Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Bowles-Simpson Commission. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bowles-Simpson Commission. Show all posts

Thursday, June 7, 2012

Move on liberals: the number 99 died in Wisconsin



The Wisconsin recall election of Governor Scott Walker was concocted by liberal Democrats and was to be a liberal’s dream come true.

There wasn’t a charismatic politician on the right, a personal or religious scandal to cloud the issue. Months of debate were conducted about union rights and the management of the state’s financial affairs. Each side had plenty enough money, campaign professionals, and neighborhood volunteers to get their message out, and repeat their message over and over.

Nothing is airtight in politics. Some voters didn’t think a recall election was justified in the first place. However, a strong majority voted to keep Walker as governor and, according to CNN exit polls, a good half of those voting openly supported his legislation to restrain the public payroll and the power of public sector unions.

Walker didn’t just complain about greedy unions. He severely reduced their rights and their financial capacity to advance their interests in the future. Liberals asked voters to side with the unions—to stand as 99 per centers. They declined.

Walker, of course, didn’t settle the issue for all time, for Wisconsin, or for America. However, his re-election does demonstrate that middle-class America is not of one mind on bread-and-butter issues and will not automatically unite with liberals, even when conservatives aren’t messing up their heads with religious and patriotic gimmicks.

Liberal Dean Bakolpoulos in Salon isn’t yet ready to learn anything from what happened:

“If Barack Obama plans to win in November, he needs to unite two factions of the Rust Belt population: The middle-class of public workers and union members and teachers, and the other middle-class, which ranges from self-made entrepreneurs to struggling service industry workers. How does he do it? With an honest message that points to the real villain: An increasingly greedy corporate culture that stops at nothing in its quest to consolidate power and wealth.

“There is, in fact, a 99 percent in this country. But right now, a big chunk of it votes in the interest of the 1 percent.”


Barack Obama has had the good sense to reject this advice. He hasn’t singled out the 1 percent as villains—or their wealth as the salvation of all America’s problems.

To redress the federal government’s structural deficit, he has frozen federal salaries, endorsed in principle the Bowles-Simpson recommendations, and he has offered a “grand bargain” that would accept as much as three times more in federal spending cuts as in new taxes.

Obama and fellow Democrat pragmatists in state governments today didn’t create all the unfunded liabilities of federal and state governments. They needn’t defend past excesses. Liberals in office, like popes, make mistakes and needn’t treat what they have inherited as infallible.

America without strong unions would become an even tougher place to live. However, the middle class will not buy the argument that the ambitions of public unions and their ambitions are always the same.

If pro-union policies by public employers were invariably in the best interests of the middle class and the less so, states like Illinois, for instance, wouldn’t have an unfunded liability of $83-billion in public employee pensions.



Keynes wasn’t a Keynesian every time he saw a tough problem. He would have collected necessary taxes to pay for all operating expenses, including salaries and benefits—and accounted for how future liabilities would be met.

When the interests of the middle class and positive government are aligned, they will vote for “tax and spend” liberals. When liberals believe in what they’re doing in government, they should ask for the money.

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Tax cut “certainty” and economic growth

Keeping their campaigns for the Presidency uncontaminated by the compromisers in Washington, Sarah Palin and Mitt Romney have chosen to reject the Obama-McConnell $858 billion tax package because its income tax cuts are “temporary.”
Compared to all the terrible things that have been said about the fiscal policy of the US government this insult “temporary” is pretty feeble. It doesn’t touch “voodoo economics” of the Reagan era or, in fact, Romney’s observation last week that “we are already drowning in debt.”
By the end of next year, we may all look back fondly at a time when we could complain: I’m not certain the good news will last.
Indeed, it’s the level of certainty around right now may that may prove to be extravagant. Not a soul running for national office or on late night television questions the left-right consensus that taxes on middle class working families, small businesses, farmers and risk-takers can’t go up. All the while, average Americans consume fifty percent more in government services than they pay for.
 Democrat spokespersons suck it up and insist that the 5% tax cut they gave the rich can’t be permanent because it’s wrong. Their metric of statesmanship in these unparalleled times is Bill Clinton’s boom-time fiscal policy of the late 1990s. They imagine girding themselves to fight the same campaign in 2012.
This 5% debate about 2% of American tax payers, however, is trivial when put against the $4 trillion fiscal hole identified by the Bowles-Simpson Commission on fiscal responsibility. Wall Street has been thriving on temporary tax cuts. But it is taking note of the observation last week by Moody’s Investors Service Inc. that the widening federal deficit may soon jeopardize the United States credit rating. The uncertainty that would launch would even give Sarah Palin’s twitter a pause. Click on: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/us-tax-plan-threatens-top-credit-rating/article1836299/

                        Countries with a 'triple-A' credit rating

  • Australia
  • Austria
  • Canada
  • Denmark
  • Finland
  • France
  • Germany
  • Luxembourg
  • Netherlands
  • New Zealand
  • Norway
  • Singapore
  • Sweden
  • Switzerland
  • United Kingdom
  • United States
Source: Moody's Investors Service
Along with governments financing themselves responsibly, a broad level of confidence in the social-economic environment is vital in a free market economy. However, that doesn’t stand or fall on a few tax points. And the fundamentals of a positive business climate are safely in place. The public’s commitment to free enterprise is as strong as ever. The world community continues to support freer trade. Both US national parties are committed to a private sector-based recovery. In fact, the Obama stimulus program (that was launched without a single Republican vote) has expanded private sector growth and allowed public sector employment to shrink. Click on: http://yglesias.thinkprogress.org/2010/11/the-conservative-recovery/
There are no influential socialists in Washington or anywhere else in the US, except possibly in communes in upstate New York or in Glenn Beck focus groups.
One of the stark differences between the political climate of the Great Depression and the recent severe recession is the degree of public support today for policies to restore, not replace, the private sector.  The hindsight movement, the so-called Tea Party, complains that the bail-outs were unnecessary, not that Washington missed a chance to nationalize the commanding heights of the economy—exactly what was done in half of Europe in the 1930s.
What is now in question is not the resilience of markets but the spine of democratic politicians. Legislation on taxes and everything else is inherently temporary. However, failing to restore the US federal government’s fiscal credibility will lead to very long-term and pervasive pain. And there won’t necessarily be a count-down.