Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label debt ceiling. Show all posts
Showing posts with label debt ceiling. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 23, 2013

What’s looming, America? A crack-up or a boom?


These are anxious times for history spotters in the US and in Canada, looking on. There’s little time left for those bored by gridlock, sick to death of incrementalism, or those who have spiced up their careers warning that America, finally, is about to explode.

According to the IMF updated economic outlook, as well as stock prices, government and corporate revenues, hiring rates, commodity, and housing prices, the US economy is finally approaching healthy growth — similar to the pace of growth that’s dampened apocalyptic political temptations in the past.

In the 60s, at about the time I experienced my first serious adult migraine, I worried about nuclear bombs. I kept the company of spectacular worriers and read worrisome books. Influential voices in my generation are still worrying. However, today, most opine on more manageable concerns: on the possibility, for instance, that professional politicians, egged on by their talking points, will blow up America’s economy, if not its less-than-perfect union.

Meanwhile, I still worry about the bomb.

My crazy hope is that our leaders will secure their precious legacies by dismantling the world’s stockpiles of nuclear warheads and melting down those devilish red buttons on their portable triggers. Then they could give former presidents and their most senior bomb executives shiney red lapel pins boasting: “We didn’t kill you.”

The chances, of course, of a survivable catastrophe in American governance are higher. Actually, its prospect is as likely to cause delight as well as alarm in global audiences hooked on the American melodrama. So, we are focused on the debt ceiling and the ever-present chance that the insane other side of American politics will “go nuclear” in Congress.

CNN generates audiences for this bloodless drama, and partisan historians add gravitas.

Last week, Sean Wilentz in Rolling Stone and Jim Laxer in the Toronto Globe and Mail took maximum advantage of silence on the front in Washington to remind us that flirting with disaster and mayhem is built into the architecture of America’s democracy.

Wilentz recalls that ever since the 1870s, Southern extremists have been threatening fiscal catastrophe to try to emasculate liberal tendencies in Washington. For over 140 years, radicals and their “subversive fury” have enjoyed the power to smash “the rules of normal consensus-building politics” that are so necessary to the proper function of America’s divided system of government.

Jim Laxer is an affable, intelligent Canadian. He offers qualifiers such as: “dysfunctional features”, “government shutdowns at least for a time…”, and measures that “could well provoke large-scale violence.” Nevertheless, his vision is dark: “Post-shutdown America is on the verge of outright civil conflict.” Two quite “distinct societies” are approaching each other’s throats — one is “Old America” and one is “New America.” Jim doesn’t explicitly pick sides; he can’t. He’s a contentious Canadian nationalist.

Laxer does believe, however, that Canadian federalism can handle two distinct societies — but America’s can’t. He doesn’t suggest the Americans would still be better governed today as British colonies. But he offers this fabulously irrefutable proposition:

“A century and a half ago, the outbreak of the Civil War had a great deal to do with the U.S. system of government. Abraham Lincoln was elected president of the United States on November 6, 1860, with a minority of the vote in a four-way contest. By the time he was inaugurated four months later on March 4, 1861, seven Southern states had seceded from the American Union to form the Confederate States of America. With a parliamentary system, the 1860 election could have resulted in a minority government and some kind of compromise.”

During the century and a half since Lincoln used his Executive powers, and Southern reactionaries found ways to block the use of Executive powers, ordinary American politicians, with the backing of ordinary Americans, have been able to hold together a federation of not two, but numerous societies. Furthermore, as one republic, it won two hot and one cold global war — and successfully fostered the creation of a peaceful, decentralized world market place. Not bad for rebellious amateurs.

Sorry, Laxer. Next year, America will be further away from extreme trouble, not closer. “Old” and “new” Americans will be more prosperous and more secure. They will share an ever-growing stake in peacefully managing their differences. Today’s peacemakers, not today’s troublemakers, will re-assert themselves or be replaced by new peacemakers.

Tuesday, October 8, 2013

Give peace a chance? In Washington too?

The 24/7 strategists on CNN coyly put it as question. Republican cliff dwellers in Congress frame it as a complaint. Wall Street money managers will be screaming it: when is President Obama going to negotiate on the debt ceiling? 

