Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label US congressional elections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US congressional elections. Show all posts

Monday, October 3, 2011

Republican advantage: the “strongman” presidency

Republicans have almost totally abandoned their fear campaign against the embattled Barack Obama. Their street philosophers and Tea Party freedom-fighters are losing their momentum. Every day, we hear less about the constitution and more and more about how to be a boss.
Republican strategists and fundraisers are not simply running away from the shrillest of the Republican candidates for president. Rather, they’re looking eagerly for a demonstrably muscular candidate who can run against a weak president—a president every bit as American and as unforgivably ineffectual as Jimmy Carter and Gerald Ford.
Michael Goodwin wrote this in the New York Post:
“His is a vision best described as pragmatic idealism. He is about taking direct and forceful action without ever losing sight of the big picture.
“As he said in his stirring speech at the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library in California, “The rule for effective government is simple: When you see a problem, you fix it.”
“Later, he added, “You can’t wait for someone else to do it when you sit in the Oval Office.”
Without the reference to the Reagan Library, this encomium to Governor Chris Christie could have been written by several equally shrewd columnists in the New York Times, in 2008, about Barack Obama.
Obama, who also talks to himself as well as the lowest common denominator, could have easily said every bit of it—only adding that a spirit of bipartisanship in Congress will be required as well.
Today, Obama doesn’t scare anyone—in America. But he isn’t called a “pragmatic idealist” because Republicans won’t let him get anything big done. 
Here’s the cruel beauty of a Christie candidacy: with a non-ideological tough guy as the star candidate for the presidential nomination, Republicans in Congress, in the shadows, can continue to block Obama’s domestic initiatives. (Conversely, without the distracting excitement of Christie, every week of paralysis in Congress further highlights Republican legislators as obstructionists.)
Nevertheless, whatever the New Jersey governor does, the Democrats are left with a dangerous problem: Americans are desperate for effective leadership, but they see that an eminently level-headed Democrat can’t get much done.
Probably millions of independent voters who support Obama’s program today would drop him now for another so-called effective president like Ronald Reagan.
He can’t win and stay the same. Obama’s leadership potential can’t be re-imagined without a clear legislative win on jobs and the economy this fall or without, shall we say, a rather vicious and winning campaign against the re-election of an obstructionist Republican Congress next fall.
It can be argued that the capacity of the two-party system to express what a majority of Americans want is at stake. The constitution doesn’t insist that only center-right presidents can lead. Nevertheless, a sane case can be made that that’s exactly what a decisive faction in the US Congress believes.
Remember, even president George Bush’s economic emergency legislation was torpedoed by the same faction (then without a brand name) when the financial system nearly collapsed in September 2008.
There is a pattern of recklessness that only the voters can break. There are many things Democrats may not understand about American exceptionalism. However, they alone, as a national party in Washington, still seem to know when to cooperate with a pragmatic president—Republican or Democrat—when the nation’s economy is in peril. 

Friday, December 24, 2010

You can lose when you're doing something important

One conspicuous symptom of our miserable times is the number of politicians leaving careers in defeat or being written off well before their next election. Most noted has been the defeat of some 54 incumbents in the November US congressional elections.
But political exile is common elsewhere. In Canada, Gordon Campbell, the Premier of British Columbia, was effectively chased out of office for expanding the tax base. Nationally, Stephane Dion, the Liberal Party’s former leader, summarily lost his job after unsuccessfully advocating a carbon tax to fight climate change.  Today, in London, Nick Clegg, leader of the Liberal Democratic Party has, in one season, gone from being Britain’s most liked politician to “Nick Clegg, Dick Head!”
A great deal of human capital has been forcefully withdrawn from public service and many good people are finding themselves with fewer friends.
Today, with so many really smart people, with high incomes, dependent on the favourable opinions of voters, defeat causes many to shudder like seeing a bat at dusk. Increasingly, consultants treat defeat as a medical illness; insisting that with the proper application of market intelligence and personal discipline other politicians can avoid the same fate.
However, political defeat is not a medical condition or a freakish occurrence. It is a good politician’s unshakable companion. Competent representative democracy could not carry on without it.
We know stories about Presidents and Prime Ministers who stood by their convictions. However, an equally relevant and inspiring book on the subject of political courage was written by an American historian about Winston Churchill’s followers in the House of Commons in the 1930s. Lynne Olsen, in “Troublesome Young Men,” tells the story of the handful of back-benchers who defied Chamberlain’s policy of appeasement, risking their careers and social standing against a massive majority in Parliament and in the country. What is striking about these mavericks was their youth, savvy and ambition. Individually, most all of them rightfully aimed for high political office. (Two, in fact, eventually became Prime Ministers.) Despite their personal ambitions, they stood against the professionals and with Winston Churchill, a loner, a has-been, a bore to many, who appeared to lack the humility and discipline to tack or make new friends.
The contemporary political victims noted earlier are not amateurish or arrogantly disdainful of the preferences of their constituents either. By and large, they are hard working representatives, not especially disputatious or headstrong. Their unpopularity was born in conscious efforts to tackle important challenges, to serve an urgent public interest.
Furthermore, they see themselves as moderates and pragmatic; their positions were unpopular even though they were often compromises as well.  Nevertheless, on climate change, fiscal stability and universal healthcare, these modern politicians recognized that a viable response to the problem at hand required their support, whether that response was popular yet or not.
If there is anything inspiring about 2010 to take into a bracing New Year it is not the public’s ability to rage, but the continuing ability of a goodly number of politicians to pay for their principles.