Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Sierra Club. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sierra Club. Show all posts

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Canadian environmentalists bet against trade and innovation

There something funny and false about the logic of arguing for the environment while dismissing the benefits of freer markets and technological innovation. Environmentalists too often use science, including economic analysis, selectively, invoking it’s authority to protect wildlife while ignoring its value to human beings.

The Pembina Institute, a go-to Calgary-based environmental think tank, defends the Ontario Government’s renewable energy program of promoting wind and solar power by offering developers long term power contracts at 2 to 5 times prevailing market prices. Pembina's defense rests on one grim assumption: all other future sources of power will be vastly more expensive as well. The Feed in Tariff (FIT) program won’t hurt too much because eventually everything else will hurt a lot more as well. Click on: https://secure.globeadvisor.com/servlet/ArticleNews/story/gam/20110706/RBBIGTICKER0607ATL

Their reasoning will give comfort to governments that think they know where technology is going and don’t trust markets to sort out what’s most efficient. However, it flies in the face of historic experience and the global and promising search for new technologies to generate and distribute power.

By all means, include environmental costs in energy prices, but please let’s not defend arbitrary and extravagant  public procurement policies by saying everything will get more expensive anyway. That kind of Luddite thinking was disapproved by coal, crude oil and natural gas innovations over the last 150 years. Only monopoly public nuclear power has steadily become more costly over the decades.

At the same time, Dan McDermott, director, Sierra Club Ontario dismisses the future economic value of the proposed new Detroit-Windsor Bridge:

“Tighter border security, passport requirements and the lingering recession are just some of the reasons identified in the January, 2011, Sierra Club report authored by a team of traffic-flow experts which concluded that this 12-year drop is the new normal.”


McDermott concludes:

“The Detroit river crossing is an unneeded $5.3-billion boondoggle that would involve substantial environmental damage. The Michigan legislature’s caution is merited and worthy of praise.”

Surely, there are better ways to protect eight species of birds and a garter snake without dismissing the potential for greater Canada-US trade and the importance of that trade to the well-being of North America. The barriers at the Canada-US border were erected by choice. And can be undone by better choices. People can, Mr McDermott, reform their relations with one another as well as with the environment.

Finally, what’s this about using traffic flow experts to determine the need for a hundred year investment project? Why not use this year’s lousy spring to shut down the climate change debate?

Thursday, November 4, 2010

Cap-and-trade legislation: saving the world in camera

Here are three quotes from a superb story by Ryan Lizza on the failed machinations of three Senators, the White House, and policy lobbyists to design a passable program to reduce US carbon dioxide emissions by 17 per cent by 2020. The focus of their efforts was the design of a cap-and-trade mechanism for the American economy.

“[American Petroleum Institute] would not run ads, they would not lobby members of Congress, and they would not refer to our bill as a carbon tax.” At another meeting, the three senators and the heads of the three oil companies discussed a phrase they could all use to market the policy: a “fee on polluters.”“According to people at the meeting, the White House aides and some of the environmentalists, including Carl Pope, the chairman of the Sierra Club, expressed their contempt for the linked fee [oil refineries would pay a fee linked to the average price of carbon over 3 months]: even if it was a fine idea on the merits, it was political poison.”
“The environmental community and the White House, which rarely weighed in on its policy preferences, thought the linked fee was disastrous because it would inevitably be labelled a “gas tax.” At one meeting, Joe Aldy, a staffer on Obama’s National Economic Council, advised Kerry, Graham, and Lieberman’s staffers to kill it.”
—Ryan Lizza, “As the World Burns”, The New Yorker, October 11, 2010
It’s brutally obvious that the environmental movement’s preference for a cap-and-trade regime was politically opportunistic, even while the opportunity had passed. The ease with which its labyrinth of rules could be gamed by special pleaders was of little concern. Its beauty was reflected in what it appeared not to be—in an untruth: that cutting emissions and raising the cost of energy wouldn’t tax consumers, that you could phase out the blessings of coal to coal states and leave them as blessed as ever.
There has been much fruitful interchange between environmentalists and economists, but in designing the cap-and-trade mechanism, they showed only passing respect for the integrity of either discipline. While the “trade” part was allegedly intended to facilitate the most efficient allocation of resources, everyone schemed to ensure that government, congress, and regulators—not the market—would finesse, in detail, how trading in carbon credits would work and what we would end up paying.
For environmentalists worried about public opinion, the only virtue of such a regime over a straightforward and firm carbon tax was that it wasn’t straightforward or firm.
It’s at least reassuring to know that three Senators, executive officials, and lobbyists are still trying to make history and are obviously highly motivated to find those compromises that allow significant change to take place. However, climate change advocates (as other radicals in the past) have to accept that you can’t outsmart the status quo alone in the corridors of power. (Lizza noted that last January the Pew Research Center found Americans ranked the importance of climate change as 21st on a list of 21.)
As a participatory democrat, it is no wonder President Obama let the venture fail. With popular support you can pass a badly compromised bill and leave time to fix the details. Without popular support—including seeing the costs along with a shiny future—politicians keep their heads down and won’t ask the best of each other.