Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Pew Research Center. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pew Research Center. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

America’s pessimistic friends


Positive expectations about America’s future as well as hellish conditions at home contributed mightily to America’s appeal to immigrants, along with long queues and queue jumpers. It might, then, stand to reason that pessimism—in the right places—could save $billions and reduce those damnable queues.  

The problem, according to the highly esteemed Pew Research, is that today those who are optimistic about America are less likely to speak English and less likely to possess those skills most in demand. Canadians and Brits, on the other hand, may be easier to absorb, but are also less easy to excite.

It is arguable that what a foreigner says about the US in opinion surveys can be a reliable guide to anticipating their next move, let alone the next car they buy or movie they view. Nevertheless, the Pew findings do say strange, bad things about what others think about the US. And, in Canada and in Western Europe, those sour opinions must influence the nervous agenda-setters in their unpopular governments.

Here’s a startling Pew finding on power:

The percent that believe China “will eventually” or has “already replaced” the US as the world’s leading superpower: 50% in Mexico; 66% in Britain; and 67% in Canada. (The Chinese themselves go along with the Brits at 66%)

Here’s a Pew finding on virtue:

The percent who have a “favorable” view of the US and of China: in Mexico 66% hold a favorable view of the US and 45% hold a favorable view of China; in Britain it’s 58% for the US and 48% for China; in Canada its 64% for the US and 43% for China.

Other North Americans are easier on the US than her peevish British parent. However, Canadian pessimism toward the US, and faith in the rise of China, is extraordinary. It belies Canada’s interests, immediate circumstances, positive prospects, and supposedly sophisticated understanding of how the world works.

These abstract opinions reveal dramatically the power of arbitrary and abstract opinion-making. After 146 years as an independent neighbor, it still passes as commonsensical to write that the US is not only a competitive place to get ahead but is also governed by less civilized people and is destined to collapse. Diversifying away from their mess goes down as ambitious and prudent.

Lawrence Martin’s Globe and Mail column “As America unwinds, Canada rewinds” is a classic of fact-free, influential Canadian anti-Americanism. The US economic recovery is unquestionably more stable than China’s, and broader, cleaner, less inflationary, and based on superior growth in productivity than is the case for the little miracle to its north.

Too bad for US protectionists, for the Tea Party—and for Canadian newspaper readers—that Martin still writes in Canada and isn’t writing his warnings about America for Mexicans or Argentinians or South Koreans or Indonesians.

Friday, July 6, 2012

Rob Portman for VP: doubling down on dull


Pew Research center’s latest data on public attitudes about the 2012 presidential election confirms that this election cycle isn’t as exciting as the last; most people (56%) feel it’s dull—as they normally do months before an election year.

That’s not surprising for Americans; getting excited in elections, anyway, is the kind of thing people who speak French or Italian do—and look at the mess they’re in. However, there is a nugget in the Pew findings that Mitt Romney must now be pondering.

“Currently, 33% of Republicans say the presidential campaign is interesting down from 52% in late March (March 22-25). The share of Republicans describing this year’s campaign as dull has spiked from 42% to 60% since then. By contrast, Democrats are finding the campaign increasingly interesting as the general election gets underway. Currently, 45% say it is interesting, up from 36% in March.

“While fewer Republicans than Democrats currently say the campaign has been interesting, GOP voters are more engaged than Democratic voters in the 2012 campaign. For instance, more Republicans are giving quite a lot of thought to the election and more say it really matters who wins.”


Dull will not keep Romney out of the White House! Dull will not deter his voters. Indeed, if he’d stop making interesting mistakes, dull could actually enhance his authenticity—and partly trivialize the scary elements of his platform.

Bearing all this in mind, Rob Portman must be Romney’s vice-presidential running mate.

He’s a generic Republican, a tallish WASP, a mid-West law graduate from in-offensive Ohio. He was and remains the guy you elect as class treasurer in high school. Portman has been in Washington since 1993—as a lobbyist, congressman, Cabinet executive in the Bush presidency, and now a first-term senator. He’s been at the center of Republican decision-making for ten years. 

Despite all the temptations, he’s served the conservative cause without, yet, saying anything remarkable or against the grain. Without saying anything interesting—or disloyal—he’s readily described as very intelligent, sensible, and electable.

Portman penned his application for the vice-presidential nomination in a Fourth of July column in the Cleveland Plain Dealer. It’s a classic; it’s everything the scripters need and not one thought out of harmony.


Portman embraces every accusation about Obama’s record that has been made by Republicans in Washington and by the candidates for either job on the Republican ticket. With the pseudo-precision of a lawyer/labor market analyst, he asserts that Obama is 42% off his team’s original promise to reduce joblessness.

What should be most re-assuring to Romney, however, is that Portman can also repeat the tax, fiscal, and social policy positions of Paul Ryan, Mitch McConnell, and the Tea Party—and sound as reasonable as those Mid-west Republicans who a generation ago were trusted to stay away from the extremes.

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

America: a 50/50 democracy or just half crazy?

