Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Angela Merkel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Angela Merkel. Show all posts

Thursday, July 16, 2015

Blessed are the closers

Whether we agree with everything Angela Merkel and Barack Obama resolved in unfriendly but decisive negotiations with Greece and Iran this week, we should celebrate that closers still make it to the top in these perilous times.

Nothing in the rulebook of contemporary politics favors closing. Endlessly spinning good intentions, turning disputes over to judges or public commissions, or simply waiting on the sidelines to attack is always safer than bringing the game to a stop.

Yet some of the people we elect do step out of the routines of the status quo. They don’t just show up for the group photo and sit as long as it takes to complete the agenda. The closers own the outcome. And that, gloriously, sets them apart.

Intelligent closers don’t look for wins compulsively or squander capital simply to help sex up a communiqué. They are disciplined by the fact that when they truly win big, they risk their futures and limit their appeal as well as make their mark.

The forgiving machinery of simply carrying on is rudely sidelined, and its busy helpers are diminished. Professional survivors feel smaller. Those great decisions that pay off over time can leave the most cerebral conferences with the feel of Waterloo the next morning.

Barack Obama will never be a left-liberal icon, let alone a cocktail socialist, after securing universal health care without a single public insurer. And Pierre Trudeau’s liberal constitutional legacy includes tacky accommodations: for instance, an unelected Senate and the Charter’s notwithstanding override.

Closers learn later, after the deed is done, whether they were liberators or bullies, whether they secured “peace in our time” or were appeasers, whether they will be honored at, or not invited to, their party’s next convention.

In our neighborhood, today, we’ll soon find out whether Stephen Harper will betray dairy farmers or win equal access to the burgeoning Pacific free trade area. Later this year, we may find out whether the leader of Canada’s Liberal Party can support, conceivably join, a left government not led by a Liberal.


But let’s acknowledge that the drama of closing also includes the bracing chance that closers can pay with their careers and, if not recently, with their lives. Canada’s unsung closer today must surely be Shawn Atleo, former National Chief of First Nations, who paid with his career for negotiating and, then, actually signing a new Aboriginal education framework with a Prime Minister every grassroots lobby loves to hate.

Monday, June 24, 2013

‘Historic’ speeches and elections aren’t what we need


We live in an age that pines to witness history—if not make it.

The most entertaining and convenient opportunities for experiencing together the tingle of big news are: "historic" presidential elections and "historic" presidential speeches.

We’re told that history may be made; the odds are usually set at 50–50. In effect, "historic" is now a promotional term.

"Historic" is a high-powered polemical benchmark we use to advance our agenda and derail our opponents. Last week, the word was busy undermining Barack Obama and advancing Hillary Clinton.  

We could see for ourselves that Obama’s second speech in Berlin didn’t inspire. He appeared tired, fumbled too many words, and didn’t lift his heat-drenched audience of invited sophisticates. Later, it was duly reported that they were generally disappointed. For failing to inspire—to transcend concerns in Europe about America’s numerous wrong-doings —columnists including the National Post’s Rex Murphy labeled Obama as the "Ordinary President."

Murphy compared Obama’s performances to the speeches of Jack Kennedy in 1963 and Ronald Reagan in 1987—both during the Cold War, when Berlin was surrounded by tanks and a cinder-block wall capped with shard glass and barbed wire. Obama didn’t offer one remarkable line in league with “I’m a Berliner” or “Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this Wall.” Apparently, those lines were historic; Kennedy and Reagan demonstrated their reach as charismatic presidents.

Berlin, then, was a dream city for US presidential oratory. It’s less so today.

Then, Berliners were literally anxious and eager participants; they came out in the hundreds of thousands to help the Leader of the Free World make a great speech about their freedom—and, by doing so, help all Americans like Berliners that much more.

Berlin’s prosperity and survival as a free city depended on the support of the President of the United States and each president’s confidence that voters back home also supported massive US commitments to West Europe and the democratic city of West Berlin. (Can you imagine influential Berliners then complaining aloud that American presidents talk too easily about freedom, while permitting discrimination against American blacks and ignoring the importance of building a more robust social safety net?)

Today, Berliners don’t worry about their freedom. If you want to excite German nerves today, in fact, you talk about what Germany must commit to maintain Europe’s solidarity and how much more they must sacrifice to restore the economies of the rest of Europe.

If Obama had wanted to give an exciting speech, he could have talked about America’s more complete and more successful economic federation. He could have scorned the complainers in London and elsewhere who think Europe’s unifiers went too far in creating the Euro-zone and a European Parliament. Maybe next time.

Great speeches are influential. However, they are usually divisive. Only in time do we learn whether they made a difference. And that’s when we should feel free to call them "historic."

By that measure, neither Kennedy nor Reagan nor Obama, as yet, made historic speeches in Berlin. Kennedy made no new friends or enemies. Gorbachev didn’t take down the Wall. And Obama hasn’t yet convinced Europe to pay its fair share of the burden of maintaining the peace.

