Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Heather Mallick. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Heather Mallick. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

America: a 50/50 democracy or just half crazy?

Liberal and foreign pundits have made up their minds: Today’s Republican Party is either suicidal or crazy. In winning so many fights with Democrats over the last year, they’ve lost their reason. They will blow next year’s presidential election by nominating a dim, offensive, or unsound nominee.
“Republicans want anyone but the pragmatist” writes Jeffrey Simpson in the Globe and Mail. They hate Obama “with a frenzied passion,” and, so, can’t think straight. Maclean’s magazine headlines its analysis of the Republican primary race with “American idiots: Gaffes, mistakes, scandals and humiliation.” The Toronto Star’s, Heather Mallick’s verdict: “The Republican catastrophe has been their faith in ideology over effectiveness. They would rather break than bend.”
The above Canadian observers only report what American pessimists say about themselves.  
The Economist’s Lexington column offers a nuanced, hopeful note. It ends a damning profile of Newt Gingrich by saying, “Unless they are feeling particularly suicidal, the Republicans will reject him, just as they have rejected Mr Perry and the Mr Cain."
The Republican Party had over 30 million members in 2008 and will have more by the end of the presidential primaries in 2012. With a base larger than the adult population of California or Canada—a base lovingly monitored by the press—it is certain that many silly, crazy, and mean things will be reported, worldwide.
However, the Republican Party is not a cult: it doesn’t practice frenzied rituals in secret cells or ignore what others think. Despite its noisy romantics, it’s still conservative because it’s heavily invested in the status quo—it’s mainstream plus.
Republican voters are older, whiter, more affluent, more likely to have completed four years in college and have kids living at home than typical Democrats. They have a winner’s stake in the existing order—a pro-business climate and a public sector financially strong enough to keep them safe and to provide generous support for seniors and for their school-age kids. They pay more taxes than the poor and get far more out of government as well.
The dearest hope of Manhattan and Hollywood Democrats is that the Republican Party will nominate a goofy candidate and, with their powdered wigs, muskets, handguns, and Confederate flags, they’ll agree to pose for a group photo for National Lampoon.
(Again, Obama relies less on hope than they would like. He’s assuming they’ll elect Mitt Romney or, if not Mitt Romney, someone who will try carefully to tailor his message in order to win next fall’s election.)
Of course, Republicans can miscalculate, especially when they’re out of power and facing a still popular opponent. Their ideal presidential candidate probably decided too early to defer to Obama; being a loosely managed human institution, the Republican convention could mistakenly pick a dud.  
Yet, as The Economist noted, so far Republicans have reacted to bad news in a brutally rational fashion. The undeserving high profiles that were granted Sarah Palin, Michele
Bachmann, Rick Perry, and Herman Cain drove up their polling numbers in the Republican Party—and then news of their flaws and shortcomings drove their numbers down just as fast.

Friday, October 29, 2010

The other guy’s hate and rage

“Fifty-three per cent isn’t a good turnout (Toronto municipal election) — it’s time to swallow our pride and start either paying citizens to vote or mandating that they do — but it does mean that the voters who decided the election were positively tattooed with rage.”
-Heather Mallick, “Voters were filled with largely pointless rage,” Toronto Star, October 27, 2010 

It’s the rage these days to find consolation in electoral defeat by doubting the mental health of the electorate.  Maybe, it has something to do with a waning enthusiasm for the fight or it’s a clever strategy to discredit opponents when they win.  As a young lefty long ago myself, I’m attracted to the latter.  In any event, the easy suggestion that anyone to the right of Paul Martin Junior must be either brain dead or full of hate and rage should be called out.
The favoured targets of the moment are Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Rob Ford, the mayor-elect of Toronto as well as those who voted for them. One is an overweight introvert and the other is a fat big talker. Both can embarrass. But, does the Prime Minister survive merely on hate and hinterland paranoia? Was the mayor elected by hundreds of thousands of raging bigots? After a quick scan of the post election media, friends at Starbucks, and the positive reception to Lawrence Martin’s biography, Harperland: The Politics of Control, you would think that both men personalize and profit from a deep distemper in Canadian politics.
Whatever you call it, it isn’t new. Liberal partisans and progressives should know that there is nothing novel or particularly Albertan about “hating” Liberals. Red-Tories and New Democrats—when together in opposition, drinking beer at the Press Club—heartily loathed the “natural governing party”.  For its part, the leadership of that party raged about vile separatists year in and year out, from coast to coast, for the last forty years.  Lawrence Martin reports that Harper resents the way the Reform Party was treated by the Liberals in the 1990’s. Wow!  You don’t have to be a paranoid to recall that Preston Manning and the Reform Party were savagely branded as un-Canadian Republican stooges.
How we feel about any politician driven by an abiding determination to “get even” often depends on whether we are on his side or not. Along with Nixon and likely Harper, the Kennedy boys, Winston Churchill, Bill Clinton and Jean Chretien were also motivated by and, in crisis, sustained by pride and righteous competitiveness.
The appeal of an awkward everyman like Rob Ford is not easy to define and usually impossible to anticipate. However, his use of the anachronism “oriental” and his observation that the city is strained by the recent volume of immigration doesn’t make him or his appeal racist. Those who voted to “stop the gravy train” may be disruptive, but let’s not confuse that with unthinking rage.