Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Conservative Party. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Conservative Party. Show all posts

Thursday, July 21, 2016

Conservative Party in WASP retreat?

Under cover of his own mediocrity, Peter Mackay remains free to ponder whether once again to be an “A-team candidate” for the leadership of the Conservative Party of Canada, or to remain a passionate family man. Who would disrupt his musings by questioning his sparse declarations? Such as: “We mustn’t live in an echo-chamber” and his “We must be more inclusive”? With over 10 years of high-profile success of similar vacuities, he knows he can keep pondering for months. The Mackay family chalice of high expectations is still filled to the brim.

So, without an “A-team candidate” like Mackay to overheat our thinking or an identifiable Republican Party ideology left to contaminate Canadian discussion, let’s look at what the declared aspirants and others are already contributing to the renewal of the Conservative opposition in Canada. 

Excepting the gregarious Maxime Bernier, a Quebecois with a libertarian rather than a red-Tory touch, the other Harper Government candidates are struggling to connect empathetically to all those Conservatives who didn’t go to Trinity College, join the Albany Club in their 20s, or read Disraeli before they read Lincoln and the National Review.

The popular meme of the moment is: inclusiveness.  

“Inclusiveness” is a bloodless reference to a life-or-death fact. In order to rattle and then beat any majority government, its opposition must grow large enough to win the next election. The word “inclusiveness” should die of boredom. But the Tories still need a lot more of that growth stuff.

Nevertheless, what’s creeping back into conservative politics in Stephen Harper’s wake may not be the “inclusive” parties of Diefenbaker and the Preston Mannings, but the ethnically distinct party of that honorable gentleman Arthur Meighen, with its hamlets of self-regarding Anglophiles scattered across the old Dominion of Canada.

Harper conservatives paid their respects symbolically to the British connection while pursuing a dogged, American-inspired neo-liberal agenda. They took risks to secure a closer partnership with the whole EU, not its second-largest member.

They marketed polar democracy and laissez-faire American materialism, not the superiority of the Westminster model, to win over a decent share of first-generation new Canadians. Also, they declared that the Quebecois are a “nation within an independent Canada,” finally closing a gulf between Conservatives and Quebec dating back over 100 years.

Harper was most certainly the most American Conservative Prime Minister in history. While he got little in return from Barack Obama, his relative lack of interest in the United Kingdom further moved the Conservative Party away from its rather unlovable ethnic base.

In that context, the nostalgic outbursts of support for Brexit by the former Conservative Speaker of the House of Commons and potential “A-Team” leadership candidate Andrew Scheer—as well as Harper’s articulate former minister of Finance Joe Oliver—are bone-headed.

Both op-ed pieces in the National Post could have been written by the London pamphleteers in the “Rule Britannia” campaign against the “centralizing, bloated, unaccountable” machinery of the their democratic partners in the EU. They argue the UK can again enjoy the same “sovereign” hygienic distance from its neighbors that their forefathers legislated for Canada nearly 150 years ago.

Nostalgic Tories in Canada and in the UK dream that their countries can flourish as eminent Commonwealth powers by trading, but not become politically entangled in the supposedly unreliable, inferior, and giant federations next door.

Advocates of the American version of 19th-century nationalism are called “isolationists.” Their counterparts in Canada were known—and, if they keep it up, will be seen again—as the Crown loyalists. You, of course, remember the stereotype: fervent British Subjects who were raised to fear Catholics and Germans, and despise Jews, Muslims, Eastern Europeans, the French, and the Italians. 

They were the good people who fought the currents of liberal history for two centuries. Unfortunately, whether called “isolationists” or “loyalists,” they’re recognized by others—those millions of voters who came here from republics not enthralled by the glories of Great Britain—for their awkward, superior ways and their lack of respect for how others do politics.

They still club, but they don’t govern.

Thursday, May 15, 2014

The invention of differences in paradise

Forgetfulness about childbirth helps mothers continue to enjoy sex. And truly forgetting is liberating. On the other hand, forgetfulness about human history can lead to dead ends and trouble. Because Canada has only recently done something noteworthy on its own initiative, our forgetfulness tends to just support mediocrity and sentimentality. It’s not life-threatening. However, it does bother emigrants and irritable bloggers. 

Jeffrey Simpson is the most solid practitioner we have who writes with one foot on the data and the other on yesterday’s puffy white clouds. 

In his Globe column “A Party defined by its enemies, by choice,” Jeffrey Simpson reflected on the rupture of our political culture: from the clubby politics of our past to the divisive politics of Stephen Harper:


“This kind of political differentiation is new to Canada. Of course, there has always been political competition among parties. And of course, parties have heaped abuse on their adversaries, exaggerating their faults.

