Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label immigration policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label immigration policy. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

America’s pessimistic friends


Positive expectations about America’s future as well as hellish conditions at home contributed mightily to America’s appeal to immigrants, along with long queues and queue jumpers. It might, then, stand to reason that pessimism—in the right places—could save $billions and reduce those damnable queues.  

The problem, according to the highly esteemed Pew Research, is that today those who are optimistic about America are less likely to speak English and less likely to possess those skills most in demand. Canadians and Brits, on the other hand, may be easier to absorb, but are also less easy to excite.

It is arguable that what a foreigner says about the US in opinion surveys can be a reliable guide to anticipating their next move, let alone the next car they buy or movie they view. Nevertheless, the Pew findings do say strange, bad things about what others think about the US. And, in Canada and in Western Europe, those sour opinions must influence the nervous agenda-setters in their unpopular governments.

Here’s a startling Pew finding on power:

The percent that believe China “will eventually” or has “already replaced” the US as the world’s leading superpower: 50% in Mexico; 66% in Britain; and 67% in Canada. (The Chinese themselves go along with the Brits at 66%)

Here’s a Pew finding on virtue:

The percent who have a “favorable” view of the US and of China: in Mexico 66% hold a favorable view of the US and 45% hold a favorable view of China; in Britain it’s 58% for the US and 48% for China; in Canada its 64% for the US and 43% for China.

Other North Americans are easier on the US than her peevish British parent. However, Canadian pessimism toward the US, and faith in the rise of China, is extraordinary. It belies Canada’s interests, immediate circumstances, positive prospects, and supposedly sophisticated understanding of how the world works.

These abstract opinions reveal dramatically the power of arbitrary and abstract opinion-making. After 146 years as an independent neighbor, it still passes as commonsensical to write that the US is not only a competitive place to get ahead but is also governed by less civilized people and is destined to collapse. Diversifying away from their mess goes down as ambitious and prudent.

Lawrence Martin’s Globe and Mail column “As America unwinds, Canada rewinds” is a classic of fact-free, influential Canadian anti-Americanism. The US economic recovery is unquestionably more stable than China’s, and broader, cleaner, less inflationary, and based on superior growth in productivity than is the case for the little miracle to its north.

Too bad for US protectionists, for the Tea Party—and for Canadian newspaper readers—that Martin still writes in Canada and isn’t writing his warnings about America for Mexicans or Argentinians or South Koreans or Indonesians.

Monday, August 20, 2012

Harper federalists: Preparing for Marois’s bluff

It’s the most exciting assignment a senior official can land: preparing strategies on how federal institutions should respond to an immanent threat by separatists. In the first instance, the advice is for the PM’s eyes only; it tells him how to lead a threatened federation. It’s dramatic; your drafts go with you when you retire to write your memoirs.

With the leader of the Party Quebecois Pauline Marois ahead in the polls in the Quebec election, it’s unsurprising to learn from John Ibbitson of the Globe and Mail that Harper’s team has already fleshed out responses A through B.

The brainy dramatists around a fresh Marois government will make a series of individual constitutional demands. They assume that Harper will reject them, thereby fueling Quebec alienation and separatist sympathies. Specifically, they’ll call for complete control by Quebec of unemployment insurance, culture, communications, and immigration programs and policies—all acknowledged today as constitutional activities of the federal government.

According to federal officials who are not authorized to speak publicaly, Harper will remain the steadfast, ugly target he is right now:

“To these and any other demands Stephen Harper will just say no. The Prime Minister will declare that he has no mandate from the Canadian people to negotiate with a separatist government over a series of measures that would lead to the slow-motion breakup of the country.

“He will say as well that the Conservative government remains focused on the economy: on creating jobs, improving productivity, expanding trade and eliminating the deficit. He will urge the government in Quebec to do likewise. This is Plan A.”

As pre-election federalist spin—which this "leak" may well be—it has a certain brutish logic: tell Quebeckers that PQ games are a waste of time. Unfortunately, it also protects Marois from substantive questions in Quebec about what’s best for Quebec.

Why make Harper’s temperament the issue before any of these demands have won informed support amongst Quebeckers? Why must Harper first stand up for Canada? Why should he appear to fear what Quebeckers may think of these ideas in the first place?

It’s sexy for prime ministers to look stout-hearted against dangerous ideas. However, Marois proposals to expand Quebec’s “toolkit” can as easily be characterized as insincere, self-defeating bluff.

Might it not be best for Harper to improve his ability to explain himself everywhere rather than have his presumed opposition used to glamorize weak ideas by his opponents?
           
If the PQ does win, Harper might consider first just being curious about what Marois has in mind. Since the powers she says she wants are incontestably within the federal jurisdiction now, why shouldn’t the federal government consult with Quebeckers directly?

Why not ask Quebec unions and employer groups whether they really want their own unemployment insurance program and, then, how they’d like to administer and pay for it?   

Why not ask Quebec’s arts community directly whether they’d like Ottawa to stop funding arts projects entirely and whether they’d rather only lobby Quebec City for support?

Do Quebec employers and citizens' groups want the Quebec government to create a “Quebec citizen” who could visit the rest of Canada, but wouldn’t be a registered landed immigrant to Canada? Do Quebeckers want to try to sell Quebec internationally as a place to live and work, without being eligible to become Canadian?

A Canadian federalist can ask these questions sincerely. The PQ’s latest demands wouldn’t necessarily lead to the “slow motion break-up of Canada”. It wouldn’t be hard to argue, however, that they’d make government in Quebec more expensive and more centralized, and Quebec less attractive internationally.