformation and Alberta independence. These charges wouldn’t have landed, except on the CBC, if she’d had enough time to establish herself.
The last dynasty in Alberta—Social Credit, 1935 to 1971—was defeated by a Harvard MBA graduate named Peter Lougheed. He first served four years in the Alberta legislature and had the intangible benefit of carrying an honored family name that had served in Alberta public life since Confederation. Like Smith, he was also articulate, business-like, and extremely ambitious. (The moment he became premier, Lougheed became a Canadian of consequence—often praised as a statesman and, as well, suspected as a divider and extremist in Eastern Canada.)
Centrist left politics, of course, are not dead. However, their chances of making a comeback in Canadian federal politics by campaigning on fear are not validated by what just happened in Alberta.
The New Democrats, though, should feel very good about choosing Thomas Mulcair as their national leader. He didn’t have the freshest face at their leadership convention, but he has all the political experience that Danielle Smith didn’t have—and would have likely saved her campaign.
The biggest policy problem for Stephen Harper, and potentially for Canada, will be Premier Redford’s self-imposed promise of talking the rest of Canada into going along with Alberta’s energy development and fiscal priorities. Albertans haven’t gone sheepish about controlling their resource development, or soft on carbon taxes and transfer payments to Eastern Canada. Her Finance Minister has Alberta conservatives and taxpayers, not the Empire Club of Toronto, to first impress.

Friday, April 13, 2012

Danielle Smith—North America’s raising conservative star



As a billion dollars gears up to get conservatives excited about Mitt Romney, Alberta, Canada, is about to launch Daniel Smith—and remind everyone that Romney is a timid bore.

Calgary’s Danielle Smith is only a smart 41-year-old troublemaker who doesn’t claim we’re going to hell in a hand basket or that moderate elites are poisoning our minds. Nevertheless, on the 23rd of April, she’s likely to crush the most powerful, longest-standing mainstream conservative government in North America.

In only 3 years, Cassias’s sister with the nice smile organized the Wildrose Party of Alberta and now is about to throw a 41-year-old Progressive Conservative government out of power. Last night’s leader’s debate did nothing to slow her insolent campaign.


In the debate, the leader of the New Democrats played the “I’m-at-least-a-clean-Canadian” card by saying, “Danielle, this is Alberta, not Alabama.”

Leave it to Fox News to decide which has the star appeal. However, if she beats the ruthless 11 straight election winning Alberta Progressive Conservative machine, Danielle Smith, not Sarah Palin or Chris Christie, will be the most accomplished anti-establishment conservative winner in North America.

If in 4 years from now, she was a competent governor of a western American state, she’d be a promising national contender.

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

"Game Change": Sarah Palin wasn’t any scarier than the guys

Republican professionals were too chivalrous to do it alone. So, they collaborated with Hollywood to produce an HBO film about that terrible woman from Alaska who wrecked John McCain’s chances to be President of the United States.
Certainly, her briefings on foreign and monetary policy, debate preparations, and the glib vice-president vetting interviews with experts from all appropriate fields—carefully verified with on-hand witnesses—were cringing. She was play-acting from Wasilla. But, for screaming out loud, they were play-acting from Washington.
The film is burdened by a rather obvious if subtle contract between its inside McCain consultants and its producers: if the insiders help the producers portray Sarah Palin as being as truly bad as she was, they will be portrayed as intelligent professionals who, at worst, made that once-in-a-career mistake that interesting professionals are prone to make.
Consequently, the conversations with the presidential candidate are worthy of Disneyworld.  McCain’s brilliant strategist Steve Schmidt’s first words of advice are “to put country first.” McCain visibly swoons.
Schmidt has acknowledged, after the campaign, that the idea of Vice President Sarah Palin is “frightening.”
However, on every occasion in Game Change that Sarah merely survived, he and his campaign (with the honorable exception of media advisor Nicole Wallace) were elated because, for a careless moment, he felt he was getting Palin and McCain that much closer to the White House. The only thing that truly frightened him was the possibility that that during the campaign itself the general public would be privileged to find out that Sarah Palin was an ignorant phoney surviving entirely on memorized one-liners provided by pointy-headed snobs.
 The closest the film gets to raw male hostility toward Barack Obama is the use of the word “celebrity.” The film notes their use of the snide slogan “Real America” and McCain’s constant rhetorical question: “What does Obama plan for America?” It doesn’t bother, however, to explore why and how they must wear him down in their overall campaign, not just in Palin’s pitch to the evangelical base.
That’s merely air-brushing history. But, it’s pure distortion to create the impression that Sarah Palin single-handily stirred up the “dark side of American populism.” She was the amateur in a bigger game.
In truth, the Republican Party still hasn’t come to grips with Obama or what to do in a general election with the slogan the "Real America.” This week, Pew Polling reported that a majority of Mississippi Republicans still think Barack Obama is a Muslim. Game Change may rehabilitate a few careers in Washington, but it won’t teach the Republican Party how to beat a popular Democratic president.

