Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label federal deficit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label federal deficit. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

Bring out the bully pulpit, Mr. President!

Being told to “man up” by the right and “come out of the closet” by The New York Times expresses a common complaint about the Obama presidency: Why doesn’t he use the office and his eloquence to lead change and get Washington to move?

Columnist Maureen Dowd put it bitterly:

“As a community organizer, Obama developed impressive empathetic gifts. But now he is misusing them. It’s not enough to understand how everybody in the room thinks. You have to decide which ones in the room are right, and stand with them. A leader is not a mediator or an umpire or a convener or a facilitator.” 

Click on: www.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/opinion/sunday/26dowd.html?_r=1&ref=maureendowd

Campaign strategist Karl Rove, looking for a reason for Republicans to not worry about Obama’s campaigning abilities, put it differently:

“Finally, Mr. Obama has made a strategic blunder. While he needs to raise money and organize, he decided to be a candidate this year rather than president. He has thus unnecessarily abandoned one of incumbency's great strengths, which is the opportunity to govern and distance himself from partisan politics until next spring.”


Click on:  http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304657804576401653113017130.html?mod=WSJ_Opinion_LEADTop

We cannot know for sure whether Obama’s low-key style has contributed to the relative civility of public discourse recently and the startlingly peaceful advance of gay rights this year and whether audacious change would be happening on many other fronts, if only he spoke up more often. Nevertheless, the bully pulpit—the inherent power of the Office of the president to heard—is of limited value and can be counterproductive.

A good president will try to speak for all the people, but will not be heard by all the people the same way.

Unless it’s an emergency and the public is already clamoring in the same direction, a president can’t change things with words unless he can mediate and facilitate as well. If a president claims an issue as his own, he’ll likely be left alone with it.

It’s disingenuous to suggest that if Obama was more Olympian and a touch less partisan he’d be more effective. Congressional Republicans leaders have responded in strident partisan terms to almost everything Obama has said in Washington—from the midst of the financial crisis to now. (Okay, they were gracious about his remarks at the memorial funeral service in Tucson.) Before the ink was dry, healthcare was labelled “Obamacare,” despite a year of compromises and its bi-partisan features.

Republicans will not support any action that serves Obama’s partisan interests unless it serves theirs as well.

A president needn’t be a mute, however. In fact, confrontational rhetoric can make his presidency more effective, as well as improving his chances of being re-elected.

Obama’s direct attack on Paul Ryan’s budget plan “A Road map for America’s Future” is one sure reason why Republicans are trying so diligently to secure a multi-trillion dollar spending reduction agreement this summer. They complained that his speech at George Town University was partisan and “demagogic” in insisting that a health vouch system could not guarantee universal medical care for seniors. They ran television commercials to defend themselves. Now, they’re desperate to make a deal with the White House on entitlements rather than carry Ryan’s plan into next year’s election. 

Monday, January 31, 2011

Did Obama skip a “teachable moment?”

Political economists who love talking about economics, and Republican reformers who want mainstream Americans to think like them, are complaining that Obama failed to use his State of the Union address to explain the true nature of America’s fiscal crisis and the hard choices that must be made to reduce the federal deficit.
Did Obama avoid a “teachable moment”? Could he have clarified the issues and left his audience of fellow politicians less divided and less nervous about public opinion? The eminent economist Robert Samuelson thought so:
“It was a teachable moment—and Barack Obama didn't teach. Unless public opinion changes, we won't end our budget deadlock. As is well-known, Americans want budget deficits curbed. In a Kaiser Family Foundation poll, 54 percent urge Congress and the president to "act quickly" and 57 percent prefer spending cuts to tax increases. But there's little support for cuts in Social Security (64 percent opposed), Medicare (56 percent) and Medicaid (47 percent), approaching half of federal spending. The State of the Union gave Obama the opportunity to confront the contradictions and educate Americans in the unpleasant realities of uncontrolled government. He declined.”

Eloquence persists in politics because people can be inspired to accept change and sacrifice. However, history and the nature of the budget problem argue that the pedagogical role of the presidency is extremely limited and—fortunately—not really necessary to resolve painful issues.
Sadly, the impact of White House pronouncements has had far more to do with the popularity of the speaker than the abiding truth of their utterances. FDR opined that Americans had only fear to fear. Really? Presidents Reagan and Clinton announced that government itself was “the problem” and that the era of “big government was over.” Yet the behemoth kept growing, and men and women still run for office promising to use public office to solve local and national problems. Jimmy Carter was probably closest to the truth in 1979 when he urged Americans to adapt to a new age of limits. The next year he was trounced and every successful president since then has been an optimist. Eisenhower’s most important utterance about the debilitating influence of the military-industrial complex was saved for his Farewell Address.
Samuelson sees the budget problem in bloodless academic terms: Americans harbour myths that can be set aside. But the term “myth” is often nothing more than what we say to diminish what others think. People would prefer not to pay higher taxes and would prefer that spending cuts hit somewhere else. In an election or on the doorstep with a pollster, the citizen simply plays his or her best card. We do not bind elected governments with those preferences. We merely want to make sure that government tries its very best to do as little harm as possible.
Obama is much closer to the truth—and to his mandate--when he merely calls for a “principled compromise.” He doesn’t suffer the illusion that the public can be made to drop their illusions or that the differences between Democrats and Republicans are born of ignorance of the facts.
Economic modeling will not write the budget and determine the ideal mix of tax increases, spending cuts, investments, and pork that will get a deal—a compromise that will be acceptable to the capital markets and not tear the country apart. Yes, in time, America’s politicians will appeal to the people’s better angels. And there will be numerous “teachable moments.” But first, they’ll have to sit down together and make some hard decisions.


