Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label US Election. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US Election. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

The debt ceiling crisis is serious, because it’s political

Most crises are brought to Washington from the real world. And—being real—they’re usually dealt with in a businesslike manner. The prospect of federal bankruptcy this summer, however, is overwhelmingly borne of political calculation. For this reason, no one should be sure it will be resolved intelligently.

Raising the debt ceiling by a couple of trillion dollars isn’t sexy; it isn’t something either party wishes to do alone. Still, it must be raised to finance the latest short-term and medium-term tax and spending policies of both Democrats and Republicans. The capital markets, business, and academic economists fortunately all agree: the US federal government is carrying a structural deficit but is several years away from crowding out private borrowing or becoming a high-risk, high-interest rate borrower itself. 

The president and Congress leaders are huddled over multi-trillion-dollar, decade-long options they say they must make “adult decisions” about in the next couple of weeks. They’ll likely fail and that probably will be a good thing.

There is no honorable excuse to even try to settle the shape of federal taxes, defence, and social spending for the next ten years behind closed doors this July. Washington may have been irresponsible for a generation—but that doesn’t mean it’s insolvent, facing a takeover by the IMF, or about to pay double-digit interest rates on its bonds.

The “crisis” has been concocted out of trends—trends that neither justify business as usual nor nihilistic panic. The Congressional Budget Office set the stage in January with this statement:

“For 2011, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that if current laws remain unchanged, the federal budget will show a deficit of close to $1.5 trillion, or 9.8 percent of GDP. The deficits in CBO's baseline projections drop markedly over the next few years as a share of output and average 3.1 percent of GDP from 2014 to 2021. Those projections, however, are based on the assumption that tax and spending policies unfold as specified in current law. Consequently, they understate the budget deficits that would occur if many policies currently in place were continued, rather than allowed to expire as scheduled under current law.


Note the sentence: “Those projections, however, are based on the assumption that tax and spending policies unfold as specified in current law.” The federal deficit will decline substantially as the economy recovers and revenues grow—if Congress does not again extend income tax cuts, does not let stimulus spending lapse, and does not repeal the projected savings in the Affordable Health Care Act.

We are facing a financial crisis at the behest of a series of political considerations. Republicans want to be able to extend all the tax cuts and kill “Obamacare.” They’d like a bi-partisan deal this summer to make their tax cuts appear affordable in next year’s election. Furthermore, Republicans want a deal on entitlements now in order to blunt the Democrat campaign against the Ryan Plan to reform Medicare. Obama knows that a longer-term deal would significantly improve his reputation on the economy and weaken Republican claims that he is an extreme tax-and-spend president.

Effectively, both parties are trying to set the table for a winning election by settling extremely difficult and legitimate election issues in the debt-ceiling legislation. 

This is ridiculously ambitious and Machiavellian at the same time. Something modest will soon look more adult.

Once the chest-beaters tire, Obama ought to select from the negotiations a trillion dollar down payment on spending cuts and fiscal targets those Democrats, swing state Republicans, and the economy can bear. He should leave taxes and social entitlements to the next election. Let the people decide which team has the most sensible long-term plan.

If the Republicans in the House of Representatives actually defeat legislation to raise the debt ceiling on the above basis, then Obama will have his chance to address an historic crisis—one with real villains.

Friday, June 24, 2011

America is strong enough for a moderate President

The closer we get to the next presidential election the more the economy will be viewed through partisan lens. The greater the temptation will be to misread what’s going, to radicalize the times to justify radical alternatives.

Karl Rove, the Republican advisor who puts trends before ideas, has neatly tied Obama to the economy:

“At the same time, objective circumstances like an anaemic economy and bad decisions not only matter; they become very nearly dispositive. Mr. Obama is now at the mercy of policies and events he has set in motion. He can't escape accountability, especially on the economy. He's not done yet, but it will be tough to recover.”


This analysis isn’t crazy—high unemployment does discredit incumbents. However, today’s economic data doesn’t justify radical measures—either from the right or the left. For now, an “anaemic” recovery is probably all a highly levered America can ask for and is probably a whole lot better than the alternatives.

It’s been headline news in every self-consciously sober newspaper this week that the US Federal Reserve has lowered its growth forecast for the next two years. The unemployment rate may not fall below 8% by the time of the election in November 2012.

Nevertheless, along with the IMF and the OECD, the Fed predicts that the American economy will continue to recover—to grow slightly above its underlying potential. They shaved their growth forecast by 0.2% because of two significant well known external shocks, the Japanese earthquake and the surge in global crude oil prices.

Nevertheless, America’s vision of open markets and broad-based capitalism is still winning converts and driving economic development globally.  The US dollar is more competitive, manufacturers are exporting aggressively, Asian free-enterprise economies have neither turned protectionist nor collapsed, and America’s three biggest political allies and markets—Japan, Germany, and Canada—are all growing strongly, buying US goods and services and enriching US corporate profits.

The markets are not forcing Washington or presidential candidates to choose between financial bankruptcy, social insurance, modern infrastructure, and the animal spirits of American investors and bondsmen. The capital markets responded well to the bi-partisan federal budget deal earlier this year and aren’t telling the government to tear it up this summer. Trends in public finances and in private job creation and income growth all say: America, you can’t hide from change, but you needn’t panic.

This may be one of those rare moments in America when it isn’t good politics to be optimistic. A Rasmussen survey this week elicited that 65% of Americans think America is on the wrong track. 