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

America: a 50/50 democracy or just half crazy?

Liberal and foreign pundits have made up their minds: Today’s Republican Party is either suicidal or crazy. In winning so many fights with Democrats over the last year, they’ve lost their reason. They will blow next year’s presidential election by nominating a dim, offensive, or unsound nominee.
“Republicans want anyone but the pragmatist” writes Jeffrey Simpson in the Globe and Mail. They hate Obama “with a frenzied passion,” and, so, can’t think straight. Maclean’s magazine headlines its analysis of the Republican primary race with “American idiots: Gaffes, mistakes, scandals and humiliation.” The Toronto Star’s, Heather Mallick’s verdict: “The Republican catastrophe has been their faith in ideology over effectiveness. They would rather break than bend.”
The above Canadian observers only report what American pessimists say about themselves.  
The Economist’s Lexington column offers a nuanced, hopeful note. It ends a damning profile of Newt Gingrich by saying, “Unless they are feeling particularly suicidal, the Republicans will reject him, just as they have rejected Mr Perry and the Mr Cain."
The Republican Party had over 30 million members in 2008 and will have more by the end of the presidential primaries in 2012. With a base larger than the adult population of California or Canada—a base lovingly monitored by the press—it is certain that many silly, crazy, and mean things will be reported, worldwide.
However, the Republican Party is not a cult: it doesn’t practice frenzied rituals in secret cells or ignore what others think. Despite its noisy romantics, it’s still conservative because it’s heavily invested in the status quo—it’s mainstream plus.
Republican voters are older, whiter, more affluent, more likely to have completed four years in college and have kids living at home than typical Democrats. They have a winner’s stake in the existing order—a pro-business climate and a public sector financially strong enough to keep them safe and to provide generous support for seniors and for their school-age kids. They pay more taxes than the poor and get far more out of government as well.
The dearest hope of Manhattan and Hollywood Democrats is that the Republican Party will nominate a goofy candidate and, with their powdered wigs, muskets, handguns, and Confederate flags, they’ll agree to pose for a group photo for National Lampoon.
(Again, Obama relies less on hope than they would like. He’s assuming they’ll elect Mitt Romney or, if not Mitt Romney, someone who will try carefully to tailor his message in order to win next fall’s election.)
Of course, Republicans can miscalculate, especially when they’re out of power and facing a still popular opponent. Their ideal presidential candidate probably decided too early to defer to Obama; being a loosely managed human institution, the Republican convention could mistakenly pick a dud.  
Yet, as The Economist noted, so far Republicans have reacted to bad news in a brutally rational fashion. The undeserving high profiles that were granted Sarah Palin, Michele
Bachmann, Rick Perry, and Herman Cain drove up their polling numbers in the Republican Party—and then news of their flaws and shortcomings drove their numbers down just as fast.

Thursday, July 21, 2011

Obama’s passion gap

George Packer delivered a bitter assault on the competence of Barack Obama’s presidency in the influential “Talk of the Town” section of The New Yorker. He elevated the standard liberal frustration—the President’s “fire in the belly” problem—by saying worse things about others, invoking the pain of unemployed individuals that Obama can’t help, and quoting the famously scientific 19th Century European political thinker Max Weber. 