“In the past, this competition has tended to be between or among parties – a political game, if you like. But the Conservatives have now focused their sights on other institutions outside of politics to help with their strategy of differentiation.”               

If you’re going to be bitter about the present, first be bitter about the past.

Simpson ought to scan the archives of his own paper, even his own early stories, and shake himself free of the winsome spin of vanquished Liberals: the theme that public life was more gentlemanly, more responsible, when we were winning.

There were every bit as many injuries on the field when Liberals and other "nobodies" played the "political game."

Today’s Conservative PM attacks his partisan adversaries by: (1) complaining that Michael Ignatieff was working abroad for 30 years (2) attacking Stephen Dion’s written platform and his legal opinion that the Governor General, on his own council, could make him prime minister instead, and (3) marketing the notion that Justin Trudeau is shallow.

Yesterday’s Liberal PMs attacked their adversaries by: (1) claiming that they were soft on Quebec nationalists and servile toward the provinces generally, (2) dismissing New Democrats as extremists, (3) describing a Harvard economic gold-medalist Robert Stanfield’s anti-inflation suggestions as “Zap! You’re frozen,” and (4) in the '90s, dismissing Preston Manning and Stockwell Day as American right-wing puppets. They were incompetent if they couldn’t control their caucus, or bullies if they could.

(Dramatizing the awfulness of now, Liberal winners transform safely departed adversaries into public-spirited gentlemen, my first leader being designated harmlessly as “the best Prime Minister Canada never had.” Simpson sees them as “more pragmatic.”)

Simpson’s principal argument, however, is about scope: in the past, PMs were hard on other politicians, not other institutions. This is both arbitrary and, again, unfair. In fact, it implies that our politics today are more vicious and dangerous than before and that’s just crazy.

Harper’s Government has fought with public institutions — the PBO, the Chief Electoral Officer, crown agencies, regulators, political journalists, and, most famously, the Supreme Court and the Senate. Life within Harper’s Ottawa is quarrelsome and that ill-serves Harper with Canada’s peace-loving mainstream. However, is that inherently bad? Were yesterday’s political targets better able to protect themselves and less important to maintaining a tolerant democracy?

You can "savage" a young Canadian’s freedom and future prospects by throwing him in jail without a judge’s warrant, as Pierre Trudeau did in 1970. Yet are heads of public institutions, with fixed terms, public profiles, public mandates, and constitutional or Parliamentary protections, being "savaged" when Harper publicly questions their public positions?

Before political parties were subsidized — and, yes, when they were directly subsidized — monies, campaign workers, newspapers, leadership delegates, core voters, and swing voters were mobilized by fear of the other guy’s ideas and the promise of one’s own. We divided, often bitterly, on religion, the monarchy, republicanism, capitalism, socialism, the Vatican, the Cold War, US "imperialism," immigration welfare and work incentives, bilingualism, the official status of the French Language, capital gains taxes, and the character, health, and associations of our political enemies.

In Simpson’s alternative paradise, Liberals are "pragmatic" in office and their opponents are "pragmatic" once they retire. Ideology would have no place.

This is a fantasy and it's no fun. Popular democracy, most conspicuously in Quebec and the West, didn’t invent ruthless politics, divisive ideas, and ideologies. It simply let the people join in the fight. 

Wednesday, July 17, 2013

Canada’s wet Head of State


Paint dries in Canada like everywhere else. And, when it peels off, Canadians do something. Pride and the elements demand it. However, when their political institutions wear out, they play dumb or insist that their polity is still young. Canada persists as a constitutional monarchy in the midst of this change-loving continent, in large part because Canadians treat the institution like a first coat of paint.

Canada has been an appendage of the oldest constitutional monarchy in the democratic world. Canada’s British head of state has stayed in place—as a given—since Canada became a federal Dominion in 1867; it has survived—as a given—through every iteration of Canada’s constitution ever since.

The Crown has survived not because Conservatives have dominated the country’s politics or are still wedded to the Crown for urgent philosophical reasons. Their anti-republicanism today is merely an expression of Anglo nostalgia and condescension toward the United States. They wouldn’t fight hard to keep the Crown. They lost one parliamentary debate against a made-in-Canada flag in the '60s and now they keep their precious Red Ensign in their studies.

Strangely, the monarchy is safe in Canada today primarily because Liberals won’t declare themselves decisively against it.

Like Bill Clinton’s virginal relationship with marijuana, Canadian Liberals believe they can be hip and serve the Crown at the same time. They tug at the edges of our monarchial traditions. However, they’d far, far rather be Her Majesty’s council of ministers than be recognized as republicans.