Apparently, it’s also okay today to bill elections in advance as "historic." Politico reports: Hillary Clinton wants a female president "in my lifetime":

“She added that President Barack Obama’s election was historic, and said, ‘I hope that we will see a woman elected because I think it would send exactly the right historic signal to girls, women as well as boys and men. And I will certainly vote for the right woman to be president.’”

Clearly, Hillary Clinton has recovered from her exhausting years as a diplomat. Unsheathed self-promotion, also, can be fun and, in her case, is reassuring. She can thrive in serving a former rival and then enjoy serving herself.

Her thesis on the presidency, however, is shopworn and weak.

Obama’s first term record and its vindication in his re-election made his first election historic, not the 2008 election itself. His victory simply confirmed that a black man could win the presidency. Electing Hillary Clinton would confirm that the polls and conventional wisdom are right: that a woman can be president of the United States. America can join the ranks of such high-regarding and demanding democracies as Great Britain, Germany, Israel, and India.

Another successful role model for young women would be welcome but wouldn’t, in itself, solve or even improve the odds of solving those problems at home and abroad that may make the next presidency historic.

Furthermore, there’s much that is parochial and arbitrary about the proposition that an American women is needed in the White House to inspire American women to succeed in politics. Liberals may not identify with Angela Merkel or Margaret Thatcher. However, in addressing "women problems" in professional politics, they set excellent examples.

Anyway, other than nagging self-interest, why can’t the Clinton clan acknowledge that Obama’s success—in elections and in office—has already made a bonfire of those stereotypes that hold back talented individuals with political ambition? Hasn’t Barack Hussein Obama already sent an inspiring invitation to white as well as black girls and women?     

Monday, May 28, 2012

Unlovable case for Europe’s union: coping with Germany


When the president of France huddles too eagerly with the Chancellor of Germany, the French grimace and soon start looking for another president. When asked to share more of their wealth with other Europeans, Germans say they love East Germans—they’ll tell you, “They don’t consider the Greeks their brothers.”


The partners of the troubled 27-member European Union—northerners, southerners, Germans or not—don’t much like each other. Unlike the American union’s founding members, the strong in Europe don’t assume that the weak will grow to be as strong; and the weak have no realistic ambition to humble Germany.

Still, without affection or optimism, they all keep compromising to save their marriage. None are keen to leap into the unknown. But, several must imagine they’d do better on their own. So, why do they all want to stay together?

Here’s one reason they don’t talk about.

They want to make their young federation work, not because they hope to be equals or lack pride as separate nations, but because Germany is relatively so much more power than they are.

Political elites in Europe are adept at the patronage and invented the rhetoric of economic nationalism. As with the Brits, they resent Brussels bureaucracy and are frustrated by collective decision-making. However, they believe it is much more important to avoid German unilateralism than expand their own freedom to maneuver.

Europeans have had all the experience they want in mobilizing the nation-state to beat their neighbors. The last thing they want to do is to excuse that kind of behavior by Germany.

The American and Canadian federations were created by weaklings to create power in a world of threatening superpowers.

Europe is hardly at that stage in its development. Federal institutions, to them, are means to bind the most powerful, as well as expand collective prosperity and influence.

Comparatively, it’s been extraordinarily easy—and safe—for Canadians to live next door to a dynamic superpower. The extreme imbalance of power between our two federations has, in fact, militated against any sustained consideration of creating a single federation.

Canadians complain when Americans unilaterally harm Canadian interests and jeopardize economic relationships. Canadians would like to be treated like Americans, while living in their own sovereign, relatively harmless country.

Resentment toward the United States excuses not looking at greater integration. Since 1945, Europeans stopped resenting their own superpower and started, in steps, finding ways to unite.

Thursday, December 15, 2011

Angela Merkel and those glorious technocrats

Time magazine’s choice of the Protestor as the person of the year captures the temper and the potentiality of the moment. Also, it honors personal courage. However, as with Barack Obama’s Nobel Peace prize in 2009, its logic seems rather premature.

Protestors in Tunisia, Libya, and Egypt demonstrated that no political order is permanent. However, they didn’t rediscover the idea that the world is changeable. Outside the Middle East, it was already widely asserted that the status quo—the global order of interdependent market economies that the designed and the whole world now operates—would soon break up.  

The biggest story of this year is not what the protestors have changed, but how well the world's young imperfect order has held.

This was to be the year for the center to lose its grip: Washington was to be irredeemably radicalized by the Tea Party, debt-default, and a double-dip recession, and the “fundamental flaws” of the Euro zone were literally going to reverse European integration.

Next year may be different. For this year, however, the so-called technocrats—the central bankers, the economists, and the elected politicians who respect and can comprehend their advise—made the real news, and saved the status quo.

Their prominence shouldn’t be dispiriting. Their accomplishments don’t represent a surrender of democratic politics to robotic bureaucrats.  