The calculator-who-calculates-forever missed his chance to make war in Syria. When will he make the same mistake in Washington and quietly let his enemies sue for peace — without risking their political lives?

From Peggy Noonan to The Economist, Barack Obama has been scorned for his lack of élan in the Middle East. For his reluctance to spill blood on his "red line" on the use of chemical weapons and his willingness to let the new leadership in Iran trim their belligerent rhetoric without calling them losers and, thereby, increasing their political problems with their touchy Tea Party base in Tehran.

That was last month, they insist. This month — better still, tomorrow — Obama must practice soft-diplomacy in Washington. He can’t carry on as the only adult in the room. Our divided government needs adult majorities in Congress too!

It must be tempting for Democrats to let radical conservatives stew in their own psychobabble about the fussy trimmer in the White House. Nevertheless, Obama must know that Americans are just as tired of warrior rhetoric in Washington as they are of wars abroad.

There are no honeymoons for war right now — or for another showdown in Washington. As elsewhere in the world, American liberal preferences usually win at home when America and its government is at peace.

It’s delusional partisan rhetoric for Democrats to say that Republicans are anti-government. Thirty Republican Governors tax and spend and share those basic public responsibilities in Washington. Next year, they’ll scramble to keep the offices they hold and will start looking for an electable candidate for the Presidential election of 2016.

Republicans are no more anti-politics than Democrats are anti-American. And they won’t be chased out of Washington.

The surest way for Democrats to win next year, and again in 2016, is to keep making those tacky compromises that got America out of recession and made universal healthcare finally a work in progress.

Thursday, January 10, 2013

Karl Rove’s miraculous virginity


We were assured that only social conservatives in the Republican Party used the term “forcible rape” or had any respect for the idea that a rape victim’s state of mind had any influence on whether she became pregnant.

When it comes to fiscal policy, however, so-called market Republicans apparently think that they can become virgins all over again simply by losing an election.

Karl Rove’s righteous advice to Republicans as they prepare to respond to the President’s next $trillion request to raise the amount the treasury can borrow to pay the federal government’s obligations was penned in the Wall Street Journal this morning. He took particular offence at Obama’s proposition that Congress “should pay the bills they have already racked up.”

He asserted baldy that Obama signed the measures, “that racked up the bills, which Republicans opposed.” Please, he’s saying, just set aside an avalanche of evidence that Republican recklessness along with Democrat indulgence created the debt problem and the Great Recession's deficit. We didn’t vote for Obamacare.

Rove endorses massive, unspecified spending cuts to keep paying the interest on Obama’s profligate spending. Even his prescription for what to do now is qualified with virginal expressions of innocence:

“With control of just one chamber, Republicans won't be able to advance much-needed structural changes in entitlements. That's the cost of losing the 2012 election. A Republican wish list will have to await a GOP president and Congress.

“For now, Republicans must make Mr. Obama take ownership of his deficits and the debt (which has increased from $10.626 trillion the day he took office to $16.433 trillion on Wednesday). It's impossible to negotiate with an ideologue, but Republicans can systematically unmask him and constrain him as much as their limited power allows, if they are united and acting in concert.”

Some cost: you lose the Presidency and so you can insist that you had nothing to do with this mess and needn’t extend yourself to fix it.

Rove’s rebut to growing impatience with Republican policy intransigence is simply more extremism. He fleshes out the paranoid perspective: foul spirits surrounds me; I’m innocent.

It won’t matter what fantasy carries the Republicans into the next fight. Neither fiscal terrorists nor suicide boomers get a pass for being virgins. 

Wednesday, January 9, 2013

Obama’s Taunts: Breadcrumbs to Oblivion


In his dealings with Republicans in his first term Obama was cold and naïve. Now, he’s cold and nasty.

He used to phone their leaders and ask them to stand up to the Tea Party. They’d put the phone on mute. Now, he calls press conferences to remind them that he won the last election. Republicans listen; the quiet ones seethe, the freer spirits howl at the moon.

