Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label trade war. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trade war. Show all posts

Monday, February 28, 2011

Imagining Canada was somewhere else


As predictable as the decline of the US economy and its adolescence, mass democracy has been the idea of leading Canada to safer shores. Choosing the world over America has been the lapel pin of sophisticates since Richard Nixon floated the dollar in 1971. The credibility of staking Canada’s future elsewhere has been maintained by two conflicting realities: the US’s success in driving globalization and the US’s volatile business and political cycles. Every time she’s down, the globalists in Ottawa say, “This time, it could be for keeps.” 

Surprisingly, Jeffrey Simpson, a Globe and Mail’s national columnist, joined the dreamy pessimists with the article “Uncertainty over the US means a shadow over Canada.” He casts an alarming scenario and concludes with an austere fantasy as a national strategy.

“But what would happen if a major ratings agency downgraded U.S. debt, or a big lender began to diversify away from U.S. debt, or the U.S. dollar plunged? This is a country accustomed to making the rules, then breaking them with impunity. But what happens if that impunity is removed, and the very forces of globalization that the Americans have trumpeted turn against the chief trumpeter.”
  

America can’t “govern itself properly” and Canada becomes a high dollar “safe haven.” How do we prepare for this dangerous vindication of Canadian superiority? Simpson tells us we should repeat what we’ve been saying to ourselves for 40 years:

“With so much uncertainty, the best option for Canada is to get deficits down much faster than federal and provincial governments are now intending, refocus as much spending as possible on improving competitiveness rather than politically attractive subsidies and useless tax expenditures, and diversifying our economy like mad outside North America. The resulting life jacket would be thin, but it might provide a little insurance against the storms ahead.”

Forget about slashing the deficit. That’s what everyone thinks you should say when you’re talking about life jackets. Hanging onto his life jacket, however, are three unlikely assumptions. The US political system will drive the US market into a catastrophic recession; at the same time, other markets will grow and drive up the Canadian dollar; and federal government policies and spending can re-orient and tone up the Canadian economy. 

Sure, we sell 75% of our merchandise to the US. And, increasingly, those exports are made up of resources, not high-value manufactured goods. We’re not beating a declining America, but we’ll do better somewhere else. Somewhere, perhaps, where we are new might be easier? Why would those markets be easier—especially the ones that are beating the Americans? Demographically, where will there be better growth than in the US? Why will another Ottawa industrial strategy—that is not “politically attractive”—close the 20-25% productivity gap with US manufactures? 

There’s too much that’s escapist about an insurance policy that counts on the unknown. It looks defeatist to invest in North America when the others are moving pins on maps of the globe. Surely, however, the best insurance policy would be to drive greater North American integration so that North America can continue to prosper and compete. 

Diplomats and visionaries in Ottawa may be fed up trying to tell Americans how to practice democracy in a mixed economy. However, if they aren’t up to Washington, they better think twice about Beijing, Moscow, and Cairo.


Wednesday, November 24, 2010

Mayor Bloomberg’s loose talk in Hong Kong

“He also lashed out at recent criticism over China's push to invest in environmentally friendly technologies, essentially saying America is just jealous. ‘I think in America, we’ve got to stop blaming the Chinese and blaming everybody else and take a look at ourselves...There’s a country on the other side of the world that is taking their taxpayers’ dollars, and trying to sell subsidized things so we can buy them cheaper, and have better products, and we’re going to criticize that?’
“He continued the tirade against his home country, accusing America of favoring uneducated and unworldly politicians. ‘If you look at the U.S., you look at who we’re electing to Congress, to the Senate—they can’t read,’ he said. ‘I’ll bet you a bunch of these people don’t have passports. We’re about to start a trade war with China if we’re not careful here, only because nobody knows where China is. Nobody knows what China is.’
“He later shot down a Hong Kong reporter who asked him about a 2012 presidential run saying, "Definitely not. I have a job for the next 1,152 days, and I plan to serve out every one of them."
—“Stop Blaming the Chinese, America,” Jaya Saxena in News on November 6, 2010
It’s nice to know that at least one politician won’t be pandering to the national electorate for the next 1,134 days.