Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Stephane Dion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stephane Dion. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 13, 2014

Conservative Tim Hudak’s Winston Churchill Moment

There’s a virus sleeping in the heads of most recognizable politicians on this continent. It makes them try to get away, if only once, with what I’ve dubbed: A Winston Churchill Moment. They want to show courage and conspicuous intellectual integrity.

Stephane Dion in Canada and Paul Ryan in the US Congress are ideal examples. They broke the strict rules of our bland politics to stand apart — from their peers and from their own unappealing images. They were convinced that "bold" fiscal and environment policies would enhance their stature — and fill gaps in their formal education.

Rather than stand with Churchill in history, they joined the swelling crowd around that literary invention: Don Quixote. And, certainly, the WCM virus is dangerously active in the Ontario election’s temporary front-runner, Conservative Tim Hudak.

Before elaborating, please accept that I’m out to protect us, not discourage policy-driven campaigns. The failure of “chivalrous” gestures does not reflect poorly on our maturity. Not being easily led near a cliff is nothing to be embarrassed about. History’s folly is fueled by the bad ideas we buy, not the ones we reject.  

Tim Hudak expressed his Winston Churchill Moment in the carefully chiseled and widely quoted cornerstone policy:

“If I have to trade off 100,000 jobs in the bureaucracy for one million new jobs in the private sector creating wealth, that’s a tradeoff I would do any second,” he told a town hall meeting in Barrie. “It’s not easy, I take no joy in this, but it has to be done if we want job creators to put more people on the payroll in our province.”

The best that has been said about this statement is that it’s “radical.” Nevertheless, it distorts both conservative economics and any common-sense conservative way to appeal for votes.

In placing his cuts right up against a million new jobs, it’s entirely reasonable to presume that he’s asking voters to endorse the layoff of 100,000 Ontario workers. Also, in placing his payroll savings against eliminating the provincial deficit in the next two fiscal years, he’s left little room for unfilled vacancies, retirements, and the private sector contracting out to significantly reduce the number of actual layoffs.

The hurried nature of his bloody prophesy certainly separates Hudak from his smarmy Keynesian pump-priming opponents. However, as stated starkly above, it also separates him from the economics of the only Conservative prime minister since the Great Depression that is better trusted in managing the economy than Liberals.

Harper’s federal deficit-reduction targets respect provincial spending cost pressures, aren’t leading to provincial job cuts, and are being absorbed by a Canada-wide economic recovery that is in far better shape than Ontario’s.

Harper isn’t terribly popular and it’s forgivable not to drop his name gratuitously. Still, on managing the economy back to sustainable growth, he still beats the competition — and did nothing in the last two restraint budgets to panic Liberals and New Democrats into uniting to defeat him at the polls.

Asking for a mandate to fire tens of thousands of people is as stupid for a conservative as asking for a mandate to raise middle class taxes by the left.

Voters rightfully suspect it’s not in their interest to help their leaders do the nasty things they must do sparingly.


These "courageous" gestures are common currency amongst retired public administrators and tenured academics. Only when struck by the WCM virus should a sane politician be excused for taking one up.

Friday, December 24, 2010

You can lose when you're doing something important

One conspicuous symptom of our miserable times is the number of politicians leaving careers in defeat or being written off well before their next election. Most noted has been the defeat of some 54 incumbents in the November US congressional elections.
But political exile is common elsewhere. In Canada, Gordon Campbell, the Premier of British Columbia, was effectively chased out of office for expanding the tax base. Nationally, Stephane Dion, the Liberal Party’s former leader, summarily lost his job after unsuccessfully advocating a carbon tax to fight climate change.  Today, in London, Nick Clegg, leader of the Liberal Democratic Party has, in one season, gone from being Britain’s most liked politician to “Nick Clegg, Dick Head!”
A great deal of human capital has been forcefully withdrawn from public service and many good people are finding themselves with fewer friends.
Today, with so many really smart people, with high incomes, dependent on the favourable opinions of voters, defeat causes many to shudder like seeing a bat at dusk. Increasingly, consultants treat defeat as a medical illness; insisting that with the proper application of market intelligence and personal discipline other politicians can avoid the same fate.
However, political defeat is not a medical condition or a freakish occurrence. It is a good politician’s unshakable companion. Competent representative democracy could not carry on without it.
We know stories about Presidents and Prime Ministers who stood by their convictions. However, an equally relevant and inspiring book on the subject of political courage was written by an American historian about Winston Churchill’s followers in the House of Commons in the 1930s. Lynne Olsen, in “Troublesome Young Men,” tells the story of the handful of back-benchers who defied Chamberlain’s policy of appeasement, risking their careers and social standing against a massive majority in Parliament and in the country. What is striking about these mavericks was their youth, savvy and ambition. Individually, most all of them rightfully aimed for high political office. (Two, in fact, eventually became Prime Ministers.) Despite their personal ambitions, they stood against the professionals and with Winston Churchill, a loner, a has-been, a bore to many, who appeared to lack the humility and discipline to tack or make new friends.
The contemporary political victims noted earlier are not amateurish or arrogantly disdainful of the preferences of their constituents either. By and large, they are hard working representatives, not especially disputatious or headstrong. Their unpopularity was born in conscious efforts to tackle important challenges, to serve an urgent public interest.
Furthermore, they see themselves as moderates and pragmatic; their positions were unpopular even though they were often compromises as well.  Nevertheless, on climate change, fiscal stability and universal healthcare, these modern politicians recognized that a viable response to the problem at hand required their support, whether that response was popular yet or not.
If there is anything inspiring about 2010 to take into a bracing New Year it is not the public’s ability to rage, but the continuing ability of a goodly number of politicians to pay for their principles.