Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label The New Yorker. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The New Yorker. Show all posts

Monday, August 13, 2012

Paul Ryan: take him very seriously, seriously!


Although Paul Ryan’s nomination was bold news on Saturday, there won’t be any of the drama that Sarah Palin generated four years ago. Sole shareholder Mitt Romney will have no trouble running the whole show. Idealistic, high-spirited Paul Ryan has been managed by his Republican elders ever since he left college.

Laid-back George W. Bush certainly didn’t have any problem running a White House full of political and campaign “giants.” Apparently, for eight years, Bush delighted in calling Vice President Dick Cheney “Big Time.” Advisor Karl Rove, the strategist that billionaires still believe walks on water, answered to the nicknames “Boy Genius” or “Turd Blossom.”

It’s too early to guess what will stick to Paul Ryan. Sooner or later, however, he’ll get tagged with a nickname more telling than “policy wonk” and less confusing than “young Republican intellectual.”

Just because he has a shallow sense of humor doesn’t mean Romney—and the rest of us—need to take Paul Ryan entirely seriously.

Isn’t there something wonderfully funny about this observation by Ryan’s New Yorker biographer Ryan Lizza about his 2010 “Road Map” fiscal plan?

“The document’s introduction referred to the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, the Federalist Papers, Hayek, Friedman, Adam Smith, Max Weber, Émile Durkheim, John Locke, Alexis de Tocqueville, Georges-Eugène Sorel, Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, Charles Murray, and Niall Ferguson. Ryan himself seemed intent on entering the canon. ‘Only by taking responsibility for oneself, to the greatest extent possible, can one ever be free,' he wrote, ‘and only a free person can make responsible choices—between right and wrong, saving and spending, giving or taking.’’’

Without mentioning Russia’s Ayn Rand, his boyhood crush, he drops the names of nine European intellectuals in a document designed to stop Barack Obama turning America into another European moral and economic swamp.

Young Congressman Ryan insists that to be free, one must take “responsibility for oneself, to the greatest extent possible.” In his cramped world, however, he’s had to make his way—and find his space—within his family business, within his family compound, with his family contacts, within the family’s politics, and in his family’s faith.

He must have read Atlas Shrugged secretly in his bedroom, with a flashlight.

Clearly, he’s exactly the kind of existential free-wheeler that family man Mitt Romney needn’t worry about.

Ryan may make Republican economics a self-defeating election issue. But neither one of them, nor the Romney-Ryan ticket, will capture the fascination Americans still have with Barack Obama.

Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Canada—where fed-up Malcolm Gladwell will go to relax?


Malcolm Gladwell’s success as a Canadian-born, best-selling, Manhattan author and regular New Yorker writer is celebrated in Canada. He can get Americans to buy new ideas and has coined popular explanations (“Tipping Point” and “Blink”) for change and success in American society—polemical skills Canadians don’t expect to see very often in fellow Canadians. He has made us proud.
Nevertheless, his melodramatic and teasing rationale for coming home is embarrassing.
Ian Bailey, while introducing his weekend Globe and Mail interview with Gladwell, highlighted that Gladwell would discuss his new book on the uses and abuses of power, the Occupy movement and “what might make him grab his Canadian passport and head back home for good.” 
Wow. What would drive a such a winner to take refuge in Canada? Here’s what we’re told:
           “You point out that most of politics is tweaking. Do you see that changing?
“Increasingly now, there are these situations where something more is demanded. I don't know whether you can tweak your way out of the euro. I think maybe you have to blow up the euro and that demands a very different mindset. It may have been that was a completely misbegotten experiment, and that it will cost all of Europe in the end and maybe something radical is demanded. And the health-care system in America, I think, is so ill at the moment. I think it, too, needs to be blown up. I don't think it can be tweaked.
“Despite health-care reform?
“Yeah, I actually think health-care reform was too timid. So there are a handful of areas where problems are so intractable that I think, maybe, you need some more revolutionary vision. We have gone beyond the realm of the tweaker who is at least someone who gets things done.
“Where do you see that going?
“I don't know. I see myself taking my Canadian passport and coming home.”
It’s easy to be a big thinker: you get excited; you tell us that we should blow up the euro or the biggest healthcare regime in the world; you scan the channels for news that the revolution is happening; by Friday, you lose patience—and, without blinking, head back to Canada.  
America is full of losers, but not as many quitters.
What is Canada’s appeal? Is its genius simply not stirring up radical ideas in the first place? Allowing quitters and patriots to console one another?
Maybe, Gladwell’s motives are deeper, profoundly pessimistic and quintessentially Canadian. He maybe genuinely believes that America is ungovernable and on the edge of collapse. (There’s a sentiment that won’t get him thrown out of any of the top parlors in Toronto.) However, leaving Toronto readers with the idea that he’d come home to feel safe is delusional.  
A few New Yorkers and many Torontonians share a vain proposition: they can side-step the mess on their continent. They think of their cities as island civilizations—diversified globally and with plenty of brands of their own. In truth, at their best, both cities are indebted to and dependent on the vitality and wisdom of the mainland—and its system of popular government.
Not having the vote in next year’s American showdown simply makes it easier to sit on your hands in Toronto.

