Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label leadership. Show all posts
Showing posts with label leadership. Show all posts

Friday, September 16, 2016

Quit! You’ll only lose your brand.

Every successful candidate—as well as most losing ones—for President of the United States attract “public intellectuals.” They offer their services as storytellers, media whisperers, and strategic thinkers. They make a difference; they help launch and sustain good and unforgettably terrible ideas as well. And they are rewarded richly in the best sense of the word: their exceptional brains work most brilliantly around power. They must, however, swim in one of two immense pools: the Republican and Democratic parties. The action is not on the beach with the independents.

The entry fee into these ponds has lightened; old-boy passports aren’t as valuable as they once were. Presidential politics today is an extremely competitive marketplace, with demanding investors who thrive in the vicious new meritocracy. So, merit should get you in.

Exiting is not as easy: it can cost you your name, career, and friendships. It raises a character question: Can you be trusted on any team?

“Loyalty” is not just a harmless pat on the back for dutiful service. The word imposes a sin tax on exit: being known as “disloyal.” Being loyal doesn’t get you a promotion or keep the business innovative or on its toes. It simply allows the institution to not worry about potential quitters 24–7. (Insights on the power of loyalty goes to Albert O. Hirschman's "Exit, Voice and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations and States")

The above considerations partly explain why David Brooks in Time for a Realignment and avowedly partisan thinkers write passionately about the dislocation and movement of millions of voters, while largely sitting still themselves. Their squirming has generated entertaining and clever discussion—and we should appreciate that.

Joseph Nye, the liberal who coined the strategic panacea “soft power” hilariously excoriates Republican Donald Trump for being soft on Vladimir Putin and squeamish about committing US forces to any war to defend Lithuania. Conservative David Frum speaks soulfully about his dark night in the Republican Party. He chooses forthrightly to campaign against Donald Trump as a loyalist’s first step to unite conservative Republicans, later.

Their loyalty shouldn’t be overvalued. There’s another equally effective way to be intellectually and politically useful: quit.

Too little attention is paid to the virtue of picking up and leaving. America is great if only because America and it’s more timid northern cousin are populated by switchers and quitters, not only by those who keep their heads down, wait for bad times to pass, or hope that their bosses will wake up one day and stop treating them as soreheads and has-beens.

Think of those illustrious troublemakers insiders loathed at the time: Theodore Roosevelt and his Progressive Party, René Lévesque and the Party Quebecois, and Preston Manning and Reform Party.

Singing the praises of the two-party system is an establishmentarian excuse for not rocking the boat amongst the brains at the top as well as amongst the “white trash” below decks. Throughout the modern communication age, the oldest parties have set the rules and acquired for themselves tremendous advantages to ward off revolts and new competition.

The privileged, of course, have done all this to make politics less corrupt and politicking more like a profession.

Yet, there’s no compelling evidence that breaking down the quasi-monopolistic advantages for Democrats and Republicans and Liberal and Conservative parties would lead to the chaotic fragmentation of our popular democracies. Insurgencies are eventually absorbed by both adaptive competitors and by an enduring preference by voters to give one party, not coalitions, decisive power to govern.

Malcontents serve new ideas within established parties. However, they only rouse themselves when there’s reasonable prospect that neglected constituencies will exercise their freedom to move on.

More “public intellectuals” should try it—light the way, so to speak. Real change needs them.


Friday, October 10, 2014

Adapt to change? That’s what we do in the Middle East.

The elites we reward when we vote can handle hooded reactionaries in Eastern Europe and hooded reactionaries in the Middle East. It’s change at home that befuddles them.

Incumbent governments and their leaders in Canada, US, and Europe confidently seek re-election as steady international problem-solvers. They scorn isolationists and nationalist romantics, and promise to continue killing violent radicals.

It’s the height of sophistication to spell, pronounce, and accurately categorize the latest bad-boy sects abroad. At home, they use stale generalizations and stale labels to put down resistance that even breathes in the polls.

Insiders mortgage their lives to stay on top and tell us not to fear change. They ask us to trust them and, also, to run away from political "paranoids."

Our overstaffed governors know more about our pressure points, our private lives, and our political biases — literally, how to handle us — than any governing elite in history. 

And the gathering wave of political frontrunners stands for continuity. Justin Trudeau, Hillary Clinton, Thomas Mulcair, and Ed Miliband are born political animals. When they get emotional, it’s about the past.

If the West’s strategic advantage were strictly conservative, we’d be blessed.

Being decisive overseas, unfortunately, is making it less necessary for our leaders to lead change at home — where our true advantage lies.

Today’s nihilists and corrupt authoritarians are child’s play compared to the enemies Western leaders faced only two generations ago. That, alone, is hardly a bad thing. Making headline news by managing manageable problems elsewhere, however, has become addictive. And the skills necessary to address novel challenges here are not being effectively exercised.

Decision-makers and agenda-setters can’t get exercised about everything of consequence — at the same time. They learn from their successes, less from failures, and almost nothing from what they leave for their successors.

