Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Fiscal Cliff. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fiscal Cliff. Show all posts

Thursday, January 3, 2013

Spin on! Spin on! It’s only a new year


Theatre in Washington closed on a delicious high: every oration and most asides were quotable and on message. The second season of “The Fiscal Cliff” transfixed the world, teased the markets, and climaxed without a blood bath or exhausting its writers.
Too bad about the writers.
Enough changed in this week’s $600 billion income tax deal to require some adjustments in future messaging. However, Democrats must continue to go on about “balanced sacrifice” and Republicans must continue to tear-up about the wretched world facing their grandchildren. The changes were big enough to settle discussion on income tax rates, for a while. But, they were not enough to satisfy worried liberals or calm worried conservatives.
“The Greek Abyss” remains the inspiration and meal ticket for the long-view wordsmiths in national politics.
For Mayans in Washington, 2020 will soon be the new 2012.
George Will is already on his feet raging against the effete dimensions of the “The Fiscal Cliff” denouement. In his column “Our decadent democracy” he complains that America’s leaders have been cowed by the “entitlement state”. Then, ta da, he invents a fresh pack of heroic Republicans preparing to come to the rescue.  
“Furthermore, a critical mass of Republicans reject the careerists’ understanding of “politically rational” behavior. These Republicans have a different rationale for being in politics.
“The media, which often are the last to know things because their wishes father their thoughts, say the tea party impulse is exhausted. Scores of House Republicans and seven first-term Republican senators (Rand Paul, Mike Lee, Pat Toomey, Ted Cruz, Ron Johnson, Marco Rubio and Tim Scott) will soon — hello, debt ceiling — prove otherwise.”
Will plays with history with the same abandon that he plays with tomorrow.
The career politicians he named, along with Paul Ryan and other members of Ayn Rand’s Congressional book club, only got excited about Mitt Romney when he started to look like a winner according to the old rationale—beating a Democrat by promising to leave voters with their entitlements and only throwing legitimate bums off the dole.
Ari Fleischer was George Bush’s press secretary and now is enough of heavyweight to get his thoughts on the economy into the New York Times. He offered this gigantic pivot to set the stage for the next man-made crisis Will is already cheering on:
“As a Bush loyalist, it’s fantastic that the Bush tax cuts, which now have to be seen inarguably as overwhelmingly for the middle class, are being made permanent. On the other hand, it’s inarguable that this adds $4 trillion to the federal debt.”
When Obama promised to raise income tax rates on the top two percent, Fleischer followed the Republican Party line: that would be an intolerable tax increase. Now that Obama has agreed to raise income taxes on only the top one percent, Fleischer introduces a brand new party line: it will cause a gigantic increase in the national debt.
In the fall, the same Democrat vision would turn Americans into godless Swedes; today it’s penniless Greeks.
According to the logic of Fleischer’s new found fascination with debt and its origins, Mitt Romney’s tax plan of piling a further 20% tax rate cut on top of Bush’s tax regime didn’t constitute a $4trillion revenue problem at all. Rather, it constituted an $8 trillion revenue problem that would have would have landed America on the west coast of the Mediterranean Sea.
Will regrets that Americans missed a wonderful educational opportunity by not being lead over “The Cliff”.
Actually, in choosing not to jump, we learned a great deal about contemporary America and its politicians. Conservatives don’t want Washington to have the means to keep growing and liberals still believe government can help. But they will compromise with each other because Americans are united—they still prize economic growth and non-discriminatory, reliable, access to the services of a competently run, well-financed government.
The nice thing about man-made crises is that they are played out by humans according to what humans want. 

Thursday, December 20, 2012

Cliff Jumping: today’s wicked liberal temptation


Barack Obama is strong in the polls and is enjoying his second honeymoon in Washington. Once again, he’s Time Magazine’s “Person of the Year”.

However, this lovely year is dying and, as in 2008, the year approaching is killing the holiday spirit. Rather than boast about the last campaign or act as though it holds all the cards, Obama’s White House keeps trying to compromise with Republicans.

Rather than only exempting income under $250,000 from higher tax rates, he now proposes to exempt income under $400,000. Furthermore, he’s agreed to constrain the growth of Social Security payments. Overall, he’s offered a plan that is less liberal than many Democrats would like, but sufficiently conservative to rally the support of business and moderates. Overwhelmingly, they see their interests best served by incremental restraint, incremental deficit reduction, and incremental revenue enhancing tax changes—whatever a majority of legislators and the President agree is necessary to sustain the recovery and avoid another crisis that would make America look stupid.