Click on: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/commentary/chrystia-freeland/why-obamas-message-of-economic-hope-could-backfire/article2073217/

Millions are unemployed and millions more are unhappy with their jobs and the market value of their real estate. However, we should be wary of political figures that use the phrase “America’s on the wrong track” to display their superior patriotism, to short circuit complex discussion and, while applying the pressure of a presumed emergency, push for extreme change.  

Barack Obama may lose the next election. However, his temperate presidency was quick enough to tame an extraordinarily dangerous recession. His presidency does stand in the way of radical change. Next year, the public will decide whether he is timid or serving their best interests.

Monday, November 8, 2010

With the U.S. election over, what next?

Here are post-election statements by three powerful Republicans about how the winners should conduct themselves in Washington. These comments were not shouted out at rallies but expressed with care, after a good night’s sleep:
“If the administration wants cooperation, it will have to begin to move in our direction.”
—Mitch McConnell, Republican Senate Minority Leader
“President Obama must decide whether he will heed the will of the people and work with us to address their concerns, or continue on a path the people have rejected.”
—John Boehner, next Speaker of the House of Representatives
“Tea Party Republicans were elected to go to Washington and save the country—not be co-opted by the club. So put on your boxing gloves. The fight begins today.”
—Jim De Mint, Republican senator from South Carolina

Before the super-rich and affluent pensioners discovered that influencing elections was more fun than buying lobbyists to seduce the winners, elections were, in large part, amateur affairs. Elections cleared the air, punished failure, and attracted new talent. When the elections were over, government got back to making decisions, with the influential assistance of professional policy advisors.
Pollsters and party organizers were invited in, from time to time, and would draw attention to the electoral consequences of actions taken in the self-important climate of the modern super state. But, after elections, Washington steadily returned to its core business—a center of government overseen by representatives of the people.
Politicians who got up every morning claiming to speak for and be bound hand-and-foot by “the will of the people” were dismissed as either unqualified to make decisions or shirkers more interested in the next election than the task of governing.
Two years ago, it was palpable that President–elect Barack Obama wanted to restore that traditional style of government. Certainly, for him, it would have been a pretty good fit. He’s not a backroom backslapper, but he’s very smart, and traditional government is far more disciplined and demanding than the so-called “permanent campaign” waged in Washington today.
After a $4 billion election, however, it doesn’t look very likely that electoral politics’ vast consulting beehive will defer to the more cerebral concerns of good government. Most pundits in Canada and in the United States anticipate at least two more years of legislative gridlock and, at best, small gestures to avoid both sides looking completely inept.
This prediction could turn out to be wrong. Not because today’s observers unfairly underestimate the motives of Washington politicians but because events may not let them get away with it. Benign circumstances allow for unimaginable mediocrity. But America is again approaching bracing times. There is no international mechanism to bail it out, and every day fresh questions are asked about its financial integrity and strategic prospects. So, American leaders may again have to act with the audacity—without paralyzing regard for partisan interests—they demonstrated only two years ago. Saving the banking industry, staving off depression, and stabilizing the world trading system deserved bipartisan attention and, fortunately, for a while, got it.
As just happened in Great Britain, America’s executive and legislative leaders may have no choice but to agree on a fiscal policy consistent with economic growth, social peace, and a trustworthy currency.  As with Britain’s Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, Republicans and Democrats in position of responsibility may have to sign on to their own “unavoidable budget.” As in other democracies with deficits over 10% of GNP, American leaders may have to make decisions on taxes and spending that were not been preapproved in the last election. 

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

US Election night on TV

—David Brooks of the The New York Times coldly offered, “The country has been unhappy for six years and is still bouncing around.” Hope Obama is less philosophical.
—Colin Robertson, a Washington observer in Ottawa, suggested to the CBC’s Amanda Lang that “The US has an allergy to taxation.” When was the last time Canadians went to the polls to vote for a tax increase?
—CBC’s “Connect with Mark Kelly” leads the pack for smug Canadians. Its election coverage was back-screened with the theme “America Divided.” It concentrated on Tea Party wing nuts and nostalgia for Obama’s election of 2008. Paul Hunter, CBC, Washington recalled the feel of Washington that previous election night. Apparently, people were actually going around saying that Obama “will take us to the promised land.” Was Obama’s message really that shallow? Was Hunter even listening to Obama’s sombre election-night speech? The point of the show seemed to be that no one in America listens or votes with any care, that America is having a nervous break-down . . . tune in for more.
—Kentucky Senate winner Dr. Rand Paul’s acceptance speech was the most intriguing. It came the closest to saying something worth mulling over: “America is exceptional but not inherently so.” He seems to want to risk saying something new and, like Obama, has as sense of occasion born of a sense of his own importance. Clearly, the political frustrations of his father have fed his ambition, not tempered it.
—The size of the flags draped behind the politicians had no relationship to the size of their ideas.
—The next speaker of the House of Representatives, John Boehner, offered the most dramatic performance. With a boy’s grimace he exclaimed, “I spent my whole life chasing the American dream.” He teared up and enumerated the lowly jobs he’d taken to rise out of poverty and be a success. A true outsider probably does see the American dream as something you must chase, with insolence and defiance. He may be a Republican insider but he revealed more genuine anger than all the gregarious patriots around Sarah Palin.
—The victors all got the same message: Americans are desperately worried about the national debt and demand “fiscal discipline.” None offered a hint about how they’ll take that message to their offices in the morning. It’s more likely their lenders rather than the pollsters will force reform.
—Political junkies in Toronto aren't holding election parties. Maybe this one isn’t that important?