Thursday, July 21, 2011

Obama’s passion gap

George Packer delivered a bitter assault on the competence of Barack Obama’s presidency in the influential “Talk of the Town” section of The New Yorker. He elevated the standard liberal frustration—the President’s “fire in the belly” problem—by saying worse things about others, invoking the pain of unemployed individuals that Obama can’t help, and quoting the famously scientific 19th Century European political thinker Max Weber. 

“On its own, the ethic of responsibility can become a devotion to technically correct procedure, while the ethic of ultimate ends can become fanaticism. Weber’s terms perfectly capture the toxic dynamic between the President, who takes responsibility as an end in itself, and the Republicans in Congress, who are destructively consumed with their own dogma. Neither side can be said to possess what Weber calls a “leader’s personality.” Responsibility without conviction is weak, but it is sane. Conviction without responsibility, in the current incarnation of the Republican Party, is raving mad.”

Read more www.newyorker.com/talk/comment/2011/07/25/110725taco_talk_packer#ixzz1SeU3bUUH

The serious target of this extravagant indictment is clearly the President. The Republican Party is not of one mind. Try to imagine Sarah Palin and Mitch McConnell finishing each other’s sentences. Republicans recklessly over play their hand. Obama apparently doesn’t even have his heart in the game.

Packer’s case against him is personal: Obama seems determined to do his best within the bounds of Washington’s divided-government and doesn’t try to escape that reality with sufficient rhetorical verve:

“More important, he no longer uses his office’s most powerful tool, rhetorical suasion, to keep the country focused on the continued need for government activism.”

This fundamentally understates what Packer actually wants him to do and overstates the use of rhetoric to do the job. Packer wants the center of opinion in the country to shift far enough to the left that Obama can get his way on policy with a hostile Congress.

The center of public opinion is deeply ambivalent about the virtue of debt- financed government intervention. It can shift in favour a little more government leadership and, for the sake of a faster recovery, it probably should.  However, trying to hasten that process now with florid presidential rhetoric would be self-defeating.

Any success would be entirely speculative. Republican activists will continue to drive the primary process—the process that disciplines the president’s recalcitrant Washington opponents. The undecided voters that Obama needs won’t have a ballot to confirm what they think for another fifteen months. That’s a long time to wait for crowd reaction and policy progress.  

Of course, it would be more exciting if Obama dropped his reputation for being “more reasonable” than his adversaries and deployed a winner-take-all inspirational style. However, that would only deepen paralysis in Washington and feed the suspicion that he’s more articulate than effective.

The crucial problem with Packer’s thesis, however, is the contention that inspirational White House rhetoric can change the way the people think and, in doing so, can change circumstances on the ground.

Teddy Roosevelt coined the phrase “bully-pulpit” but never enjoyed the right circumstances to make it work. His theatrical competitor Winston Churchill appeared to use words to vastly great effect while TR ended his public career as a rather windy crank.  Yet, it was only during an extraordinary period in history that Churchill truly inspired. In the late spring and summer of 1940, he and his listeners agreed, finally, on the nature of the problem and necessity to act.   

Reading the facts responsibly did not encumber Churchill’s rhetoric. Luftwaffe planes over the night skies of London established Churchill as Britain’s greatest realist and that allowed him to be heard by everyone. Theories about military deterrence didn’t work for Churchill and economic arguments will not create a national consensus for Obama.

For a generation, Churchill had been recognized as a great wordsmith, while his political influence faded. He inspired a nation in 1940 because no one questioned his definition of the task before them. It would have only been embarrassing if he’d given “his blood, sweat and tears speech” a year earlier.

Conviction, without good timing, makes people look away rather than leap to their feet.