Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Germany. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Germany. Show all posts

Thursday, July 5, 2012

David Cameron isn’t ready to be a Norwegian or a Canadian


So long as political power within the European Union is weak and decentralized, Britain’s ultra-conservatives can tolerate being members of the club.

They get secure access to a gigantic market and participate as equals in decisions that usually require unanimity. They keep their currency and their conceit that the UK is still a first-tier power with its own unique way of doing things.

Despite their head shaking, British Tories can live with being members of a bureaucratic organization; they’re good at that. Their Commonwealth, monarchy, and House of Lords are all show and no beef.

Fear of dissolution and the unfinished necessity of creating a viable fiscal as well as monetary union, however, are raising the possibility that Europe will steadily come together as an effective federation—in which a substantial amount of power is centralized.

And in which Britain will be respected, but not as feared as Germany.

That kind of club—a federation eventually along the lines of the United States of America, which they thought would fall apart sometime in the 19th century—is not at all to their liking. So, they’re pushing for a national referendum in the hope of pulling the UK out of the European community all together.

To his credit, Prime Minister David Cameron is still rejecting the idea.

“Mr. Cameron said it was essential that Britain did not just have access to the single market but that it played a role in shaping its rules. He said he would not swap Britain’s position for that of a country like Norway which “only has access” to the single market.
“But in a sign of his precarious political balancing act, Mr. Cameron also refused to rule out the possibility of one day giving British people a choice on whether to follow the Norwegian model by leaving the EU altogether.”

It’s ironic that Cameron would shrink at the prospect of living like a Norwegian. That’s exactly the status Tories in Britain and Tories in Canada have pressed on Canadians ever since the United States was formed. 

Like Norway, Canada was always too small (and, as individuals, probably too nice) to be full-fledged, vote for vote, members of a greater liberal democratic federation. 

They rallied against economic and political integration with the US because it was too liberal. Now, they dismiss the EU because it’s bureaucratic. 

Let’s hope Cameron doesn’t back down and that he decides to re-embrace the unfinished work of building a workable European federation.

It’s only a pity Canada’s Stephen Harper isn’t engaged in a similar fight with the defeatist dogma of his Tory forefathers.

Monday, July 18, 2011

The debt-ceiling debate: a sweet spot for Anti-Americanism

There’s a sweet spot in every American crisis when prophets of America’s collapse weigh in.

Her detractors were freer to express their disdain before America became a great power. James M. McPherson’s July review in the New York Review of Books provides a timely reminder that in Europe’s exclusive parlours America’s political union has always been seen as an insolent experiment.  Referring to influential opinion in Great Britain during the darkest days of the American Civil War, he writes:

“On the whole, those most likely to express pro-Confederate or anti-American sentiments tended to be conservatives and members of the aristocracy or gentry. The Earl of Shrewsbury looked upon “the trial of Democracy and its failure” in America with pleasure. “I believe that the dissolution of the Union is inevitable, and that men before me will live to see an aristocracy established in America.”1 The voice of the British establishment, The Times, considered the downfall of “the American colossus” a good “riddance of a nightmare…. Excepting a few gentlemen of republican tendencies, we all expect, we nearly all wish, success to the Confederate cause.”2


America, today, is seen by a new generation of European intellectuals as the world’s indispensible incompetent.

America’s most wealthy friends, whether evolving constitutional monarchies like Canada and Great Britain or serial republics like France and Germany, can’t imagine life without her. Yet, with little hope of making matters better, they level the sweeping, seemingly clinical diagnosis that America’s political system is “dysfunctional.”

Canada’s leading liberal daily The Toronto Star asks whether US politicians are “really prepared to burn down the house in a bitter ideological tussle over the role, size and cost of government?”


Political suicide in freedom-loving America is conceivable. And, of course, before every crisis is resolved there is a moment when both happier times and catastrophe can be anticipated. However, the question itself is cheap.

US democracy has been engaged in an ideological “tussle” over the role and size of its federal government since 1776. Running alongside that ongoing argument, Americans have done politics well enough to create the most successful transcontinental federation in the world and build a federal government strong enough to finance the West’s side in two world wars and the Cold War, and drive the emergence of the modern global economy that is now changing America as well as every other privileged economy in the world.

David Gordon Smith sums up German editorial opinion on the debt-ceiling crisis with the plaintive headline “The US Is Holding the Whole World Hostage.” Center-left Suddeutsche Zeitung tells Congress to “think carefully about what it’s doing.” The conservative Die Welt is less restrained: “Democrats and Republicans are so hopelessly embroiled in a religious war that compromise and pragmatism are just dreams from a far-off era of reason. . . .” The mass-circulation Bild tries to be condescending complaining that America is exhibiting the “worst kind of absurd theatrics.”

Running through the piece is the assumption that Americans can’t talk about ideas without becoming extreme, that religiosity and the Tea Party drive American politics.


It’s tempting simply to say to Germany: If you’re finally sure enough of your democracy to deprecate America’s, then why not finally take on your own defence and carry your weight in the NATO alliance? Besides, would you rather have a German skinhead over an American Tea Partier as a neighbor?

