Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label separatism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label separatism. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 21, 2016

Sovereignty games that only the Yankees mustn’t play

For months, close friends and satellites of the American military-commercial colossus have been writing and ringing their hands purple over the possibility that an insincere, reckless businessman who’s had everything he wanted since his first adult dreams might win the presidency of the United States on behalf of a crazy idea: that the US can be truly independent again. Meanwhile, this week, the former center of the so-called Anglo-sphere will vote calmly on whether to go back to those glorious days when the English Channel was wide enough to keep Europe’s disorderly games at a safe distance.

It’s amazing how our own affairs keep sneaking up on us while watching America burn.

Sovereignty proponents in Quebec, Scotland, and now in England are treated calmly as normal people promoting a disruptive idea. They put their case to the people in state-organized referenda and, eventually, everyone weighs in. It’s a stimulating exercise; it tests ideas and aspiring and incumbent politicians. So far, the status quo prevails with arguments about incremental economic costs and, oh yes, last-minute threats about social benefits and pensions.

Why is nationalism—that desire to not be bound collectively to other collectives less competent or less trustworthy or less civilized than us—a tolerable sentiment in relatively small places and for places that practiced it so disastrously barely a century ago, but absolutely not in the USA?

My hypothesis can’t be verified because no one can admit to it. Still, here goes: European and Canadian politicians and opinion-makers think they can be idealistic and emotional, and can imagine surviving safely outside the status quo, because the US-of-A will always be there to give them security from other powers and from each other, and will keep generating enough economic growth to keep their economies recognizably afloat.

The longer the US is on the scene as their steady, rather philistine, superpower, the longer the rest of us can argue about how to make history again.


Of course, America’s friends can’t keep talking about transformative, existential changes for themselves without having another patient, team-spirited, mainstream President in the White House.

Thursday, November 15, 2012

North American Dividers Take the Stage


Happily, the American federation doesn’t need another Abraham Lincoln in the White House right now. Nevertheless, history’s phantom limbs live on. Lincoln’s first election as President in 1860 promptly drove the Southern white plutocracy to leave the Union. Barack Obama’s re-election, as noted in Politico, has generated, in less than a week, fourteen secessionist petitions:

“As of Monday, residents of Kentucky, Oregon, Montana, North Dakota, Mississippi, North Carolina, Florida, Georgia, New York, New Jersey, Colorado, Arkansas, South Carolina, and Missouri have all expressed interest in dissolving their relationship with the United States.”

By last night, the Texas petition had collected over 100,000 signatures.

Politico didn’t get into specifics. We may never know, for instance, whether the New York petitioners have uniquely Yankee reasons for leaving or, like Texans, simply feel they’d be better off without playing politics with all those swing-state blackmailers.

Whatever. This isn’t too worrying a development.

Grassroots petitions don’t drive radical constitutional change. Dividers don’t get very far until they learn to make friends and, as in Canada, win within the damnable status quo sufficient legitimacy to be able to sell the notion that they could actually leave, without a civil war or, at least, without ruinous economic consequences.

Still, the story is irritating. Dividers are guaranteed serious media attention. They can easily find a respectable number of adults who’d like to make their politics smaller.

Uniters, on the other hand, are often treated as clueless visionaries, without anything exiting to be angry about.

For the record, and with my best wishes, the Canadian option is also now circulating across the US. It declares quietly: “We want to bring our northern brethren into this fine union.”

By this morning, it’s collected thirty signatures.

Soldier on.