Obama doesn’t talk about bi-partisanship anymore; he just scorns extremists and those who avoiding making a deal. Also, he says he’s prepared to keep negotiating. This is making some influential liberals very uncomfortable.  Are Democrats reverting to Wimps? Timothy Noah asks in today’s post for The New Republic.

Calling a politician a “wimp” can be dangerous. Remember George Bush’s first term? However, this isn’t Obama’s first crisis, nor is it his first term. Politically and legislatively, he’s done quite well settling for what often appeared at the time as less than half a loaf.

Daredevil liberals presume that Obama finally has sufficient political capital to intimidate the more pragmatic Republicans and shouldn’t be compromising anymore. If those blockhead Republicans don’t give in voluntarily they can be bullied into after Washington, Wall Street and American self-confidence goes over the “Fiscal Cliff”. Whoopee!

If only politics was only theatre and its artists controlled the scripts. Winning on fiscal policy, however, isn’t ever clear-cut or permanent. New Deal Democrats didn’t get through their agenda before they were thrown out. Reagan and Thatcher conservatives didn’t undo big government or even change the public’s habit of turning to the state for help and solutions.

Before risking another recession that—in advance—looks manageable, liberals should recall why they feel like winners, and why that feeling could be fleeting.

They won, in large part, because millions of Americans decided that Obama offered a more careful Presidency than the alternative. And they want a careful President because the economy and America’s stature are recovering.

Maybe there is no honorable deal to be had over the next ten days. However, insisting Obama win big in this lame duck Congress carries immeasurable risk. Historically, economic prosperity has been good for liberal incumbents. And retrenchment has been very tough.

Avoiding another recession and the scorn of the world are not only the responsibility of wimps. Obama’s extraordinarily liberal agenda—immigration reform, now gun control, implementing universal healthcare, advancing gay rights, and possibly, securing election finance reform—needs the climate of generosity and confidence that economic prosperity inspires.

Going over the “Fiscal Cliff” could destroy John Boehner. However, returning to mean times could save the Tea Party in 2014. 

Monday, December 17, 2012

Presidents lead because others don’t have to.


If you ever read a one-pager on the division of powers in the US Constitution and halfway accept the theory that Washington is the Establishment’s water-boy, you’d think Obama’s office has been swamped with outside advice on how avoid the “Fiscal Cliff”. 

You’d think his job was straightforward: make tolerable compromises out of clear proposals—proposals other politicians, eminent Americans, and powerful interests are championing, in public or in correspondence.

Yet, Obama has effectively been working alone since the November election.

Republicans pleaded to voters: “Choose America” and now they plead: “You choose, Mr. President”. They complain that Obama won’t flesh out what Republicans meant when they promised to “save” Medicare and Social Security, and “reform” the Tax Code. 

The only hint of precise thinking from John Boehner’s side of the “Fiscal Cliff” negotiations was a leak last weekend in the Wall Street Journal. It suggested that he’d accept higher taxes on those who take home over one $million annually—in return, of course, for a little restraint on future Social Security payments and healthcare entitlements.

Boehner’s concession could satisfy those who assume that the top 0.0l percent of income earners have all the cash the President needs, that Social Security is a military euphemism, and that ‘entitlements’ are for the privileged. Most everyone else, unfortunately, might think Mitt Romney actually won the election.

Nevertheless, we can still be hopeful, and cynical about the leadership of the Republicans at the same time. After all, there are plenty of other smart, experienced, tough people out there—in the real world—telling the President what has to be done, what they will help him sell.  Aren’t there?

Not writing in yesterday’s New York Times.

An entire page in the governing class’s must-read newspaper was purchased by the Peter G. Peterson Foundation to convey the advice of eight distinguished, retired giants of US public service. They acknowledged, in the first sentence, that they’d served eight presidents. They know how to be useful and still like being heard.

Under the headline: “Addressing Our Debt is a National Security Imperative”, they called on Washington to make a three-part deal to eventually balance the budget and avert the “Fiscal Cliff”. Here’s their message on taxes:

“◊ Tax reforms to raise more revenues, encourage growth and enhance progressivity — and it must be decided how much should be done through eliminating deductions, increasing rates and/or more fundamental changes to our tax code.”

If you find this rather vacuous, at this late date, imagine what Obama thought.

The “longer document” on their website offered no further details. They didn’t volunteer how much new revenue they think is needed, let alone exactly how that money would best be raised. They didn’t endorse Obama’s proposal to raise $1.4 trillion in new taxes; or say whether it’s too much or too little. They didn’t press conservatives in Congress to be precise about any of their generalities either.