Just every now and then, they remind Canadians that Conservatives are slightly too enthusiastic about the Monarchy and hint that they’re still thinking about little changes to make the country a little less so.

This week, the Globe and Mail reported that almost 20 years ago, Jean Chretien nearly agreed to champion legislation to remove the requirement that a would-be Canadian must promise to be “faithful and bear true allegiance to Queen Elizabeth the Second, Queen of Canada.” In the end, he didn’t bother: why should new Canadians not be expected to repeat a white lie that he’d repeatedly uttered for the privilege of being her faithful first minister?

Constitutionally, the Harper government has been to the left and the right of the Liberals. They’ve endorsed the “Quebecois nation” and championed an elected Senate. And, conversely, they’ve put the Crown and the Queen’s picture back on display on government property. This latter gesture has generated a brand-new word for Canadians watching Canada dry: "royalization."

The term serves Liberals and the status quo perfectly.

It marginalizes Conservatives by suggesting that they genuinely support an undemocratic, ethnically exclusive Head of State. Again, it puts Liberals nicely in the sensible center of a phony debate.

Unfortunately, the monarchy in Canada isn’t like a hemline that raises and falls according to the aesthetic tastes of the government of the day. It’s the cornerstone of a polity that is still reluctant to trust in the will of the electorate and the constitutional protections fashioned by their representatives. 

Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Can fear of change in Alberta change Canada?

Red Tories haven’t had a good election for a generation and they had every right to celebrate last night.
However, like others who weather bad times, they can be small, too. Allison Redford had good reasons to be small last night: she was expected to lose the last standing dynasty of progressive conservatism to a conservative upstart, and she had already worked for the vanquished Joe Clark and seven failed states on behalf of the UN. So, just for the record, last night, she was a little nasty.
“Every Albertan knew that this election was about choice. A choice to put up walls or to build bridges. A choice about Alberta's future,” Ms. Redford said in her victory speech. “Tonight, Alberta chose to build bridges.”
It's a gleeful iteration of a campaign of fear, but hardly a reliable guide for Western politics or the last word on her opponent, Danielle Smith.
When you’re rich and you’re thinking about throwing out a regime that’s been in office for over 40 years—and the alternative has been ahead in the polls for nearly three weeks—the alternative, not change or the brutes you’ve known for a life time, becomes the ballot issue.
Danielle Smith was crudely accused of being Sarah Palin and suspected of being easy on the Counter-Reformation and Alberta independence. These charges wouldn’t have landed, except on the CBC, if she’d had enough time to establish herself.
The last dynasty in Alberta—Social Credit, 1935 to 1971—was defeated by a Harvard MBA graduate named Peter Lougheed. He first served four years in the Alberta legislature and had the intangible benefit of carrying an honored family name that had served in Alberta public life since Confederation. Like Smith, he was also articulate, business-like, and extremely ambitious. (The moment he became premier, Lougheed became a Canadian of consequence—often praised as a statesman and, as well, suspected as a divider and extremist in Eastern Canada.)
Centrist left politics, of course, are not dead. However, their chances of making a comeback in Canadian federal politics by campaigning on fear are not validated by what just happened in Alberta.
The New Democrats, though, should feel very good about choosing Thomas Mulcair as their national leader. He didn’t have the freshest face at their leadership convention, but he has all the political experience that Danielle Smith didn’t have—and would have likely saved her campaign.
The biggest policy problem for Stephen Harper, and potentially for Canada, will be Premier Redford’s self-imposed promise of talking the rest of Canada into going along with Alberta’s energy development and fiscal priorities. Albertans haven’t gone sheepish about controlling their resource development, or soft on carbon taxes and transfer payments to Eastern Canada. Her Finance Minister has Alberta conservatives and taxpayers, not the Empire Club of Toronto, to first impress.

Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Why not a two-party democracy in Canada?

