Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Preston Manning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Preston Manning. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 24, 2015

Western Canada not yet “in” where it counts

Possibly, the nicest slogan a protest party ever invented in Canada — if not clear across the English-speaking world — was the Reform Party’s 1987 plea: “The West wants in!” Its loquacious leader Preston Manning didn’t want to alienate patriotic Canadians who were already fed up with Quebec’s separatist movement; he hoped that open-minded voters, with enough time to hear his case, would make him Prime Minister of Canada.  

The gentleness of his slogan, however, didn’t protect him from old-line party adversaries who branded his movement as a radical un-Canadian front for US-style evangelical illiterates. Manning did destroy the national Progressive Conservative Party but never won Parliamentary seats in Eastern Canada, an absolute necessity to win power. Today, in retirement, his consolation is ready access to the Globe’s op-ed page and near-universal appreciation that he’s nicer than that fellow Westerner who did get the job.

The West is now “in” in Canada — and, so, enjoys great influence within Canada’s federal government. Demographics, resources, young immigrants and wealth, it’s assumed, will acquire for the West ever more influence in the centers of power. The rest of us will keep thinking of the West as the country’s flytrap for extremists and oddballs. But no one expects to hear again their old disruptive alternatives to the Canadian federation.

The Reform Party’s slogan has been effective; now it’s everybody’s property, a bland iteration of the status quo. “In” points east, obviously. But is that the end of the story?

If only to reduce the boredom of Canada’s hamster-in-a-cage politics, let’s exhume a few dormant thoughts about the West’s external relations.

The term “Western separatism” persists as an insult in the East but never was credible, strategically, in the West. Western Canadian visionaries didn’t see the West as "exceptional" as storytellers do in Quebec, Newfoundland, and Cape Breton, for instance. Rather, they worried, above all, about their province and the West’s economic vulnerability and relative powerlessness.

Getting “in” was the original family response of the Manning, Lougheed, Douglas, Roblin, Bennett, and Diefenbaker cadres of Western reformers. However, they weren’t single-minded as we almost mindlessly are today. They were outward-seeing, not simply Ottawa-seeing.

When they thought about and lobbied about infrastructure, banking, trade, immigration, and taxation, they looked for ways to escape the claustrophobic post-Confederation status quo, not merely catch a "fair share."

The least obsequious, most successful, and controversial Western reformer of our time was Premier Peter Lougheed of Alberta. The 70s and 80s inspired big thinking and he offered plenty. Pierre Trudeau centralists, severe recession, and uncertain commodity markets spurred Lougheed to secure whatever powers the West needed to reduce the West’s exposure to political whims in the East and political barriers to export markets.

He was a political as well as an economic diversifier. Free trade and resource sovereignty for the provinces, crucially including unobstructed access to the US market, would translate into less economic policy interference from Ottawa.

He joined alliances with other federalists to keep Quebec “in,” but in return he secured trade and constitutional powers for the West.

His victories in the 80s seemed to work. The West generally thought it had secured tariff free trade with the US and constitutional authority over its resources. Also, many presumed that eventually an elected and effective Senate would exist — making the West’s interests even more secure in the Canadian union.

However, has having a prime minister, more Cabinet ministers, MPs, and senior appointees today provided the West any more power in the world — even necessary access next door? Or did outward-looking strivers like Lougheed, Manning, and Stephen Harper only effectively win greater executive authority over a progressively powerless "national" economy?

Immediately, a Barack Obama Presidential rejection of the Keystone XL pipeline would most hurt Stephen Harper. We shouldn’t be surprised, however, if Western voices join this blog in asking not only whether our impotence as a trading nation is tolerable, but whether, to a great extent, it was our choice.

Western Canadians inherited a border that’s managed by a foreign superpower and, unlike Arizonians and North Dakotans, have no vetoes or votes where the commercial destiny of this continent is shaped.


Westerners, traditionally, face up to fundamental structural barriers to their interests. (Status quo political cultures prefer to double down on diplomacy.) The substance of the slogan “The West wants in!” struck a nerve because they felt marginalized and didn’t like the feeling. Within this year, certainly before this decade grinds to a close, they’ll be feeling that way again. 

