Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label US taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US taxes. Show all posts

Thursday, July 12, 2012

“ObamaTax” won’t defeat Obama in November


Some consultants bank on being listened to by identifying the latest terrifying political “third rail.” Many pundits today think that Justice Roberts figuratively laid Obama across one by characterizing the individual health insurance mandate as—gasp—a tax penalty. Was the term “individual mandate” that much better? Did it really disguise something far worse—a tax?
Last year, political blogger Pat Caddell advised Obama simply to give up on being re-elected and settle for being an honorable one-time president, like his old boss Jimmy Carter. This week, Caddell’s telling Mitt Romney how to prove him right, how to lick Obama in November.

“So Romney must wield that cudgel, and wield it hard.  And so must Republicans, because if the campaign against Obamacare--the ObamaTax--is to be truly effective, it must be a top-to-bottom message.  Indeed, as we shall see, the anti-ObamaTax message could be even stronger for down-ballot Republicans than for Romney himself.  
“The challenge is to keep the focus on the tax--the ObamaTax.  Obamacare is many things, but the biggest single thing is the thing that they said it wasn’t--the ObamaTax.”  

Click on: www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2012/07/09/taxes-and-trust

There’s much to criticize, amend, and worry about in Obama’s 2,700-page liberal/conservative/public/private/federal/state health legislation to ensure universal access to America’s gigantic inflationary health care system. Fine.

(Indeed, Justice Roberts may come to be seen as Obama’s wise helper by making the states more equal and, thus, more accountable partners in its implementation and expansion.)

However, a small health tax on that fraction of American citizens who have the means but presently simply choose not to insure themselves is the least of Obama’s problems.

It’s conceivable that the Republicans might succeed in exaggerating this new tax penalty burden, for instance, repeatedly calling Obamacare one of the “biggest tax hikes on the planet.” But, will Obama actually let them get away with another “death panel” campaign?

Mitt Romney can say pretty well anything, but he can’t be Sarah Palin.

In any case, is that word “tax” always death in American politics? When it comes to accepting common sacrifices, are Americans really that exceptional? The draft and the history of US taxation suggest not.

Look north and you’ll see that typical Canadians pay quite similar levels of taxation and regularly re-elect tax-raising governments.

Really.

Bruce Bartlett’s column of May 12th includes a revealing table on personal taxes as a percent of the labor costs for an average worker in OECD countries, in 2011. The “tax wedge” on the Canadian worker was a whopping 30.8% compared to 29.5% on his American counterpart.  

Click on: http://kalamazoopost.blogspot.ca/2012/05/bruce-bartlett-us-is-low-tax-country.html

In 2004, a new McGuinty government introduced the Ontario Health Premium to collect another $3billion annually to bolster the finances of Ontario’s burgeoning public health care system. Up to $900 annually has been levied on everyone making over $20,000 ever since.

Click on: www.fin.gov.on.ca/en/tax/healthpremium/index.html

It’s not a better tax than Obama’s so-called health tax; it wasn’t discussed in the Ontario election, it doesn’t single out bad behavior, it’s harder on the working poor than on the rich, it covers only a fraction of the health system’s financial pressures, and it doesn’t lead necessarily to a better-run, more accessible system.

Nevertheless, it was quickly accepted and didn’t stop Dalton McGuinty from being re-elected twice.

The magic of the Ontario health tax is not the superior appeal of the Ontario premier. He’s not in Obama’s league. Its rationale, however, was compelling—it was seen as a health tax, necessary for additional investments in healthcare.

Ontarians, like Americans, will pay a little more if they think they’re paying to get into and keep up, respectively, the “greatest” health system in the world.

Putting the word “health” in front of a tax is very sexy. Obama can’t do better. Posthumous letters of endorsement by Harry Truman, Richard Nixon, John Kennedy, and Mother Teresa would pale by comparison.

Wednesday, September 7, 2011

Is democracy too hard on the rich?

The authors of the American constitution had good reason to fear what popular governments and voters could do to unpopular individuals, ideas, and minorities. Accordingly, they created constitutional safeguards to tie the hands of democratic government.

When the ballot was extended to include women and labor, should nation-builders also have introduced fiscal safeguards for the rich?

Underlying the vehement opposition of American conservatives today toward any measure to enhance federal tax revenues — and their support for a constitutional amendment to make new taxes and federal deficits next to impossible — surely beats a profound fear that democracy is rigged against the affluent. The reckless demos will depreciate the value of their savings, tax away what they have protected for their children, and tax their “excessive” incomes along the way.