Eminent Americans are very worried, but not enough to cause offence. They love their country, but aren’t responsible.

It’s possible that Gridlock in Washington will not be resolved by the ‘grown-ups’ taking collective responsibility for solving the problem.

There is, ultimately, a rather ugly nuclear scenario: The crisis gets big enough for Obama’s coy adversaries to just get out of the way.

Are Boehner, McConnell and the other debt-fighters just waiting for one of those glorious American emergencies that allow Washington’s stout survivors to give the President of the day what he wants?

Thursday, December 6, 2012

Has John Boehner joined the “War Against Christmas”?


Calling Mitt Romney stupid hasn’t made other Republicans any smarter. John Boehner is already making the same mistakes.

For a while, the House Speaker was careful to match Obama’s explicit call for higher tax rates for the top 2% with pleasing generalities: Please, higher revenues not higher tax rates; and, yes, special interests should give up their loopholes and deductions.

This approach united Republicans. It would likely work as firm policy in another presidential television debate. However, it didn’t go far enough as a compromise formula for actually legislating a package of tax changes with Obama. And Republicans insist that the voters want them to lead too. So Boehner, in a letter to the President last week, went further: He’d agree to raise $800 billion by cutting the deductions and loopholes of the “same people” Obama would tax at higher rates.

If you insist on negotiating, not just campaigning in public, you have to get specific. However, Boehner has bought himself a world of trouble. The reaction to what he’s proposed, in fact, may be enough to force him to work within the revenue formula Obama has long proposed.

Konrad Yakabuski in today’s Globe and Mail neatly summarizes Obama’s response and, more importantly, the alarm of the unintended, lovable victims of Boehner's counter-proposal: America’s charities and its fragile housing recovery.

“The United Way and other non-profit organizations held a 'Hill Day' on Wednesday to press members of Congress not to change the tax deduction for the $200-billion Americans donate to charities each year.

“The deduction costs the federal treasury more than $50-billion in foregone tax revenue annually. Charities worry donations would dry up without it.”

Boehner can’t find his $800 billion without taking away that $50 billion of offsetting tax relief for those who give most generously to charities.

Yet it’s Republican orthodoxy—and widely accepted—that significantly raising taxes on work and consumer activities alters what taxpayers do with their time and money. Raise marginal income tax rates too high and many will stay home longer and putter in the basement. Make gasoline considerably more expensive and they’ll drive less.

It defies faith and common sense to believe that taking away $50 billion in targeted tax relief for charitable giving will not materially dampen support for charities.

If Boehner thinks the rich will carry on as if nothing happened, then what’s the problem with Obama’s modest across-the-board increase in the top tax rates on their incomes? They’ll lay off their workers while giving more to charity?

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Taking the Leap for a Carbon Tax?


If the President knew the future as well as those who are telling him how to fix it, he’d stop worrying about going over the “Fiscal Cliff.”

On New Year’s Day, Washington politicians and American reformers would wake up to significant opportunities along with today’s risks: The American economy would still be growing slowly, but, as well, government planners would know—for the first time in this century—that there will be sufficient revenues coming in to run the place, and actually reform how that money is raised and how it’s spent.

In his first term, Obama gambled when he had almost no choice. In his second term, he’s in a stronger position to be very careful. Furthermore, he can’t know for sure whether another failure to make a deal with Republicans will lead to a better deal next year. Nor can he know whether other public and private leaders would be rational, minimizing the economic disruption caused by an across-the-board income tax increase and significant spending cuts that, together, would constitute the hard part of the landing.

Nevertheless, getting past George Bush’s ridiculously low income tax regime—a tax regime demonstrably unable to finance what elected conservatives and liberals keep promising and what red and blue state voters still want—would blow up a generation of slogans and fixed positions, and it would put real ideas (including new tax ideas) back on the table, with money to pay for them.

Along with modifying the new higher income tax rates for middle class taxpayers, liberal and conservative legislators could agree to find some additional, offsetting revenues by intelligently introducing consumption taxes. Canadian politicians got away with implementing a national consumption tax (GST) in the '90s, in part, because they had fiscal room to lower income tax rates. Washington would have that room next January.

David Frum lays out a comprehensive, timely, and politically serious case for introducing a carbon tax to kickstart a new global effort to resist climate change. It should be taken seriously, especially, if Washington actually takes the fiscal leap and is forced to be creative next year.