Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label US deficit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US deficit. Show all posts

Monday, February 25, 2013

Republicanism’s own looming danger: “normalcy”


Republicans didn’t just wait for big-government Democrats to age and grow incompetent. They developed a winning formula to unite two powerful electoral strangers: high-spirited fundamentalists and less high-spirited materialists with good pensions and business interests. Republican campaigners could rally these groups around a driving anxiety: “These are not normal times.”

Modern Republicans get elected by promising to clean up the indulgences of their less-adult opponents; they draw lines in the sand; most recently, they talk of Greek immorality and imminent financial collapse. This formula has been strikingly successful.
It’s in trouble now, however—not because the Party is short of fine performers but because their alarming argument is running out of gas from the real world.

Americans aren’t chronically fearful people. They don’t husband old traumas like adults in more slow-moving places like France, Russia, and Canada. So, being stirred to sacrifice requires fresh supplies of American bad news—credible signs of danger, of a danger, incidentally, that can be dropped at the feet of the federal government.

Bloomberg News reported quietly last week that Americans back spending-cut delay. That, itself, isn’t significant. That opinion can change with the times. Most people will delay unpleasantness if pollsters given a credible option.

What’s important, however, is that the failing case for severe cuts (a burgeoning deficit) is itself inflated:

“At the same time, the size and trajectory of the U.S. deficit is poorly understood by most Americans, with 62 percent saying it’s getting bigger, 28 percent saying it’s staying about the same this year, and just 6 percent saying it’s shrinking. The Congressional Budget Office reported Feb. 6 that the federal budget deficit is getting smaller, falling to $845 billion this year — the first time in five years that the gap between taxes and spending will be less than $1 trillion.”

In other words, the more Americans, and their business leaders, who acknowledge the recovery in government revenues as well as growing activity in the private sector, the less they’ll go along with extreme emergency measures to stave off an approaching national bankruptcy.

The Republicans will soon have to re-learn how to play politics more calmly. Indeed, if they’d let a retiring President win a couple of affordable fights, they’d be halfway there.

The world will surely give them a dandy crisis in the future. However, there is no virtue, on earth or in heaven, for inventing one now.

Thursday, January 10, 2013

Karl Rove’s miraculous virginity


We were assured that only social conservatives in the Republican Party used the term “forcible rape” or had any respect for the idea that a rape victim’s state of mind had any influence on whether she became pregnant.

When it comes to fiscal policy, however, so-called market Republicans apparently think that they can become virgins all over again simply by losing an election.

Karl Rove’s righteous advice to Republicans as they prepare to respond to the President’s next $trillion request to raise the amount the treasury can borrow to pay the federal government’s obligations was penned in the Wall Street Journal this morning. He took particular offence at Obama’s proposition that Congress “should pay the bills they have already racked up.”

He asserted baldy that Obama signed the measures, “that racked up the bills, which Republicans opposed.” Please, he’s saying, just set aside an avalanche of evidence that Republican recklessness along with Democrat indulgence created the debt problem and the Great Recession's deficit. We didn’t vote for Obamacare.

Rove endorses massive, unspecified spending cuts to keep paying the interest on Obama’s profligate spending. Even his prescription for what to do now is qualified with virginal expressions of innocence:

“With control of just one chamber, Republicans won't be able to advance much-needed structural changes in entitlements. That's the cost of losing the 2012 election. A Republican wish list will have to await a GOP president and Congress.

“For now, Republicans must make Mr. Obama take ownership of his deficits and the debt (which has increased from $10.626 trillion the day he took office to $16.433 trillion on Wednesday). It's impossible to negotiate with an ideologue, but Republicans can systematically unmask him and constrain him as much as their limited power allows, if they are united and acting in concert.”

Some cost: you lose the Presidency and so you can insist that you had nothing to do with this mess and needn’t extend yourself to fix it.

Rove’s rebut to growing impatience with Republican policy intransigence is simply more extremism. He fleshes out the paranoid perspective: foul spirits surrounds me; I’m innocent.

It won’t matter what fantasy carries the Republicans into the next fight. Neither fiscal terrorists nor suicide boomers get a pass for being virgins. 

Monday, December 17, 2012

Presidents lead because others don’t have to.


If you ever read a one-pager on the division of powers in the US Constitution and halfway accept the theory that Washington is the Establishment’s water-boy, you’d think Obama’s office has been swamped with outside advice on how avoid the “Fiscal Cliff”. 

You’d think his job was straightforward: make tolerable compromises out of clear proposals—proposals other politicians, eminent Americans, and powerful interests are championing, in public or in correspondence.

Yet, Obama has effectively been working alone since the November election.

Republicans pleaded to voters: “Choose America” and now they plead: “You choose, Mr. President”. They complain that Obama won’t flesh out what Republicans meant when they promised to “save” Medicare and Social Security, and “reform” the Tax Code. 

The only hint of precise thinking from John Boehner’s side of the “Fiscal Cliff” negotiations was a leak last weekend in the Wall Street Journal. It suggested that he’d accept higher taxes on those who take home over one $million annually—in return, of course, for a little restraint on future Social Security payments and healthcare entitlements.

Boehner’s concession could satisfy those who assume that the top 0.0l percent of income earners have all the cash the President needs, that Social Security is a military euphemism, and that ‘entitlements’ are for the privileged. Most everyone else, unfortunately, might think Mitt Romney actually won the election.

Nevertheless, we can still be hopeful, and cynical about the leadership of the Republicans at the same time. After all, there are plenty of other smart, experienced, tough people out there—in the real world—telling the President what has to be done, what they will help him sell.  Aren’t there?