These conservatives, of course, do not believe that government can’t do anything right; most say American government will never accidently hang an innocent man, spill nuclear fuel, or conduct an incompetent war. They fear, however, that as soon as the people start thinking again that activist government can help solve their problems, they will start using government to hurt those with means. (On the left, they are increasingly called “billionaires and millionaires.” Conservatives rally to the defense of anyone with a taxable income of over $200,000 as a “job creator.”)  

This vision of the masses lined up on Election Day to cut their betters’ throats was starkly outlined in a piece by George Bragues, assistant vice-provost and program head of business at the University of Guelph-Humber in Toronto. He asserts:

“Consequently, the state’s fiscal operations necessarily divide society into two classes — that is, between those who, on balance, receive more from the government than they are required to give it, as opposed to those who must pay more to it than they are entitled to receive from it. Following John ­Calhoun, the 19th-century American politician and writer who developed this analysis, we can refer to the first class as tax consumers and the second as tax payers.

“Amid the struggle that occurs between these two, democracy favours the tax consumers. In every society that has developed beyond the hunter-gatherer stage, wealth has been distributed unequally, that is, concentrated in a group making up less than 50% of the population, indeed often a good deal less than that. At the same time, democracy in principle empowers whoever can garner 50% plus one of the votes. To an ambitious democratic politician, the optimal strategy to win elections is obvious: Promise the not-so-wealthy majority a wide assortment of government-supplied benefits in the hopes of passing on the costs to the wealthier minority. In other words, forge a coalition of tax consumers that outnumbers the tax payers.”


Where have these ambitious politicians been for the last hundred years?

Certainly, wealthy tyrannies like Saudi Arabia bribe their subjects with ridiculously cheap public services in order to keep them servile politically. Certainly, some anti-democratic capitalist regimes like China’s have been able to create an impressive number of billionaires — for at least a generation. Certainly, democratic governments can be corrupt, bribing groups of voters as well as rich patrons. Nevertheless, the masses have hardly forced governments to systematically exploit the wealthy.

It’s a pure pandering by an academic, and paranoia by the well off, to imagine that a majority of voters turn out in elections to soak the rich. America has the most competitive mass democracy in the world — regularly shunning tax measures that would clip the wings of the rich. America’s business class is the most affluent in the world — and the safest. Also, America’s most affluent families are the biggest beneficiaries of public spending on the arts, health research, and advanced education.

Clearly, a shared idea of fair treatment and mutual gain — of a just society — disciplines our politics and permits our economies to grow. That idea, not a predatory game theory, has allowed for fantastically different economic outcomes for individuals and a decent level of social solidarity.

The challenge now is not to shrink our democratic rights, but to design tax policies that will strike people as fair.






Friday, August 19, 2011

US Tax reform is coming


Except in a handful of wicked American cities, you could not get elected a hundred years ago without being able to talk intelligently about the family farm and commodity markets. Economic dangers and opportunities were immediate and hotly discussed; the stakes were high and, consequently, the voters were economically literate. Is it possible that those times are returning?  
This summer, twenty-four hour coverage of the economy and Washington’s finances—and extreme political talk on both—may be doing the economy measurable harm, as well as educating the public. Talk of national bankruptcy has surely had something to do with the decline in consumer confidence, an ever rising savings rate, and now stalling industrial production.
Consumers, investors and employers have been told that the glass in Washington is not just half empty, but half full of poison.   
Being unready to accept failure or live for long in pain, the next response by Americans is likely to be higher political participation and, just possibly, less tolerance for Democrat and Republican clichés. Over the next fifteen months, it could get harder and harder to sound stupid and irresponsible.
Already, two fire lines against fresh thinking are in trouble. “No new taxes” and higher taxes on “millionaires and billionaires” are perceptively giving away to calls for tax reform and, yes, some new revenues. The prospect of a more robust tax base would make short-term stimulus more credible and, therefore, more effective.
Singling out too few taxpayers for an income tax increase sounds too convenient. It doesn’t sound statesmanlike, it sounds envious. Alternatively, calling any new tax “socialistic” or a “job killer” is wearing thin. American governments spend like Canadians. Ultimately, they’ll have to pay equivalent taxes too. Most important, there is no credible way to raise serious money without asking more from the rich.
(Okay. Let’s set aside the extraordinary growth in wealth of the top 0.1% of Americans over the last thirty years. It is not demagogic, however, to note that the top 10% of Americans control two-thirds of America’s wealth. The Democrat’s proposed tax increase on those earning over $200,000 is stale, doesn’t raise enough, and doesn’t encourage economic growth. Nevertheless, it is not radically left or substantially different from most conservative and mainstream alternative ideas to modernize the tax code. They all hit those with high incomes and indulgent tax breaks—because that’s where the money is. This isn’t a class-war issue. It’s about ability to pay.)
Clearly, the business community has discovered, albeit, ridiculously late, that brinksmanship, polarization and paralysis in Washington are very bad for business. Also, on his Midwest tour this week, Obama must have noted that his audiences want him to test Congress with new measures immediately, not simply sound reasonable. 