“On its own, the ethic of responsibility can become a devotion to technically correct procedure, while the ethic of ultimate ends can become fanaticism. Weber’s terms perfectly capture the toxic dynamic between the President, who takes responsibility as an end in itself, and the Republicans in Congress, who are destructively consumed with their own dogma. Neither side can be said to possess what Weber calls a “leader’s personality.” Responsibility without conviction is weak, but it is sane. Conviction without responsibility, in the current incarnation of the Republican Party, is raving mad.”

Read more www.newyorker.com/talk/comment/2011/07/25/110725taco_talk_packer#ixzz1SeU3bUUH

The serious target of this extravagant indictment is clearly the President. The Republican Party is not of one mind. Try to imagine Sarah Palin and Mitch McConnell finishing each other’s sentences. Republicans recklessly over play their hand. Obama apparently doesn’t even have his heart in the game.

Packer’s case against him is personal: Obama seems determined to do his best within the bounds of Washington’s divided-government and doesn’t try to escape that reality with sufficient rhetorical verve:

“More important, he no longer uses his office’s most powerful tool, rhetorical suasion, to keep the country focused on the continued need for government activism.”

This fundamentally understates what Packer actually wants him to do and overstates the use of rhetoric to do the job. Packer wants the center of opinion in the country to shift far enough to the left that Obama can get his way on policy with a hostile Congress.

The center of public opinion is deeply ambivalent about the virtue of debt- financed government intervention. It can shift in favour a little more government leadership and, for the sake of a faster recovery, it probably should.  However, trying to hasten that process now with florid presidential rhetoric would be self-defeating.

Any success would be entirely speculative. Republican activists will continue to drive the primary process—the process that disciplines the president’s recalcitrant Washington opponents. The undecided voters that Obama needs won’t have a ballot to confirm what they think for another fifteen months. That’s a long time to wait for crowd reaction and policy progress.  

Of course, it would be more exciting if Obama dropped his reputation for being “more reasonable” than his adversaries and deployed a winner-take-all inspirational style. However, that would only deepen paralysis in Washington and feed the suspicion that he’s more articulate than effective.

The crucial problem with Packer’s thesis, however, is the contention that inspirational White House rhetoric can change the way the people think and, in doing so, can change circumstances on the ground.

Teddy Roosevelt coined the phrase “bully-pulpit” but never enjoyed the right circumstances to make it work. His theatrical competitor Winston Churchill appeared to use words to vastly great effect while TR ended his public career as a rather windy crank.  Yet, it was only during an extraordinary period in history that Churchill truly inspired. In the late spring and summer of 1940, he and his listeners agreed, finally, on the nature of the problem and necessity to act.   

Reading the facts responsibly did not encumber Churchill’s rhetoric. Luftwaffe planes over the night skies of London established Churchill as Britain’s greatest realist and that allowed him to be heard by everyone. Theories about military deterrence didn’t work for Churchill and economic arguments will not create a national consensus for Obama.

For a generation, Churchill had been recognized as a great wordsmith, while his political influence faded. He inspired a nation in 1940 because no one questioned his definition of the task before them. It would have only been embarrassing if he’d given “his blood, sweat and tears speech” a year earlier.

Conviction, without good timing, makes people look away rather than leap to their feet.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Feasting on an American tragedy

Nobody, in the land of the free, takes being called an accomplice to murder lying down. Accordingly, the far right is raising hell, in its own defense. Whether, they can regain the political offensive remains to be seen. Sarah Palin, possibly the cockiest politician to come along since Mayor Richard Daley, has the biggest problem: innocent as driven snow as she thinks, her charm was born of her blithe and reckless style. And reckless political rhetoric will, for some time, match drunk driving for bad taste
Jared Lee Loughner’s rampage may have a long impact on American politics. There is nothing exotic or foreign about any of it. A single issue—like, racial equality or the right to strike—was not at issue and isn’t at hand to resolve. The victims were not Presidents or radicals but ordinary, affable Americans living in a community still optimistic about the future.
As a Canadian neighbor, one thing that is starting to embarrass me is the verdict of outsiders that America’s political style is murderous, that violence emanates from America’s peculiarly abrasive political culture and commercial media.  John Doyle, a Toronto film critic said:
“What Fox News has sown is now being reaped. . . . Fox News does indeed define the U.S. political culture and the manner of debate inside that culture. It is to blame, but blame must be tempered by our understanding that Fox News is America and America is Fox News. There will be neither silence nor a change of tone until the Fox News Channel changes or shuts up. That’s not going to happen. Look at the ratings. The ratings don’t lie.”
—John Doyle, “How fox changed the tone of American political debate,” The Globe and Mail, January 11, 2011