Not writing in yesterday’s New York Times.

An entire page in the governing class’s must-read newspaper was purchased by the Peter G. Peterson Foundation to convey the advice of eight distinguished, retired giants of US public service. They acknowledged, in the first sentence, that they’d served eight presidents. They know how to be useful and still like being heard.

Under the headline: “Addressing Our Debt is a National Security Imperative”, they called on Washington to make a three-part deal to eventually balance the budget and avert the “Fiscal Cliff”. Here’s their message on taxes:

“◊ Tax reforms to raise more revenues, encourage growth and enhance progressivity — and it must be decided how much should be done through eliminating deductions, increasing rates and/or more fundamental changes to our tax code.”

If you find this rather vacuous, at this late date, imagine what Obama thought.

The “longer document” on their website offered no further details. They didn’t volunteer how much new revenue they think is needed, let alone exactly how that money would best be raised. They didn’t endorse Obama’s proposal to raise $1.4 trillion in new taxes; or say whether it’s too much or too little. They didn’t press conservatives in Congress to be precise about any of their generalities either.

Eminent Americans are very worried, but not enough to cause offence. They love their country, but aren’t responsible.

It’s possible that Gridlock in Washington will not be resolved by the ‘grown-ups’ taking collective responsibility for solving the problem.

There is, ultimately, a rather ugly nuclear scenario: The crisis gets big enough for Obama’s coy adversaries to just get out of the way.

Are Boehner, McConnell and the other debt-fighters just waiting for one of those glorious American emergencies that allow Washington’s stout survivors to give the President of the day what he wants?

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Taking the Leap for a Carbon Tax?


If the President knew the future as well as those who are telling him how to fix it, he’d stop worrying about going over the “Fiscal Cliff.”

On New Year’s Day, Washington politicians and American reformers would wake up to significant opportunities along with today’s risks: The American economy would still be growing slowly, but, as well, government planners would know—for the first time in this century—that there will be sufficient revenues coming in to run the place, and actually reform how that money is raised and how it’s spent.

In his first term, Obama gambled when he had almost no choice. In his second term, he’s in a stronger position to be very careful. Furthermore, he can’t know for sure whether another failure to make a deal with Republicans will lead to a better deal next year. Nor can he know whether other public and private leaders would be rational, minimizing the economic disruption caused by an across-the-board income tax increase and significant spending cuts that, together, would constitute the hard part of the landing.

Nevertheless, getting past George Bush’s ridiculously low income tax regime—a tax regime demonstrably unable to finance what elected conservatives and liberals keep promising and what red and blue state voters still want—would blow up a generation of slogans and fixed positions, and it would put real ideas (including new tax ideas) back on the table, with money to pay for them.

Along with modifying the new higher income tax rates for middle class taxpayers, liberal and conservative legislators could agree to find some additional, offsetting revenues by intelligently introducing consumption taxes. Canadian politicians got away with implementing a national consumption tax (GST) in the '90s, in part, because they had fiscal room to lower income tax rates. Washington would have that room next January.

David Frum lays out a comprehensive, timely, and politically serious case for introducing a carbon tax to kickstart a new global effort to resist climate change. It should be taken seriously, especially, if Washington actually takes the fiscal leap and is forced to be creative next year.

Wednesday, November 14, 2012

Obama is flexible, but the numbers aren’t


By the end of another week of “fiscal cliff” discussions, the press and a whole world of day-traders will be obsessing over Obama’s true intentions. Is he sounding tough because he’s arrogant? Has the election gone to his head? Is he only buying time for things to get so ugly that even liberal democrats will thank him for again giving in to the Republicans?

Or is he just waiting for Republican wordsmiths to so confuse the issue that he’ll be able to surrender on taxes and the deficit without anyone noticing? 

Sadly, the last gentle scenario can be ruled out: Republican street rhetoric about just closing “loopholes” and raising revenues from special “special interests” won’t give Obama cover if he gives up on his promise to fully restore Bill Clinton income tax rates on the most affluent.

Thanks to former Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin’s op-ed piece in the New York Times, it’s not possible to imagine that “tax reform” Republicans have a practical alternative. Finding the money Obama needs by cutting popular deductions for home mortgage payments, charitable donations, and employer insurance premiums, Rubin concludes, is a high-minded, bipartisan goose chase.

“When you compare raising the marginal rates for roughly 2 million Americans to phasing out health insurance exclusions that would affect 150 million Americans — even if some reform should be done — I don’t think it’s a close call substantively or politically.

“We should let the Bush high-end tax cuts expire, with an achievable, progressive reduction in tax expenditures. And we should have spending cuts, including entitlement reforms, equally matched by revenue increases. The entire program — including budgetary room for public investment and a moderate upfront jobs package — could be enacted now and deferred for a limited time with a serious mechanism to guarantee implementation.”

Brian Beutler in TPM this morning quotes Rubin and adds:

“In January, TPC analyzed (PDF) the revenue and distributional effects of three plans to limit tax expenditures. Each would raise over $2 trillion over 10 years. But each would also require millions of middle class taxpayers to pay higher taxes — something Obama’s pledged not to do.”

Republican leadership and their business economists may argue that Rubin’s been out of Washington for too long, that they’ve got new analysis that they’ve been holding back to help whoever won the election. Nothing they’ve said or tabled so far, however, should persuade anyone to believe that they are better at political economy and, politically, are more courageous than the generation of politicians Rubin served in the 90s.

From a distance, it’s impossible to imagine that today’s Republican legislators—men and women who were never clear with the people in last week’s elections—can now match, let alone trump, the courage of a President who was always clear about what he wanted to do, if he was re-elected.