Unfortunately, a constructive reply—including, steady economic growth—probably won’t dampen anti-American sentiment for long. The politics of the debt-ceiling crisis circles around the desperate desire of both of America’s great national parties to re-capture the confidence of pragmatic, mainstream opinion. Of course, that center of America is the very philistine, short-sighted, complacent America that her detractors love to hate.

Monday, June 27, 2011

America isn’t even exceptionally miserable

Foreign correspondents can report on Americans by standing in the public square and channel surfing. In order to report on the state of mind of that other Western great power—Germany—the visitor must read and listen to professional people readers.

Unlike American activists, Germans don’t wave the flags their fathers fought under. And their politics aren’t as heavily influenced by media celebrities and sensationalism. Nevertheless, Doug Saunders reports that Germans are not happy either: 

“If previous German booms were marked with a national mood of confidence and optimism, this is a prosperity of angst and fear: According to one survey, 80 per cent of Germans now believe that the future will be worse than the present, that “everything is getting worse.” There is an entire consulting industry devoted to analyzing the “national angst.”

“What we're repeatedly finding is that, despite the very good economic data, there is a huge amount of unease and uncertainty,” says Stephan Grünewald, a Cologne-based psychologist who recently interviewed 7,000 citizens for his book Germany on the Couch. “There is a manifest crisis of trust. … The Germans have at the moment a mood, a feeling that things can go to pieces, a feeling of being in a situation in which one is completely incapable of action.”

“People no longer believe in this culture of accumulation, they no longer believe in growth. ... Nuclear power, speculation, Greece, these all strengthen their feeling that things cannot go on like this. There is a kind of vacuum of meaning. And that leads to a feeling of being in the rat race, of only being focused on next week or next month, but not having any overarching vision, let alone having any sense of optimism.”


Imagine worrying about nuclear accidents, speculators and the Greeks rather than your own job and national economy.

Catching up with Germany’s economic outcomes and social services would be worthwhile, a realistic American growth agenda.  Full employment, less crime, universal health and social services, and no hot wars for a while would help most Americans feel a little more secure and surer about their country.

However, is it possible for normally observant people in any of the great powers ever again to be captured by an over-arching vision—a vision sturdier and sunnier than the constantly changing facts on the ground?

Thursday, December 23, 2010

Putting down Europe won’t make John Bolton’s America look any better

The most profound and widespread challenge is the growing sense that the EU's
common currency, the euro, may not survive in its present form, if at all.
The obvious reason is that, as a matter of economics, the euro project gives surrealism a bad name: A currency without a government was always doomed to fail. Now, there are only two choices: 1) Abandon or dramatically shrink the euro concept, or 2) increase the powers of the European Commission to oversee—and where necessary de termine—national tax and spending decisions.

Default on a major EU sovereign-debt obligation may just be just the thing to wake up the rest of Europe to get its house in order. It wouldn't be a bad lesson for Washington, either. We should worry about President Obama's staggering
deficit spending and let Europe worry about its own.

—John Bolton, “It’s Europe’s crisis: Saving the euro is up to them,” New York Post, December 21, 2010
Europe’s financial strains may reduce to a trickle the flow of European pronouncements on the competence of the US—and that, even if it lasts only for a while, ought to be savoured. However, John Bolton’s attempt to reverse the flow—to portray the EU as a sobering example of bad government that should be allowed to sink or swim on its own—is immodest, uncharitable, and self-defeating. Taking pleasure from other people’s pain has never been a characteristic of America’s winning face to the world.
Bolton advertises himself on the dust jacket of his memoirs as one “who held high-level positions in the administrations of Presidents Ronald Reagan, George H. W. Bush, and George W. Bush.” It’s not uncommon to get attention by being cocky on the way up. But, after an influential career with those three presidents, a little humility on good governance would be an excellent career transition strategy.
Even if America’s staggering deficit was Obama’s fault—which it is not and which won’t be fixed by simply reversing his measures—and even if Bolton and the last Bush presidency guessed right about how to govern Afghanistan and Iraq, Bolton’s pessimism about European governance is no more than one of those unserious cheap shots that frustrated people are wise to keep to themselves.
Of course, putative presidential candidates like John Bolton have to spend time in New York to raise money, even if they want to appeal to more conservative parts of the country. However, out in the heartland it could make people laugh to read a lecture about not bailing out Europeans in a New York newspaper—New York being the biggest bailout city in modern history and still a financial capital wedded to and sustained by trade in money and goods and services with other major markets, including Europe.
Europe may take itself too seriously too. However, Germany exports more manufactured goods to the world than the United States, and the EU 27 nations are still America’s largest market. Certainly, in a crisis, Germany has the financial capacity to keep even Spain solvent. Could we say the same thing about the US government if the bond market turns on California?
Things could go very bad without intelligent leadership on both sides of the Atlantic. However, at this moment, it is Europe’s liberals and conservatives who are actually reforming their tax policies and social entitlements. Rather than wait to be aroused by the next European crisis, Mr. Bolton might consider and speak to some of their ideas about how to solve the West’s collective problems.