In a series of statements, he’s taunted Congress to act “promptly” on contentious issues and apologized to the American people for Congress’ “games”. On the appointment of his Defense Secretary, on Senate filibusters, on the debt ceiling, gun controls, immigration reform, and further tax revenues and reform, he’s annoyed Republicans and worried centrists who pine for more discreet negotiations at their next cliff-side rendezvous.  

Obama’s new chivy style is well documented in this morning’s Politico by Glenn Thrush and Reid J. Epstein. (They concentrate on legislative tactics and set aside the more interesting possibility that Obama is actually indulging himself, after four years of biting his lip.
But, let’s leave emotion speculation to history and Bob Woodward.)

 In his first term, Obama tried to generate bi-partisanship by personal example--being more restrained and more open to compromise than anyone else in town.

Some say that Obama was on the right track but needed to be more ‘accessible’.

Political folklore instructs that the positive half of Lyndon Johnson’s Presidency was secured by his big bear, sweaty, tactile ways with other men.  Temperamentally, that style isn’t available to Obama. And in any event--in all honesty--is America actually ready for its first black president to throw his weight around like a backslapping pol?

Obama appears to have taken away a different message from the mid-Sixties legislative accomplishments of Johnson: a president can get conservative and liberal careerists in Congress to go along with him when they fear that they will miss the parade--and appear out-of-date and extreme.

Most elected politicians stop being brave when they stop being called “brave” back home, and start being called irresponsible.  That’s what got a $600 billion income tax increase the support of over a third of the Republican House of Representative on January 1st.

That tribal impulse, fortunately, helped pass civil rights legislation though, unfortunately, it also helped finance the build up of the War in Vietnam. It’s not a gentle way of making progress. But, Obama has got the parade moving and clearly wants to keep moving.

His provocations, so far, probably help.

As the more temperamental members of the Republican caucus react to Obama’s teasing and pander to their most radical supporters, the harder it will be for mainstream Republicans to resist Obama's legislative and fiscal proposals.

Tuesday, September 6, 2011

Starbucks: great coffee, insipid politics

The opium den was where men escaped. The coffee house was where they talked politics. In one, they made history and in the other, they hid. Howard Schultz owes it to coffee and American democracy to do better than release an insipid letter on the failure of leadership in Washington.
This weekend, over the signature of Howard Schultz, CEO of Starbucks Coffee Company, he placed full page advertisement announcing to Americans that he and another 100 business leaders were going to go on strike as campaign donors until the President and Congress ended their partisan deadlock and agreed on a short-terms stimulus package and a long-term plan to reduce the US deficit. He endorsed the “No Labels” non-partisan movement and urged other Americans to tell Washington to put “citizenship ahead of partisanship.”
If a paralyzed Obama presidency proves to be the beginning of the end for American leadership, Schultz’s letter will rank as a telling contribution. Sure, the Tea Party has been disruptive. But, it was inevitable that Republicans would be more radical in opposition than in office. The consistently late and anemic influence of moderate American business leaders, however, is as important.
Shultz and his aroused one hundred now see America at a “fragile and critical moment.” Why couldn’t they see this months, even weeks ago? Why, for instance, didn’t these “job-creators” send their pro-business Republican champions back to the negotiating table in July? Why did they not raise hell about playing chicken with the US debt ceiling? The obvious, lame reason they can speak now is that the “no label” non- partisan platform allows them to speak--without taking sides.
These business leaders spend millions buying attention in Washington that they can have for nothing, but don’t seem to have anything bold, concrete or offensive to say. 
There were plenty of gentlemen in the late 30s who told Winston Churchill to tone down his rhetoric, that the way to impress Hitler was to get along and stand with his Prime Minister, Neville Chamberlain.
History doesn’t remember or honor “no label” politics when decisions must be made.
Starbuck’s has a vital stake in social harmony and broad-based job creation in urban America. Furthermore, when Americans get fed up, they don’t boycott politics or leave for Canada, they take sides. Schultz owes it to his business as well as his convictions to place a second advertisement openly endorsing Obama’s Thursday address to Congress if it does, in fact, offer a centrist strategy for immediate stimulus and comprehensive fiscal reform.