It is noteworthy that the two Western leaders holding more political power in December than they held last January—Angela Merkel and Stephen Harper—are both called technocrats. And those whose authority has weakened—Barack Obama, David Cameron, and Nicolas Zarkozy, for instance—are called consummate politicians and great communicators.

Slate magazine noted the technocrat’s impact but misrepresented their vocation.

“An expert, not a politician. Technocrats make decisions based on specialized information rather than public opinion. For this reason, they are sometimes called upon when there’s no popular or easy solution to a problem (like, for example, the European debt crisis). The word technocrat derives from the Greek tekhne, meaning skill or craft, and an expert in a field like economics can be as much a technocrat as one in a field more commonly thought to be technological (like robotics). Both Papademos and Monti hold advanced degrees in economics, and have each held appointments at government institutions


Angela Merkel has proven to be a master of details but, also, an architect of political change and a shaper of public opinion.

Addressing the “fundamental flaws” of the Euro-zone, rather than surrendering to them, requires confidence as a politician as well as technical credibility.

Great public projects demand both sets of skills—occasionally in one person, usually in seamless teams. In the spirit of this season of generalities and Time magazine, here are a few propositions about these two sets of political actors:

The technocrats prefer to huddle; the campaigners look for the podium.

The technocrats are called incrementalists and miss deadlines because they like to test ideas.

The campaigners like to force the issues and compromise later.

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Hard times and European solidarity


Has the European Union’s evolution as a federation reached its limits? Will nationalism increasingly limit power-sharing with Brussels? Can we assume on this side of the Atlantic that future political challenges will all be on the Pacific? Recent events suggest otherwise. Indeed, it looks like European federalism may be outsmarting us.

Canada was defeated for a temporary seat on the Security Council of the United Nations because individual members of the European Union decided it was in their interests to support one of their own, rather than a valued friend. The idea that Angela Merkel and Nicolas Zarkozy were out to teach Stephen Harper, an upstart Canadian conservative, a lesson in humility and political correctness is silly. Clearly, European leadership has decided that European political solidarity comes first. Protecting the Union—its common market and its common currency—trumps its individual external ambitions, including the credibility of the NATO alliance.

There are numerous other indications that the recession is not undoing existing arrangements, but rather leading to further cooperation in sensitive areas. Across Europe, social tensions are rising; the outsider, whether a Muslim or someone from somewhere else who is looking for a job, is feeling less welcome. However, the Schengen Agreement that now holds twenty-five countries—400 million Europeans—together in one borderless security zone is firmly intact. France and Britain are actively negotiating a defence agreement that could lead to pooling resources and cooperation on everything from procurement to sharing France’s nuclear-warhead-simulation-testing facilities. Last weekend, the European members of the G-20 were finally able to agree among themselves to reduce their over-representation on the board of the International Monetary Fund.

There is more muscle behind these concerted actions than bureaucratic inertia and a swelling feeling of being European. Germany and France and the other more affluent northern partners have an immense stake in maintaining the Euro currency and an open market of some 500 million people. When unity will be served, we shouldn’t be surprised if they undertake further restraints on their freedom to act as sovereign states. If we do nothing to alter the status quo on this continent, we’ll likely fall further behind as an integrated economic competitor.

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Investment analysts pick their winners


Last month, Bloomberg News released a survey of fourteen hundred investors and analysts that ranked world leaders according to their efforts to create a “more favorable business climate." Click here to read more: 

Angela Merkel came in first with a “mostly favorable” rating of 56 per cent. This isn’t that surprising. Whatever you think of Germany’s incremental domestic policies, she did consent recently to bail out the Greek government and, thereby, save several European banks from possible bankruptcy. And we’ve come to understand that professional investors are bred and paid to think short-term.

Obama hasn’t saved a bank in over a year. But, is it credible to rank him almost last—at only 37 per cent, behind two appointed central bankers and Hu Jintao, President of the Republic of China and General Secretary of the Communist Party of China?

Let’s not take this too far. Those who keep small investors, economists, and entrepreneurs up at night probably aren’t, by nature, authoritarians who prefer un-elected technocrats to politicians and, when they do, they are like a lot us. But it is a bit disheartening. These people have a big say in shaping the global economy and, yet, show little regard for how the checks and balances of liberal democracy create long-term economic wealth.

Ben Bernanke could not have stopped the recession by himself and enjoys the powers he has by the consent of a duly elected senate and president. Unlike the President of China, Barack Obama cannot choose winners and decide for now that profits are more important than health services and pensions. As long as Hu Jintao gets results, no organized force can get in his way. However, surely, Western investors ought to appreciate that a superior climate for investment by capitalists requires a broad-based liberal consensus—popular support for property rights, open markets, an independent system of courts, and freedom of expression for journalists and knowledge workers, for instance.

The maintenance of that consensus in the United States and amongst its principle trading partners is surely a test of leadership that deserves to be weighed in the balance. And, in the long-term, may place Obama in a very positive light.