Fox News is a delicious whipping boy.  If Fox News, rather than Radio Free Europe was broadcasting in the 1980’s, the Berlin Wall would probably still be standing. Nevertheless, if Fox was the voice of America today, Barack Obama would not be President. 

The notion that rough debate somehow causes Americans to kill one another and that that rough debate is something that America’s civilized friends have, thankfully, put behind them is offensive.

Let’s hear it for partisan civility. But let’s not pretend that good manners in Washington will civilize the fevered margins of America’s culture. When the US Congress was dominated by so-called bi-partisan elder statesmen, blacks were regularly being lynched and civil libertarians and peace protesters were being clubbed by the police.

Americans are not passive people. However, labeling their aggressiveness as an expression of a people “fearful of change and hostile to opposing viewpoints” is, coming from a Canadian, cheap. 

American protest movements and political fights have authored much of Canadian and Western political discourse for decades. Americans argue in public about the most sensitive tensions in their culture and their conduct in the world. Nothing is excluded in Washington simply because it’s not mainstream.

In cocktail parties in Toronto, it’s easier to have an intelligent discussion about what Americans are excited about than how we govern ourselves. Just try having an interesting argument about Canadian foreign policy or why we have an appointed Senate.

Sunday, January 9, 2011

Jared Lee Loughner’s crazy violence and partisan rhetoric

This tragedy will, at least for awhile, wring some of the sexiness out of the violent rhetoric of the last few years. Muskets and rebel garb too will probably go back to the rec-rooms and costume boutiques from where they came. “Manning up” and “re-loading” may lose their power to amuse. Once again violent language will remind us of real violence and will offend.

However, directly connecting Sarah Palin, the Tea Party and Arizona’s political climate to Loughner’s motives feels unfair and naive.  Crude and hateful rhetoric should be shunned at the polls, not named as an accomplice to a crime.

The mystery behind Mr. Loughner’s crazy act is embedded in his environment and, in part, in all he absorbed from what he read. It is ridiculous to pull out and high light that he read Mein Kampf and The Communist Manifesto and it’s mischievous to connect his primary target to Sarah Palin’s hit list in the congressional elections.

According to MySpace, his favorite books also included:  Animal Farm, Brave New World, The Wizard Of OZ, Aesop Fables, The Odyssey, Alice Adventures Into Wonderland, Fahrenheit 451, Peter Pan, To Kill A Mockingbird, We The Living, Phantom Toll Booth, One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest, Pulp, Through The Looking Glass, Siddhartha, The Old Man And The Sea, Gulliver's Travels, and The Republic.
We are about to learn a lot of details that may, for some, fill in the puzzle behind this crime. Who knows? We are very unlikely, however, to find that Sarah Palin and Rush Limbaugh were his inspiration.

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Tax cut “certainty” and economic growth

