Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Jim Flaherty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jim Flaherty. Show all posts

Friday, March 21, 2014

Jim Flaherty’s great tax transgression

It was bad enough that departing finance minister Jim Flaherty survived in finance for eight years — right under our noses, through two minority Parliaments and a recession that compelled the largest and most self-conscious application of Keynesian pump-priming in modern history. Along with all that, Flaherty didn’t cut taxes the way liberals — and Andrew Coyne — would have.

Designing big tax cuts, of course, isn’t a signature passion among federal Liberal thinkers. They’ll do it in emergencies and when a budget surplus grows too large to be spent responsibly or credibly withheld from taxpayers.

Then, they’ll make broad cuts to personal income taxes.

Their approach (which I generally favor) has two virtues: It can easily be tailored to most benefit the middle class and least benefit the rich, and it can be phased out over time. Taking away payroll tax cuts has been done successfully by incumbent governments in North America for a century. It’s the safest way to manipulate revenues.

It’s the status quo working intelligently. Yet, there are adult options. That’s one of the reasons why we still have politics.

Jim Flaherty’s two percentage point cuts off the GST was his best conservative option and he took it.

Although it "costs" the federal treasury some $13billion annually, it helped hold up demand in a shaky economy, helped Stephen Harper defeat three Liberal leaders, facilitated consumption tax harmonization with Liberal governments in Ontario and Quebec — and will be almost impossible to repeal by whoever forms the next government.

Yes, it was a conservative accomplishment by a conservative government. It addressed a longstanding concern by conservative federalists: A balanced union can’t be sustained by a tax structure that makes it too easy for Ottawa to raise money and relatively more difficult for the provinces to finance their own legitimate responsibilities directly.

Andrew Coyne poses Flaherty’s choice differently:

“Should we remember the Flaherty, who against every axiom of economics, cut the GST rather than cutting income taxes, then larded up the tax code with all manner of special tax breaks for favored political interests?”

You can strip Coyne’s assertion down to this: My politics are above politics; I follow axioms and you’re a clown.

The technical issues are subtle and do not, overwhelmingly or conclusively, favor one broad tax cut option over another.

Consumption taxes, like the GST and HST, can be levied reasonably equitably — otherwise liberals wouldn’t regret Flaherty’s cuts to the GST. Further, it’s mighty shaky as an "axiom" to presume that increasing people’s discretionary incomes by cutting income taxes rather than consumer prices will necessarily better stimulate savings and investment rather than unwise shopping. (A dollar saved, as my mother would remind me, can also be banked.)

Further, liberals (not Coyne) would favor, rather than resent, the appreciation of the Canadian dollar if they believed lower prices would automatically lead to quantitatively greater purchasing. A strong dollar makes it easier to import productivity and wage-enhancing technologies.

However, the political case for the Harper-Flaherty GST cuts were overwhelming. The promise to cut the GST further distanced Stephen Harper from memories of the Brian Mulroney government, and that was a political imperative. The GST cuts weren’t merely variants of what Liberal Finance Minister Paul Martin had been doing. They would be hard for the government to forget to do them or take away. You pay them almost every time you leave the house.  


This post wasn’t written to guild Jim Flaherty’s political obituary. I’m only saying it is unfair to bury his tax cuts in some shadowy graveyard of two-bit ideas that betray fixed rules of effective public finance.

Thursday, November 8, 2012

The next American Melodrama: the “Fiscal Cliff”


American democracy didn’t die on Tuesday and hasn’t killed the American Dream. The world’s oldest federal democracy hasn’t reached its "use by" date.

As the worldly world outside waited, Americans devoted long hours, in greater numbers than before, to give a clear majority to a moderate President who didn’t hide his willingness to advance the causes of moderates in Washington. The people’s voices have made it more dangerous, not easier, for America’s politicians to be extreme, to slow things down, to play dice with their economy or world peace, or single out who’s a good American and who’s not.

Headliners abroad screamed that America “split in half.”

Is supporting (in the tens of millions) two viable national campaigns a provocation, an indulgence? Is there a better option out there? Would we wish on Americans the harmonious one-clique model practiced in China? Or the micro-party, coalition politics that leaves all the compromising to the backrooms, and makes it easy for Canadians and Europeans to vote for fanatics, as well as professional politicians?

Let’s go further and start being a little more hopeful as well about Washington’s ability to fix its problems and support economic growth. After all, the US is now the only superpower, the only giant mixed economy in the world, with one set of fiscal and monetary levers in one national government, lead by seasoned executives and legislators with fresh popular authority to attend to its problems.

The “fiscal cliff” is the term used to scare people into following the debate over how to align America’s spending and taxing levels in ways that will lift uncertainly about the future and, thereby, bolster sustainable recovery. Obviously, the subtly of it all cries out for alarming, simple language.

Nevertheless, the “fiscal cliff” isn’t a suicide pact. It’s the law of the land and, if implemented, would take a giant step toward closing the US structural deficit. (The thing Obama’s critics call the freeway to Greece.) It entails, unfortunately, too much on taxes and too much on spending, at once, at this time. Taking approximately $600 billion out of the economy, especially the piece that includes middle class tax increases, has orphaned the whole plan and made the likes of John Boehner welcome new ideas from Obama. Here’s what he said today to the New York Times:

“Instead of allowing the top rates to go up, which Republicans say would harm the economy, Mr. Boehner said Washington should end some deductions and loopholes to raise revenues.”

A hybrid of Obama’s income tax rate increase on incomes over $25,000 and Romney’s coy proposal to impose a $15,000 or, say, $25,000 cap, on popular tax deductions could help raise enough on the tax revenue side necessary to complement entitlement spending cuts.

It’s not likely, however, that Boehner could sell his Republican colleagues on any tax package that explicitly raises revenues, if Obama appears willing, yet again, to postpone the legislated New Year’s tax increases that make up about half of the “fiscal cliff.”

For the “fiscal cliff” to work as blackmail, it has to be reckoned with as something that could actually be done, if negotiations fail. Obama again must play the long game and risk causing hearts to race everywhere for the next couple of months.

Speaking to the recessionary threat of the “fiscal cliff” in today’s National Post, Canada’s Conservative Finance Minister Jim Flaherty inadvertently spelled out how it would work out: his "pragmatic" government would stimulate the Canadian economy. Republican conservatives along with Canadian conservatives would scramble to keep the North American economy growing.

They’d blame Obama for the crisis. The markets would prefer a quick return to those $trillion deficits that were making them rich and smug at the same time. The IMF and other forecasters would predict a recession that could only happen if Washington, for the first time in modern history, refused to do anything.

American politicians never fail to take short-term actions to fight recessions. The question with no clear answer now is: Can they still do hard things to protect America's future?

This looming "fiscal cliff" will be puffed up over the next weeks by low tax fanatics to excuse further delay on tax reform—until it’s too close to the 2014 congressional elections to do anything. Yet, now is the safest time for Congress to compromise, and the best moment Obama will have to get them to be statesmen, just like in the movies.