With the resurgence of the right in the West and the re-release of the Titanic in theaters everywhere, Canadian progressives—in the Liberal Party, especially—are asking: must we live through years and years of further internal and electoral attrition before Canada’s center left unites?
What are they waiting for? They say that they believe that 60% of the people want Harper out for their kind of politics. Isn’t 60% already enough of a market to unite their ambitions?
Sure, it might be easier in the future to set aside their personal differences when Harper gets even more hateful. But between us: isn’t it clear by now that Harper is trying to make Ottawa a less passionate place? And he isn’t even very inflammatory about that.
Good timing is introduced as an adult argument by those who tell others to sit still. It often disguises fear and usually inflates the procrastinator’s ability to control events.
Echoing loyalist in the Liberal Party, the Toronto Star’s columnist Tim Harper pronounced:
“Any move to unite the left will have to wait until Canadians pronounce one more time at the ballot box.”
Tim Harper is repeating, in servile terms, a desperate Toronto Liberal prayer: the people of Canada will come back to us, humble the NDP in the next election, and thereby give us our rightful place in any two-party negotiation, if any kind of accommodation is necessary to get back into power.
Two problems.
The people don’t pronounce. The next election will not make tough decisions easier for leaders or procrastinators. It could, however, take one option away from our fearful federal Liberals.
The Liberal Party could wake up after the next election further marginalized. As scenarios go, either a shaky New Democrat Government (with the support of the Greens, before or after the election) or a shaky Conservative government could be the next step on the way to a two-party, left-right parliament.
Conceivably, Canada could end up with a two-party system before the incredible intellectual capital of the Liberal Party comes to the table.

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

Great Liberals had ideas too, before they were partisans

It’s time for Canada’s Liberals to shake themselves: presently, they are only ripening in opposition, while their opponents are renewing themselves in office.  
A young conservative, not a young liberal, is likely to soon lead the fastest growing, richest, and youngest province in Canada.
Apparently, the best obstacle Liberals think they can throw in the way of Danielle Smith and the resurgent conservative movement in Alberta is the insistence that they have a “hidden agenda” and unconsciously want to be hated and laughed at after the election. It’s a tactic Liberals have honed since Preston Manning formed the Reform Party in 1987.
They’ve used this tactic so often they don’t think it’s either extreme or funny anymore. Warren Kinsella just unleashed a classic in the Toronto Sun:
Kinsella, the Inquisitor from Toronto, informs that “back then” Smith was on the far right of court activism, 2nd- and 3rd-trimester abortions, and student conduct on campuses, for instance. Now, she’s a “crafty” professional politician who says she’s pro-choice and has no intention to introduce contentious social legislation.
Kinsella calls her a liar. Albertans on the ground will make up their own minds next Monday.
Liberal Party warriors today may feel it’s clever to have zero tolerance for past political indiscretions. That it’s fair to suspect the worst of whatever is not in writing in a politician’s platform. They may be happy to settle for being Canada’s Truth Squad following—from puberty to retirement—the lively minds of their opponents.
They’ll have to accept, however, a rather mediocre future.
Would Kinsella insist that the next generation of young Liberals first be recruited and taught Liberal policies before they express political ideas on their own? Does he not worry that lurking in senior Liberal circles are a few Liberals who once uttered divisive liberal ideas in emails and campus resolutions?
A party that recruits supporters only for jobs and election parties may survive. The Liberal Party that supposedly governed naturally, however, first won majorities by attracting individuals who came to it with opinions of their own.
There wouldn’t have been a tinkle of excitement about the Trudeau Years if Trudeau and his supporters—in  the West as well as in Quebec—came to power with no strong ideas of their own. 

Monday, March 26, 2012

Two bullies building a two-party democracy for Canada?

Never has Canadian politics been so strangely and portentously aligned. Together, Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Official Opposition Leader Thomas Mulcair are truly unique.

Canada has witnessed pragmatists and intellectuals, party men and outsiders, free men and bought men, face off across the House of Commons. Never before, at one time, however, has Canadian politics been lead by two exceptionally intelligent loners, with a common vision of leadership and confidence that Canada isn’t too big to be lead by two national parties—one center right and one center left.

The right has already united and crushed the little flowers of traditional conservatism. Now, with Harper’s co-operation, Thomas Mulcair, is out to do the same on the left, over the next three or eight years.

This enterprise will unearth indignant and amusing opposition.

Core “social-democrats” will worry about sounding like Liberals, while campaigning on Barack Obama’s tax themes. They’ll argue that it’s safe to trade votes with Liberals in Ottawa backrooms but it's dangerous to campaign on the ground with other progressives in the suburbs of Toronto.

Old Liberals will argue that Canada has outgrown even the Liberal Party’s grand old big tent and that it’s pure vanity that any other tent can ever be built in its place.

That the party of Trudeau, Chretien, King, Laurier, World War Two, and the War Measures Act doesn’t really feel comfortable anymore about the prospect of strong majority governments. They call Harper an autocrat and see Canada inevitably returning to a five-party state.

As in any free country, there should be air time for a true socialist voice in Canada. That voice, however, isn’t loud enough in the New Democratic Party today to prevent the NDP from simply becoming Canada’s Democratic Party.

Mulcair should conduct himself in the North American progressive tradition and challenge all the romancing about European models of coalition democracy.