Keeping their campaigns for the Presidency uncontaminated by the compromisers in Washington, Sarah Palin and Mitt Romney have chosen to reject the Obama-McConnell $858 billion tax package because its income tax cuts are “temporary.”
Compared to all the terrible things that have been said about the fiscal policy of the US government this insult “temporary” is pretty feeble. It doesn’t touch “voodoo economics” of the Reagan era or, in fact, Romney’s observation last week that “we are already drowning in debt.”
By the end of next year, we may all look back fondly at a time when we could complain: I’m not certain the good news will last.
Indeed, it’s the level of certainty around right now may that may prove to be extravagant. Not a soul running for national office or on late night television questions the left-right consensus that taxes on middle class working families, small businesses, farmers and risk-takers can’t go up. All the while, average Americans consume fifty percent more in government services than they pay for.
 Democrat spokespersons suck it up and insist that the 5% tax cut they gave the rich can’t be permanent because it’s wrong. Their metric of statesmanship in these unparalleled times is Bill Clinton’s boom-time fiscal policy of the late 1990s. They imagine girding themselves to fight the same campaign in 2012.
This 5% debate about 2% of American tax payers, however, is trivial when put against the $4 trillion fiscal hole identified by the Bowles-Simpson Commission on fiscal responsibility. Wall Street has been thriving on temporary tax cuts. But it is taking note of the observation last week by Moody’s Investors Service Inc. that the widening federal deficit may soon jeopardize the United States credit rating. The uncertainty that would launch would even give Sarah Palin’s twitter a pause. Click on: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/us-tax-plan-threatens-top-credit-rating/article1836299/

                        Countries with a 'triple-A' credit rating

  • Australia
  • Austria
  • Canada
  • Denmark
  • Finland
  • France
  • Germany
  • Luxembourg
  • Netherlands
  • New Zealand
  • Norway
  • Singapore
  • Sweden
  • Switzerland
  • United Kingdom
  • United States
Source: Moody's Investors Service
Along with governments financing themselves responsibly, a broad level of confidence in the social-economic environment is vital in a free market economy. However, that doesn’t stand or fall on a few tax points. And the fundamentals of a positive business climate are safely in place. The public’s commitment to free enterprise is as strong as ever. The world community continues to support freer trade. Both US national parties are committed to a private sector-based recovery. In fact, the Obama stimulus program (that was launched without a single Republican vote) has expanded private sector growth and allowed public sector employment to shrink. Click on: http://yglesias.thinkprogress.org/2010/11/the-conservative-recovery/
There are no influential socialists in Washington or anywhere else in the US, except possibly in communes in upstate New York or in Glenn Beck focus groups.
One of the stark differences between the political climate of the Great Depression and the recent severe recession is the degree of public support today for policies to restore, not replace, the private sector.  The hindsight movement, the so-called Tea Party, complains that the bail-outs were unnecessary, not that Washington missed a chance to nationalize the commanding heights of the economy—exactly what was done in half of Europe in the 1930s.
What is now in question is not the resilience of markets but the spine of democratic politicians. Legislation on taxes and everything else is inherently temporary. However, failing to restore the US federal government’s fiscal credibility will lead to very long-term and pervasive pain. And there won’t necessarily be a count-down.


Tuesday, December 14, 2010

“American Exceptionalism” and the future of the West?