They may respond well to another “give ’m Hell Harry” next fall. But, for this fall, they want an LBJ problem-maker.

Wednesday, August 3, 2011

Austerity politics and business confidence

The economic recovery has lavishly rewarded those already at the top and made it much more difficult for tens of millions of other voters to realize the American dream. Observations like that get into politics and turn business leaders off.

Yet, the business community’s favorite, if not exclusive political voice, the Republican Party presently sees political advantage in polarizing America’s mass democracy. They portray the Democrats—the oldest political party in the union—as European social democrats and would happily privatize social insurance rather than ever raise a tax. With global capitalism starting to look more and more like an idea designed for China’s future, not America’s, business planners complain about political uncertainty and wait for the restoration of “business confidence.”

It’s not good enough that governments—local, state, and national—are entering a long, fraught period of austerity. They want assurances that scrambling politicians won’t talk themselves into doing anything to disrupt their world view. Without that assurance, many will sit on their hands and talk about grand expansion plans suspended in save files. Kevin Carmichael in The Globe and Mail captured these sentiments under the headline “Tax uncertainty handcuffs U.S. firms.”

“I could hire another 15 or 20 people, but I’m scared to death to do it because I’m afraid some tax change will come through,” said Clint Greenleaf, chief executive officer of Greenleaf Book Group LLC, a publisher based in Austin, Tex.

“It stifles growth,” Mr. Greenleaf said of Washington’s inability to come up with a coherent approach to taxes. “I’m not going to leverage the future of my 50 employees on the hope that the government won’t hurt me in the future.”


Is that what’s left of the legendary animal spirit of American entrepreneurship?

Did the 20th-century offer business a sure thing? Did American business then not notice that real socialists actually won elections in the United States, that both Roosevelts and, occasionally, a majority of Americans actually believed that elected governments, not business should drive economic reform?

Today, a majority of Americans say America is on the “wrong track.” Not long ago, a majority of Americans worried that American business was on the wrong track. And there was a time when the best and brightest sought public service—not MBAs.

The climate for business generally has never been better than it is now. In Canada, one political party stood for lower corporate taxes across the board and won a majority this spring. Developed and emerging economies all tackled the recession with measures to restore the private sector. Every Washington bipartisan commission that has addressed the US structural deficit has called for more intelligent growth incentives for business and for lower corporate tax rates.

Unless Mr. Greenleaf is worried about a particularly egregious tax loophole his business relies on or, in fact, has no strong commercial reason to hire more people right now, he should welcome, not worry about tax reform in Washington.

Waiting for things to calm down in Washington is naïve. Politics don’t slow down in difficult times. It could, as likely, get more radical and not limit itself to trimming entitlements and cutting bureaucracy.

How revenues are raised is as open to change as how revenues are spent. Unless mainstream business finds ways, with government, to restore shared prosperity, government, with others, will ultimately try other people’s ideas.

Friday, February 25, 2011

Why “We’re broke!” is bogus US budget rhetoric

Sadly, “We’re broke” may impress the poor but it won’t impress the bond market and foreign lenders. For the time being, they’ll keep purchasing US government bonds whether US politicians cry poor or not. The US budget deficit is a political crisis, not a fiscal crisis. America’s politicians simply aren’t ready yet to take feasible actions to address it.
Unlike Greece, Iceland and Ireland, America’s economy and its people are generating enough money to pay their way and maintain their enviable standard of living. The structural deficit—a gap in revenues and spending that persists even when the economy is operating at full potential—has been solved on paper by several technically credible strategies. The president’s own debt commission provided a complete package that emphasized long-term restraint in entitlements and modest tax increase. Implementing everything at once would probably create a recession but that isn’t necessary.
The credit markets recognize that the US economy has ample capacity to carry a sustainable nation budget. Furthermore, recent history also confirms that it can chose leaders—and re-elect leaders—who loathe waste but can raise taxes. Reagan, the Bushes and Bill Clinton all said the era of big government was over. All increased spending and, reluctantly, all but one raised taxes.
The Financial Times commented:
“Nor does either political party wish to air another economic reality, that America’s tax burden as a proportion of national income is currently a low 24 per cent, according to Credit Suisse. This is 2 percentage points below the 50-year average and 4 percentage points below the late-1990s peak. Under Mr. Obama’s proposed budget only a quarter of the planned deficit reduction comes from tax rises. Republicans no doubt think even this is unreasonable. But the truth is there is still capacity for taxes to take more of the strain.”
America, thank goodness, doesn’t need saints for leaders. It may be badly managed. But mere mortals can learn to be better managers.