Liberal and foreign pundits have made up their minds: Today’s Republican Party is either suicidal or crazy. In winning so many fights with Democrats over the last year, they’ve lost their reason. They will blow next year’s presidential election by nominating a dim, offensive, or unsound nominee.
“Republicans want anyone but the pragmatist” writes Jeffrey Simpson in the Globe and Mail. They hate Obama “with a frenzied passion,” and, so, can’t think straight. Maclean’s magazine headlines its analysis of the Republican primary race with “American idiots: Gaffes, mistakes, scandals and humiliation.” The Toronto Star’s, Heather Mallick’s verdict: “The Republican catastrophe has been their faith in ideology over effectiveness. They would rather break than bend.”
The above Canadian observers only report what American pessimists say about themselves.  
The Economist’s Lexington column offers a nuanced, hopeful note. It ends a damning profile of Newt Gingrich by saying, “Unless they are feeling particularly suicidal, the Republicans will reject him, just as they have rejected Mr Perry and the Mr Cain."
The Republican Party had over 30 million members in 2008 and will have more by the end of the presidential primaries in 2012. With a base larger than the adult population of California or Canada—a base lovingly monitored by the press—it is certain that many silly, crazy, and mean things will be reported, worldwide.
However, the Republican Party is not a cult: it doesn’t practice frenzied rituals in secret cells or ignore what others think. Despite its noisy romantics, it’s still conservative because it’s heavily invested in the status quo—it’s mainstream plus.
Republican voters are older, whiter, more affluent, more likely to have completed four years in college and have kids living at home than typical Democrats. They have a winner’s stake in the existing order—a pro-business climate and a public sector financially strong enough to keep them safe and to provide generous support for seniors and for their school-age kids. They pay more taxes than the poor and get far more out of government as well.
The dearest hope of Manhattan and Hollywood Democrats is that the Republican Party will nominate a goofy candidate and, with their powdered wigs, muskets, handguns, and Confederate flags, they’ll agree to pose for a group photo for National Lampoon.
(Again, Obama relies less on hope than they would like. He’s assuming they’ll elect Mitt Romney or, if not Mitt Romney, someone who will try carefully to tailor his message in order to win next fall’s election.)
Of course, Republicans can miscalculate, especially when they’re out of power and facing a still popular opponent. Their ideal presidential candidate probably decided too early to defer to Obama; being a loosely managed human institution, the Republican convention could mistakenly pick a dud.  
Yet, as The Economist noted, so far Republicans have reacted to bad news in a brutally rational fashion. The undeserving high profiles that were granted Sarah Palin, Michele
Bachmann, Rick Perry, and Herman Cain drove up their polling numbers in the Republican Party—and then news of their flaws and shortcomings drove their numbers down just as fast.

Friday, August 5, 2011

Friday wrap-up: talk economics, seriously

The debt-ceiling deal may not have lasting economic significance. After all, it doesn’t bind the future where it’s supposed to do the heavy lifting. The debt-ceiling debate, however, may have changed American politics. The politicians looked terrible but may not be able to change the subject get Americans excited about something else.

The Pew Research Center for the People and the Press released an extraordinary set of findings on public participation and interest in news coverage of the debt-ceiling debate.


Forty-one percent of Americans were “very closely” following the drama in Washington last weekend. The debate beat out the economy generally, the Norway massacre, the NFL labor agreement, the stock market, and the 2012 elections. Amazingly, 10% of those surveyed said they bothered to contact an elected official on the federal deficit. Furthermore, those who were most interested and most likely to weigh in fell equally on both ends of the political spectrum. Twelve percent of conservative Republicans and 14% of liberal Democrats say they contacted their representatives.

The vast majority, likely, after many hours of watching television and reading press reports, didn’t go to bed meekly regretting their economic illiteracy; they felt sure enough about what was going on to volunteer that their politicians were “ridiculous” and “disgusting.”

Effectively, Americans have experienced another national trauma. It’s too early, of course, to say anything with confidence, but there surely will be consequences—in politics and in the economy. Here are three bald assertions:

One: Washington’s perceived economic incompetence is a critical economic factor, it affects consumer and investor behavior.

It matters when people stop trusting banks and the stock markets, and it matters as well when they think Washington is incapable of offering coherent economic leadership. (Is there any point increasing public borrowing to stimulate consumer demand if consumers respond by saving more because they fear that $trillion deficits will break the economy?)

Two: simple economic slogans won’t get you elected.

People may or may not be polarized. However, they are now intensely interested in economic issues and have been exposed to many points of view on what should be done. They didn’t tell the Pew Center that Washington politicians were ridiculous because they didn’t use the right sound bites, but because sound bites were all the politicians had to offer. Promises like “jobs, jobs, jobs” and “cut, cap, and balance” and retorts like “job-killing taxes” and “fair shares from millionaires and billionaires” won’t work with the un-indoctrinated.

Three: the public watched what was happening because they know that what leaders do still counts.

The Iraq War led to severe voter remorse in 2006 and 2008. People didn’t turn their backs on the world then and they are not going to try to fix the economy without a competent federal government.

Democratizing elite policy-making has been America’s unique political dynamic. It has worried the world for over a century. However, as often as not, in foreign as well as domestic affairs, the final verdict of the people has favored enlightened American self-interest. But, nothing’s a sure thing.

