Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label consumption taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label consumption taxes. Show all posts

Friday, March 21, 2014

Jim Flaherty’s great tax transgression

It was bad enough that departing finance minister Jim Flaherty survived in finance for eight years — right under our noses, through two minority Parliaments and a recession that compelled the largest and most self-conscious application of Keynesian pump-priming in modern history. Along with all that, Flaherty didn’t cut taxes the way liberals — and Andrew Coyne — would have.

Designing big tax cuts, of course, isn’t a signature passion among federal Liberal thinkers. They’ll do it in emergencies and when a budget surplus grows too large to be spent responsibly or credibly withheld from taxpayers.

Then, they’ll make broad cuts to personal income taxes.

Their approach (which I generally favor) has two virtues: It can easily be tailored to most benefit the middle class and least benefit the rich, and it can be phased out over time. Taking away payroll tax cuts has been done successfully by incumbent governments in North America for a century. It’s the safest way to manipulate revenues.

It’s the status quo working intelligently. Yet, there are adult options. That’s one of the reasons why we still have politics.

Jim Flaherty’s two percentage point cuts off the GST was his best conservative option and he took it.

Although it "costs" the federal treasury some $13billion annually, it helped hold up demand in a shaky economy, helped Stephen Harper defeat three Liberal leaders, facilitated consumption tax harmonization with Liberal governments in Ontario and Quebec — and will be almost impossible to repeal by whoever forms the next government.

Yes, it was a conservative accomplishment by a conservative government. It addressed a longstanding concern by conservative federalists: A balanced union can’t be sustained by a tax structure that makes it too easy for Ottawa to raise money and relatively more difficult for the provinces to finance their own legitimate responsibilities directly.

Andrew Coyne poses Flaherty’s choice differently:

“Should we remember the Flaherty, who against every axiom of economics, cut the GST rather than cutting income taxes, then larded up the tax code with all manner of special tax breaks for favored political interests?”

You can strip Coyne’s assertion down to this: My politics are above politics; I follow axioms and you’re a clown.

The technical issues are subtle and do not, overwhelmingly or conclusively, favor one broad tax cut option over another.

Consumption taxes, like the GST and HST, can be levied reasonably equitably — otherwise liberals wouldn’t regret Flaherty’s cuts to the GST. Further, it’s mighty shaky as an "axiom" to presume that increasing people’s discretionary incomes by cutting income taxes rather than consumer prices will necessarily better stimulate savings and investment rather than unwise shopping. (A dollar saved, as my mother would remind me, can also be banked.)

Further, liberals (not Coyne) would favor, rather than resent, the appreciation of the Canadian dollar if they believed lower prices would automatically lead to quantitatively greater purchasing. A strong dollar makes it easier to import productivity and wage-enhancing technologies.

However, the political case for the Harper-Flaherty GST cuts were overwhelming. The promise to cut the GST further distanced Stephen Harper from memories of the Brian Mulroney government, and that was a political imperative. The GST cuts weren’t merely variants of what Liberal Finance Minister Paul Martin had been doing. They would be hard for the government to forget to do them or take away. You pay them almost every time you leave the house.  


This post wasn’t written to guild Jim Flaherty’s political obituary. I’m only saying it is unfair to bury his tax cuts in some shadowy graveyard of two-bit ideas that betray fixed rules of effective public finance.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Taking the Leap for a Carbon Tax?


If the President knew the future as well as those who are telling him how to fix it, he’d stop worrying about going over the “Fiscal Cliff.”

On New Year’s Day, Washington politicians and American reformers would wake up to significant opportunities along with today’s risks: The American economy would still be growing slowly, but, as well, government planners would know—for the first time in this century—that there will be sufficient revenues coming in to run the place, and actually reform how that money is raised and how it’s spent.

In his first term, Obama gambled when he had almost no choice. In his second term, he’s in a stronger position to be very careful. Furthermore, he can’t know for sure whether another failure to make a deal with Republicans will lead to a better deal next year. Nor can he know whether other public and private leaders would be rational, minimizing the economic disruption caused by an across-the-board income tax increase and significant spending cuts that, together, would constitute the hard part of the landing.

Nevertheless, getting past George Bush’s ridiculously low income tax regime—a tax regime demonstrably unable to finance what elected conservatives and liberals keep promising and what red and blue state voters still want—would blow up a generation of slogans and fixed positions, and it would put real ideas (including new tax ideas) back on the table, with money to pay for them.

Along with modifying the new higher income tax rates for middle class taxpayers, liberal and conservative legislators could agree to find some additional, offsetting revenues by intelligently introducing consumption taxes. Canadian politicians got away with implementing a national consumption tax (GST) in the '90s, in part, because they had fiscal room to lower income tax rates. Washington would have that room next January.

David Frum lays out a comprehensive, timely, and politically serious case for introducing a carbon tax to kickstart a new global effort to resist climate change. It should be taken seriously, especially, if Washington actually takes the fiscal leap and is forced to be creative next year.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Imagine if North America responded rationally to rising crude oil prices

Oil supply disruptions and revolutions in the Middle East beat millions of consumer decisions for the news--and for gestures of concern by our leaders. Nevertheless, Western governments have the means to stabilize crude oil price increases and, thereby, protect the fragile global recovery. All they have to do is be half as bold at home as their rhetoric is abroad.
The underlying problem in the global crude oil market is steadily rising demand not uncertain supply. That will not change fundamentally if oil suppliers swap autocrats or democratize. New governments in the Middle East will face the same demographic pressures and the same desperate need to raise money from increased oil sales to meet their subjects rising demands. What sustains the speculative rise in crude oil prices now is not the prospect of irrational politics in the Middle East. Rather, it is the persistence of irrational energy policies in the West.
Rather than repeat the predictable folly of subsidizing consumers when prices rise Canada and the United States could shock the speculators by taking further action to discourage consumer demand.
With crude oil now hovering around $100 a barrel, there’s little room or need for a big consumption tax. However, the legislatures and governments of Canada and the US could agree on a carbon tax or VAT mechanism that would make sure that today’s prices rise steadily, rather than spike and collapse every few years. Such a measure, complemented by energy efficiency regulations, would send a powerful message to those who speculate in oil futures, invest in green technologies and hold US government bonds.
The mechanism could be fleshed out in days. Both capitals are replete with the necessary expertise and draft tax models. All it takes is the nerve to take action. It would impress the world. Imagine.