Friday, October 29, 2010

The other guy’s hate and rage

“Fifty-three per cent isn’t a good turnout (Toronto municipal election) — it’s time to swallow our pride and start either paying citizens to vote or mandating that they do — but it does mean that the voters who decided the election were positively tattooed with rage.”
-Heather Mallick, “Voters were filled with largely pointless rage,” Toronto Star, October 27, 2010 

It’s the rage these days to find consolation in electoral defeat by doubting the mental health of the electorate.  Maybe, it has something to do with a waning enthusiasm for the fight or it’s a clever strategy to discredit opponents when they win.  As a young lefty long ago myself, I’m attracted to the latter.  In any event, the easy suggestion that anyone to the right of Paul Martin Junior must be either brain dead or full of hate and rage should be called out.
The favoured targets of the moment are Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Rob Ford, the mayor-elect of Toronto as well as those who voted for them. One is an overweight introvert and the other is a fat big talker. Both can embarrass. But, does the Prime Minister survive merely on hate and hinterland paranoia? Was the mayor elected by hundreds of thousands of raging bigots? After a quick scan of the post election media, friends at Starbucks, and the positive reception to Lawrence Martin’s biography, Harperland: The Politics of Control, you would think that both men personalize and profit from a deep distemper in Canadian politics.
Whatever you call it, it isn’t new. Liberal partisans and progressives should know that there is nothing novel or particularly Albertan about “hating” Liberals. Red-Tories and New Democrats—when together in opposition, drinking beer at the Press Club—heartily loathed the “natural governing party”.  For its part, the leadership of that party raged about vile separatists year in and year out, from coast to coast, for the last forty years.  Lawrence Martin reports that Harper resents the way the Reform Party was treated by the Liberals in the 1990’s. Wow!  You don’t have to be a paranoid to recall that Preston Manning and the Reform Party were savagely branded as un-Canadian Republican stooges.
How we feel about any politician driven by an abiding determination to “get even” often depends on whether we are on his side or not. Along with Nixon and likely Harper, the Kennedy boys, Winston Churchill, Bill Clinton and Jean Chretien were also motivated by and, in crisis, sustained by pride and righteous competitiveness.
The appeal of an awkward everyman like Rob Ford is not easy to define and usually impossible to anticipate. However, his use of the anachronism “oriental” and his observation that the city is strained by the recent volume of immigration doesn’t make him or his appeal racist. Those who voted to “stop the gravy train” may be disruptive, but let’s not confuse that with unthinking rage.

Monday, October 25, 2010

The taming of Preston Manning?


“A national virtue, the tolerance and moderation of Canadians, is being turned into a liability for short-term political gains. Thus, whenever you hear a public figure or their positions being routinely characterized by their opponents and the media as ‘extreme,’ think twice. There are political extremists in Canadian politics, but 90 per cent of the time, such accusations are false.”—Preston Manning, Click here: Preston Manning, “Stop Polarizing our Discourse,” The Globe and Mail, October 21, 2010.

For a decade, as the founder and leader of the Reform Party, Preston Manning was slandered by moderation monitors as being an extremist and un-Canadian. He has every right to complain about the sloppy way politicians call each other “extremists.” However, there are troubling implications in what he said. What should we think when the accusation is accurate? 

Do only ten per cent of us hold positions that could be called “extreme”? Does our national virtue of “tolerance and moderation” not include respect for extreme opinion peacefully expressed? When the press get it right and the position is extreme, is it Canadian common sense to look away in disgust?

There are numerous radical positions waiting to be taken up by the political system—the three-E Senate of Preston Manning, sovereignty for Quebec, various forms of integration with the United States, evolving from a common currency to a common federation, the privatization of our electrical utilities, and the nationalization of universal child care, for instance.  Surely, the test for Manning—and other citizens with something to sell—is not the location of the idea on last year’s official political spectrum, but whether it appeals to our interests and our values.