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

Obama’s Libya speech: selling multilateralism at home and America abroad

Obama takes his time to express himself and irrevocably commit himself politically. He’s been called a follower on healthcare and the deficit and, over the last few weeks, on Libya. However, these three challenges all require co-operation with others—others who like to get attention as well. Managing multi-party relations makes grandstanding counter-productive. Fortunately for Obama the storyteller formally addressing Libya after much of the dust has settled allowed him to bolster his new foreign policy with concrete success on the ground.
Obama has transferred military responsibility to a competent alliance, strengthened a comprehensive economic boycott of Libya and, of more broad importance, turned America into a potential friend rather than an alien fiend amongst young Arabs.
NATO is now accountable for grinding down Kadhafi’s military power and political credibility. NATO may not sound as sexy as “Desert Storm.” However, it is dogged and it is the most successful military alliance of the last two centuries. Lines in the desert may move back and forth for awhile but a stalemate is unlikely.
Obama made it clear that the US and the alliance want to force Kadhafi out of power. The steady application of military and economic pressure should work. It doesn’t really matter whether Kadhafi is insane or wily. No governing machine that has enjoyed and indulged in power for over 40 years can survive for long without large, fresh supplies of cash and reasonable assurance of future personal security. Old favours and sentiment will not for long protect Kadhafi and his inner circle when everyone else’s interests lie elsewhere.
Obama offered a vivid illustration of how pleasant it is to be using force the way others want:   
“Of course, even when we act as part of a coalition, the risks of any military action will be high.  Those risks were realized when one of our planes malfunctioned over Libya.  Yet when one of our airmen parachuted to the ground, in a country whose leader has so often demonized the United States –- in a region that has such a difficult history with our country –- this American did not find enemies.  Instead, he was met by people who embraced him.  One young Libyan who came to his aid said, “We are your friends.  We are so grateful to those men who are protecting the skies.”
Finally, Obama’s more modest approach to the exercise of American power doesn’t seem any longer to be that alien to Americans. Before his speech, The Pew Research Centre found:
Notably, most people do not view the United States as the lead actor in the military operation. Fully 57% say that the United States “is just one of a coalition of countries” involved in the military mission; far fewer (35%) say the United States “is leading the military action.”`

Thursday, November 4, 2010

Cap-and-trade legislation: saving the world in camera

Here are three quotes from a superb story by Ryan Lizza on the failed machinations of three Senators, the White House, and policy lobbyists to design a passable program to reduce US carbon dioxide emissions by 17 per cent by 2020. The focus of their efforts was the design of a cap-and-trade mechanism for the American economy.

“[American Petroleum Institute] would not run ads, they would not lobby members of Congress, and they would not refer to our bill as a carbon tax.” At another meeting, the three senators and the heads of the three oil companies discussed a phrase they could all use to market the policy: a “fee on polluters.”“According to people at the meeting, the White House aides and some of the environmentalists, including Carl Pope, the chairman of the Sierra Club, expressed their contempt for the linked fee [oil refineries would pay a fee linked to the average price of carbon over 3 months]: even if it was a fine idea on the merits, it was political poison.”
“The environmental community and the White House, which rarely weighed in on its policy preferences, thought the linked fee was disastrous because it would inevitably be labelled a “gas tax.” At one meeting, Joe Aldy, a staffer on Obama’s National Economic Council, advised Kerry, Graham, and Lieberman’s staffers to kill it.”
—Ryan Lizza, “As the World Burns”, The New Yorker, October 11, 2010
It’s brutally obvious that the environmental movement’s preference for a cap-and-trade regime was politically opportunistic, even while the opportunity had passed. The ease with which its labyrinth of rules could be gamed by special pleaders was of little concern. Its beauty was reflected in what it appeared not to be—in an untruth: that cutting emissions and raising the cost of energy wouldn’t tax consumers, that you could phase out the blessings of coal to coal states and leave them as blessed as ever.
There has been much fruitful interchange between environmentalists and economists, but in designing the cap-and-trade mechanism, they showed only passing respect for the integrity of either discipline. While the “trade” part was allegedly intended to facilitate the most efficient allocation of resources, everyone schemed to ensure that government, congress, and regulators—not the market—would finesse, in detail, how trading in carbon credits would work and what we would end up paying.
For environmentalists worried about public opinion, the only virtue of such a regime over a straightforward and firm carbon tax was that it wasn’t straightforward or firm.
It’s at least reassuring to know that three Senators, executive officials, and lobbyists are still trying to make history and are obviously highly motivated to find those compromises that allow significant change to take place. However, climate change advocates (as other radicals in the past) have to accept that you can’t outsmart the status quo alone in the corridors of power. (Lizza noted that last January the Pew Research Center found Americans ranked the importance of climate change as 21st on a list of 21.)
As a participatory democrat, it is no wonder President Obama let the venture fail. With popular support you can pass a badly compromised bill and leave time to fix the details. Without popular support—including seeing the costs along with a shiny future—politicians keep their heads down and won’t ask the best of each other.