Some days, living in Canada you have to be a farseeing optimist to stand up for the United States. However, America’s best friends will steadily pull away if resurgent nonsense about “American exceptionalism” is not challenged, especially within the Party of Lincoln and Eisenhower. 
This is not a call for another “apology” to sensitive neighbours. American democracy is at its best when it’s rough.  And its continued success is of vital interest to its Western allies. However, America’s future influence is not assured and is undermined daily by the rhetoric of exceptionalism that now appears to dominate the world view of prominent Republicans. It insults our intelligence as well as our equally well-demonstrated attachment to Western values.
For over a year now, Barack Obama has been attacked for a polite statement he made on the subject in Europe. Trying, as he was then, to make everybody feel comfortable, he said that he believed in American exceptionalism in the same way the “Brits believe in British exceptionalism and the Greeks believe in Greek exceptionalism.” Imagine! Putting American pridefulness on the same level as Brits and Greeks—two of the principal authors of Western values, industrialization, and modern empire.
“Appalling,” Sarah Palin exclaims in her latest book, America By Heart. Shrewdly, appreciating that the readers like to be thought of as nice, she unsheathes:
“Sad to say, many of our national leaders no longer believe in American exceptionalism. They—perhaps dearly—love their country and want what’s best for it, but they think America is just an ordinary nation and so America should act like just an ordinary nation. They don’t believe we have a special message for the world or a special mission to preserve our greatness for the betterment of not just ourselves but all of humanity.” Click on: http://www.nationalpost.com/todays-paper/America+Exceptional/3949230/story.html
(I can’t say whether it’s a great book. I’ve only read excerpts in the press. However, what I’ve read is clear and premeditated. Sarah Palin is serious, has a talented organization, and is already a dominating influence among active Republicans. The next Republican candidate may be Sarah Palin or someone effectively imitating her words.)
To tens of millions of those of us on the outside, the way she brands Obama brands America too. Imagine how Palin’s claims for America echo amongst America’s best friends.
Did Franklin D. Roosevelt—a mean communicator in his own right—ask the US Congress to help Great Britain in 1940 because the English, and their Canadian and Commonwealth allies, were too ordinary to defend themselves? Did Churchill and Roosevelt draft “four American freedoms” as their allied mission statement and, later, as the basis of the Charter of the United Nations? Are we in Afghanistan, if not to protect US interests, only to uphold made-in-the-US ideas about liberty and equality?
Surely, it is not what is unique, but what is universal about what Americans believe that is the basis for our fraternity and the West’s solidarity in a challenging world. Common cause cannot be freely sustained between the “exceptional” and the ordinary.
The Romans at their zenith, in fact, decided to grant Roman citizenship to all free people in the Roman Empire. They kept their pride and their power intact for another two centuries. America, not being an empire in the literal sense of the word, would be well to question whether claims of special status go with global influence.
De Tocqueville did say that in the 1840s America’s cultural and physical circumstances provided an “exceptional” opportunity for liberty and human progress to flourish. But he didn’t suggest that America’s values were wholly American inventions or that Americans were graced with super insights about how to navigate the future.
De Tocqueville was a social analyst, not a stone mason: he left nothing solid behind to protect America’s relatively superior circumstances from misuse and decline.


Wednesday, December 8, 2010

Wikileaks and spinning America

Along with the Ground Zero mosque and Glenn Beck’s righteous march on Washington, Wikileaks offers fantasists a fresh chance to unfurl their gaudiest ideas about America.
On the right, Charles Krauthammer, Sarah Palin, and Newt Gingrich are irresistible; it’s like watching a train of high explosives heading for no-man’s land. The US administration, they complain, is playing things down. Hell, they haven’t even hinted that they’d like to kill someone. Espionage and treason have consequences. “This is a country where a good prosecutor can indict a ham sandwich,” Krauthammer boasts. With a wistful reference to the tactics of the KGB, he concluded, “. . . it would be nice if people like Assange were made to worry every time they go out in the rain.”
He made no reference to the US army private who has been arrested and who actually leaked the documents. Also, he didn’t bother to explain what should be done about the distinguished newspapers that published the stuff. It appears that neo-cons believe that the Johns should go free.
Knowing that Obama is a bit vain about the rule of law, his critics know they have a stationary target. They’ll cast him as Jimmy Carter and prey that he dawns Carter’s sad severe mantle in the 2012 campaign. It is of no concern to them that America’s critics feast on their violent rhetoric. Hard power is the only power that seems to arouse them.
The more pervasive and disappointing response, however, comes from the left. Two century-old liberal institutions—The Globe and Mail in Canada and the Guardian in London—ran columns of unctuous contempt for the United States. The leaks read like a sick diary of a deranged, flailing bully.
Judith Timson in The Globe assumes a bored air in complaining about the seeming triviality of much of what was reported. That a few of the leaders who were exposed might react brutally, whether the sources were witty or not, doesn’t seem to prick her concern as a reporter who once had sources to protect. More significantly, she appropriates Hannah Arendt’s haunting description of the Holocaust, with the complaint—“talk about the banality of evil.” Diplomacy isn’t for saints or those who need their own by-lines. The diplomats and soldiers outed by Wikileaks, however, are not doing the work of the devil. (It was an heir to the British Crown, not an American diplomat, who wore an SS uniform for fun.)
Seumas Milne in the Guardian wholeheartedly upholds the motives of Wikileaks: shrink the American empire’s influence, reputation, friendships, and ability to act globally. America is not merely the most influential liberal market economy in the world. It operates an “overstretched imperial system” that has arrogated onto itself the role of world leader and police officer. The leaks reveal that the “empire” is beginning to flounder as “independent regional powers” such as China start to make their global presence felt. Click on: http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/dec/01/wikileaks-embassy-cables-us-global-power
Milne skips over the heart of the American machine: an unruly, largely amateurish electoral democracy that settles in church basements and town halls, as well as in boardrooms—exactly who will make the big and the smallest decisions in Washington. (Within the week, the Guardian will run another story about an American leviathan that can’t govern itself, let alone its puniest allies.) 
On good days, the US is a force for stability and organized progress—an ancient liberal Anglo-American dream. Assange, however, is an anarchist. And for a well-fed anarchist, weakening and shrinking the US internationally is the biggest prize of all. But surely that cannot be the biggest prize of all for a liberal of any stripe. Certainly not in a world in which at least three of the rising “independent regional powers” are aggrieved authoritarian machines that see the machinery of state as their clique’s trough or God’s handmaiden.

