Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label mainstream media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mainstream media. Show all posts

Monday, February 18, 2013

Quote of the day goes to the Cardinal


Here’s a gold-medal performance in media relations! Canadian Cardinal Marc Ouellet wins a full two-page biographical sketch in the weekend Globe and Mail—as a “deep theological thinker” and credible candidate for Pope—without bothering to sit for an interview. Reporter Ingrid Peritz faithfully passes on the Cardinal's explanation:

“With all the talk that he is a contender to succeed the resigning Pope Benedict XVI, the 68-year-old Cardinal told those closest to him that the best response was no response. ‘The coming month will be rather tough, given the novelty of the situation, and speculation is rife,’ he wrote to his siblings and 90-year-old mother."
                 
“Bombarded with interview requests, he chose instead a week-long retreat of ‘profound silence.’”

Out of sight, not fishing, not hiding: being profound. Could a war hero, a two-term President, Alice Munro, David Brooks, even Michael Ignatieff get away with that?

Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Justin Trudeau's Gentle Press Juggernaut


The Canadian journalists we rely on to handicap the horse races in federal politics underestimated Thomas Mulcair’s appeal outside Quebec and just as badly overestimated Michael Ignatieff’s appeal in Canada. Second-hand stories about Mulcair’s bad temper and second-hand stories about Ignatieff’s brilliance were unpersuasive.

Consequently, the national media today is playing a more modest role in the roll-out of the Liberal Party’s presumptive front-runner, Justin Trudeau. With that light touch the Canadian press employs for vacuous British Royal visits, they’re helping to turn a do-or-die contest for Canadian liberalism into a coronation.

The editorial pages of the Globe and Mail and the National Post tell us to be objective and set aside half-backed clichés. Readers are assured by the Post that Justin Trudeau isn’t an “untested political dilettante” because he won two elections in the riding of Papineau, Quebec. The Globe reminds young Western Canada to not judge him by what they were told about his father and that there is no ideal credential for political leadership. They conclude that before we oppose Mr. Trudeau’s candidacy, we should study his parliamentary record and “policy positions, once they’re announced.”

This is all too coy.

As a young backbencher, Trudeau has no Parliamentary record of his own. Inviting Liberals and potential liberal supporters to judge him, in effect, by policy positions churned out by party professionals will only confirm he’s a front-runner, not a competent future leader.  

Winning a riding in which the Conservative vote is under 5% hardly hints at his ability to offer a credible, sustained alternative to Stephen Harper, let alone rally progressive centrists who are now favoring Thomas Mulcair.

It’s not mean-spirited to ask the national press to give Justin Trudeau a rough ride—to be as hard on him as prudent Liberals must.

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Mainstream media and the depressed observer

Do you ever find yourself dissatisfied with the in-your-face wholesomeness of mainstream news commentators?
Night after night, we are bombarded by the concise insights of clever, fit people. Invariably, they carry themselves as if they were wrapping up the last ten minutes of a spectacular job interview, with just enough time to pick up the kids at karate class. None appear to be minutes away from a dry martini. If they weren’t on the air they’d be air traffic controllers.
It’s not that they offend us, per se. Indeed, you’d be delighted to have any one of them coach your junior hockey team or meet your closest unattached friend. But still—something is missing now and then.
Thanks to Will Wilkinson’s essay on the poor mental health and literary genius of David Foster Wallace, we can see our frustration in rather high-minded terms. All those fresh, prime-of-age public intellectuals aren’t all that’s out there.
“There’s some evidence that the moderately depressed are less self-deceived. ‘Depressive realism’ is said to leave us less disposed to happy illusions about our abilities or our degree of control over our behavior. It’s easy to see how an unblinkered sense of the self could be an asset to a novelist. Moreover, an unshakable sense of dissatisfaction and hopelessness in the face of the forces that control us, even if muted, can act as a powerful prod to serious contemplation of the conditions for happiness and autonomy. Of course, if depression can make seeing the truth about some things easier, it makes doing everything more difficult. And Wallace appears to have adopted, by choice or chance, demanding standards both in literature and life, and these standards seem not to have been unreasonable. He could, sometimes, live up to them.”
Contemporary events offer much to be depressed about. In truth, much that we call news should upset us and should certainly not be background sound over dinner. Maybe we’d be less tolerant of the dogged mediocrity and cruelty of modern life if the depressives also had a little airtime to seize our attention.