At a banquet of Canadian public intellectuals and
philanthropists, a Canadian happiness scholar dismissed my attraction to the idea
that talented Canadians might fend for themselves in a wider political association
with Americans. It’s a “ludicrous” idea that mustn’t resurface. America is a
miserable place; all the wellness indicators say so. Why would we want to be
miserable, too?
There are various ways for Canadians within a larger
association to continue to feel superior and keep telling the world about their
superior social indicators.
Nevertheless, being dismissed as some kind of playful
nihilist stings. The charge, however, fairly echoes two centuries of American
grief with the "pursuit of happiness.”
In earlier times, Europeans and Europhiles in Canada taught
their children that putting happiness in their constitution was vulgar, even
hedonistic—not something adult societies would do. Now, after the privileged
of the world have consumed a century of American materialism, America is put down
for slipping in the happiness stakes.
Despite being the richest, the US only ranked 12th
in last year’s OECD’s Life Satisfaction Index. Eleven enviable little
countries, including Canada, ranked higher.
Rather than expecting the US—with its burgeoning minorities,
numerous regions, and a million legal immigrants a year—to beat Denmark on
these indexes, it’d be more informative to rank the gigantic American
federation with other great federations—the EU, Russia, Brazil, India, and
China, specifically.
Nevertheless, one thing about America’s relative unhappiness
that we should embrace is their perspective on their own politics. American
political discontent isn’t always a good thing. However, the smiling alternative
could diminish the future for all of us.
Yesterday, Arthur Brooks, president of the American
Enterprise Institute, explained why
Conservatives are happier than Liberals. He also noted that moderates lose
out to both extremes.
“Correcting for income,
education, age, race, family situation and religion, the happiest Americans are
those who say they are either “extremely conservative” (48 percent very happy)
or “extremely liberal” (35 percent). Everyone else is less happy, with the
nadir at dead-center “moderate” (26 percent).
“What explains this odd pattern?
One possibility is that extremists have the whole world figured out, and sorted
into good guys and bad guys. They have the security of knowing what’s wrong,
and whom to fight. They are the happy warriors.”
American extremists and contented Canadians may have the best
parties. But, it’s those miserable moderates that we count on to keep us
safe and progressing intelligently.
No comments:
Post a Comment