They make trade-offs and nudge us to as well. The people don’t want to elect a Jimmy Carter and a Ronald Reagan for the same term.

When history sums things up, there’s a decent chance Obama is going to score as the most transformative foreign policy President since Richard Nixon. America’s postwar baby — global capitalism — is growing despite a severe global recession. American foreign policy is becoming less burdensome, less beholden to old sentiments and arrangements in Europe and the Middle East, and US public opinion has moved along with him.

Domestically, however, there’s a decent chance he’ll be seen as another coy conservative who employed his eloquence and personal popularity to make it politically respectable to let significant problems fester. In his second term, “not doing stupid stuff” domestically has come to mean: don’t overreach, always appeal to tested homilies, and never fail conspicuously.

Tethering significant domestic responsibilities to entrenched clichés may save a handful of unproductive Democrats in Congress. But that won’t change Congress.

Doing some good is not always better than trying to do too much.

Climate change is a classic example.

Rather than repeating what every reasonable person already knows and passing executive orders that can be scrapped by the next President unilaterally, Obama could put forward a concrete legislative plan, including an unlovable carbon tax. He has the voice, if not to win immediately in Congress, at least to bind one national political party to a concrete, comprehensive response.

Obama’s healthcare accomplishment was built on the shoulders of numerous failures. So was Roosevelt’s New Deal. A viable response to climate change probably needs at least one President who can loose big as well as give strong speeches.  

One of the essential reasons the West has been more adaptive than its ideological adversaries has been the relative freedom of its leaders to overreach, to ask a little too much of the people and powerful interests — and lose.


Happily, our vanquished leaders don’t need private armies, Swiss bank accounts, or safe houses overseas. They can fail.

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

David Petraeus’s winning confession


Spring is late. Yet, green shoots of innocence and hope are popping up everywhere. The Catholic Church has a new Pope who rose to prominence in the capital of a fascist republic, and radiates in culpability and love. And just last night David Petraeus received a standing ovation for apologizing for an affair that forced his resignation as head of the CIA.

His statement came awfully late for an effective military decision-maker. Nevertheless, he did earn the best wishes of those who were listening. According to AP reporters JOHN ROGERS and SHAYA TAYEFE MOHAJER, he acknowledged unreservedly that he’d shown “extremely poor judgment.” unacceptable behavior for a “leader of an organization such as ours.”

The immediate responses to Petraeus’s statement also demonstrated the undiminished faith of American marketers in the readiness of the American people to forgive and move on. Brace yourself for the words of Howard Bragman, vice-chair of the image-building company Reputation.com:

"I think the world is open to him now," said Bragman, vice chairman of the image-building company Reputation.com. "I think he can do whatever he wants. Realistically, he can even run for public office, although I don't think he'd want to because he can make more money privately."

Think of all the surviving “Willy” Lowmans who will be shining their shoes and walking taller today.

That said, David Petraeus’s confession of private misjudgments shrinks beside the rock-hard unwillingness of his political superiors to admit to their public errors of judgment, and unacceptable behavior as the war-makers of 2003.

Friday, January 4, 2013

2013: Fewer firefighters and more architects?


Last month, during a London School of Economics symposium on the European Union a student asked whether we need fewer firefighters and more architects in positions of power. The question sounded slightly rhetorical. The audience applauded.

Four Decembers ago, on either side of the Atlantic, such an audience of political scientists would have laughed.

Whether elected as visionaries or as technocrats, leaders in Europe and North America were not required to envision, but to act. It didn’t matter then whether they were democrats or bullies, outgoing or shy, elected to office or one step removed and running central banks. They didn’t have to define the problem; they just had to fix it.

Thanks to four years of successful firefighting, it shouldn’t be surprising that the public is less awed today by can-do executive resumes and talk of imminent collapse. (Otherwise, in the US, Rick Santorum or Mitt Romney would be President-elect, and Donald Trump would be recognized as a builder and not as an arsonist.)

As people get used to breathing more easily, they’re less easily impressed and are more open to new worries--new problems that can’t be addressed by the emergency power leaders have been relying on through the Great Recession.

Centrists in Washington probably have enough votes to stabilize the public debt’s share of US GNP. North Americans should also be able to stabilize and eventually reduce CO2 emissions, in absolute terms. A Canadian-style immigration policy should eventually be adopted by the US.

Nevertheless, North American and European leaders do not know how to stay ahead of China and the other BRIC’s economically while meeting the frustrated expectations of their own middle classes. Whatever they do domestically, they don’t know how to inspire collective global action on the environment without being in charge anymore.

Firefighters have little to offer. Technocrats may agree broadly that more continental integration and less parochialism on both continents would offer the scale--and the architecture--for greater success. However, big policy, on paper, is cheap. 

The leadership task now won’t be solved literally by replacing today’s leaders with architects. However, the ones we have need to master politics’ toughest job. They need to be able to be persuasive, to convince us that we ought to try something new rather than simply replace the smoke detectors.