Thursday, November 18, 2010

Is only the flag sacred to neo-cons?

“The Fed’s pump priming addiction has got our small businesses running scared, and our allies worried. The German finance minister called the Fed’s proposals “clueless.” When Germany, a country that knows a thing or two about the dangers of inflation, warns us to think again, maybe it’s time for Chairman Bernanke to cease and desist. We don’t want temporary, artificial economic growth bought at the expense of permanently higher inflation which will erode the value of our incomes and our savings.”
—Sarah Palin’s prepared remarks on November 12th obtained by National Review Online
Two years ago, Sarah Palin claimed that she could handle foreign policy because she could see Russia across the Bering Sea. That was poorly received. But Sarah Palin at least didn’t abandon the politics of audacity.
Pundits who look for growth (or decline) in public figures suggest that she’s maturing as a politician. Today, she radiates ambition rather than innocence. But is she any closer to a brand of conservatism that could lead America during perilous times?
What is striking about her attack on the US Federal Reserve is its extravagance and premeditation. She is no longer the spiny mascot for the Tea Party but, likely, the presidential candidate-of-choice of a group of East Coast neo-cons determined to recapture the presidency—whatever the state of the union.
A few days after her speech, a group of Republican intellectuals and former office holders promptly placed an open letter in The Wall Street Journal, essentially repeating her concerns.  http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2010/11/15/open-letter-to-ben-bernanke/  
Unsurprisingly, William Kristol—the ardent wordsmith, Palin confidant, and editor of The Weekly Standard—was reported to be one of the group’s key organizers.
Both Palin’s speech and their public letter enumerated the risks entailed in expanding the money supply to encourage economic activity. Neither, however, granted the Reserve any credit for understanding those risks or possessing the means and the will to abate inflation if the economy responded too enthusiastically to easy money. They all know, despite Palin’s false sympathy for rising food prices, that there remains deep, painful slack on the supply side of the economy to absorb a resumption of consumer demand and investor confidence.  They didn’t offer any concrete ideas to launch an alternative fiscal policy to expand the economy. And, while they spoke of the importance of a stable credible dollar, both the speech and the letter invited the world to question the Federal Reserve’s competence and commitment to a sound dollar.
There isn’t a name on Kristol’s list—with the possible exception of his own—that would have any trouble corresponding directly with or talking directly to Reserve Chair Ben Bernanke about his or her concerns.
Along with Congress and the Presidency, should the Federal Reserve also be buffeted by 24-7 political spin and become a platform issue in the approaching Republican presidential primaries? For three generations of enviable growth, in America and globally, the Federal Reserve’s independence has been respected. Surely, that’s something a serious Conservative appreciates.
The Economist’s editorial of November 6th called for “urgent incrementalism” in rebalancing the world economy and sustaining economic recovery. The term won’t end up in Palin’s speeches or as a bumper sticker. Yet, it should prick the conscience of Conservative thinkers, especially those who speak for interests that have benefitted so greatly from the status quo.
William Kristol’s Harvard degree in government, however, doesn’t include personal discipline. A doctor who loves medicine can ask for your trust. A public intellectual who loves power should be watched.