  

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Obama’s speech: restoring the presidency and Washington later.

Obama's State of the Union speech was not great or heroic but nor was it insignificant. We’ll be even more determined to hear the next one because Barack Obama obviously makes up his own mind about what to do.
Democrats ready to address the federal government’s looming financial crisis did not get a call to arms or a message to ease their burden with fellow Democrats. Obama didn’t walk away from comprehensive fiscal reform or shrink the agenda set out by his own bi-partisan commission. He presented a few specifics and then acknowledged that what he presented was not enough. He did three things, however, that keep alive the prospect of great things to come.
First, instead of another squishy call for bi-partisanship he offered to help fashion a political deal to save careers on both sides of congress—“a principled compromise” that will rein in the deficit and, thereby, allow room for new investments in education, innovation and infrastructure.
Second, he said nothing that would let Republicans walk away and he said enough to increase pressure on Republicans to get specific on spending cuts.
Third, the speech’s tone and energy will likely solidify the public’s growing confidence in his presidency. The public will not march on Washington to write the budget. But in settling down with the Obama presidency they’ll make a “principled compromise” possible. 
It would have been historic and dramatic if Obama had committed to bring forward a budget with actual tax increases along with tax reform. However, the capital markets, for now, may be happy enough that the public mood is up and that the president and the congress dealing with a real problem together.
They may find the right balance of fear and courage necessary to make hard decisions. Actual economic circumstances will have a say as well. However, a popular president won’t hurt.

Thursday, December 16, 2010

The Business Roundtable and Washington political leadership

With so much money running around American politics, you’d think big business ran the show. Certainly, big money, thanks to the supreme court, is now operating more freely and secretly through the American political system and does influence the behavior of public decision-makers as they weigh constantly conflicting interests.  However, time and time again, business leaders are cowed by Washington.

While elections cost $billions and the rich get richer, one hard fact about North American democracy remains true: the most successful business leaders make tough business decisions—but tough political decisions are always left to the politicians.
This should reassure democrats everywhere. However, in bracing times like these, business leaders who trek to Washington would be of greater service to their country if their advice was at least tough.

The Business Roundtable, an eminent assembly of a hundred or so titans from high tech, banking, manufacturing, entertainment, and retail industries that desperately depend on the restoration of America within the global system, sent twenty business leaders to Washington twice this month to lay out, in person, their recovery plan “Roadmap for Growth.”

It is an understatement to say that these men and women are nervous about the future. It is estimated that American business is sitting on well over one $trillion of profit that it has accumulated from sales and cost savings since the depths of the recession. The unwillingness of big business to get America going again through resurgent private investment is dramatically demonstrated in the numbers. The written advice the Roundtable has to Washington, however, doesn’t add much to the prospects of restoring confidence in America.

On the one big confidence test of the day—the long-term federal deficit—the Roundtable’s advice is all too rounded. Its take-away “ask” echoes the sunniest platitudes of the fall Republican electioneering:

“Fiscal Policy and Competitive Taxation: Redesign the corporate tax system to promote investment and strengthen US competitiveness in the international economy, and undertake significant reforms to reduce government spending before the American economy is swallowed by debt.”

Maybe, in private, they explained what that meant. We were told through the Wall St. Journal that their talks were “substantive.” Conceivably, they even accepted the broad logic of the majority report of the bipartisan Bowles-Simpson National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform: more tax money must be raised as well as saved.
In fact, it is impossible to believe that they and their brilliant in-house strategists don’t recognize that the US government is underfinanced. They also must know that a collapse in confidence in the US dollar—and souring interest rates caused by that collapse—would be catastrophic for their gigantic businesses.
Nevertheless, the president and congressional leaders don’t need private lessons on Economics 101 tutoring. What would more likely bolster their untested resolve to credibly address the fiscal problem would be public support for reforms to both sides of the fiscal challenge. Something pointed like this:
Mr. President, (1) develop a plan as broad as the Bowles-Simpson majority report; its compromises work for business and would be fair for Americans. (2) Tax rates for business and individuals can come down if we eliminate most business and individual tax deductions. (3) The best next step to encourage innovation and energy independence would be a comprehensive consumption tax, at least on carbon-based energy products, and, ideally, on goods and services generally.
Extremists aren’t the only people licensed to speak clearly. Business and civic leaders who ultimately defer to elected politicians to make the hard political decisions can be pointed in their advice, accepting that at the end of the day even compromised political decisions are what political leaders are good at.

Tuesday, December 7, 2010

Another Republican admits that Washington can raise taxes

“A critical feature of the proposal recently unveiled by Erskine Bowles and Alan Simpson, the co-chairmen of the president's bipartisan fiscal commission, is to reduce tax expenditures rather than raise tax rates. That would increase revenue without reducing incentives to work, save or invest….
The budget gain would be substantial. My colleague Daniel Feenberg of the National Bureau of Economic Research and I have estimated that capping an individual's benefit from tax expenditures at 2 percent of adjusted gross income would reduce the federal deficit in 2011 by $262 billion, or about 1.7 percent of gross domestic product.”

Bottom line: Martin Feldstein, former chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers to President Ronald Reagan and advisor to John McCain during the 2008 presidential election, endorses the Bowles-Simpson task force’s over-arching strategy. It has concluded that new revenues sources, if not higher tax rates, should make up a substantial portion of the effort to reduce the U.S. federal deficit.
Feldstein’s proposal to cap all individual benefits from tax expenditures (income tax deductions for mortgage interest and education costs, and employer payments for health insurance) at 2% of gross incomes, he argues, could eliminate more than a third of the deficit. Sure, they would be politically difficult. However, Feldstein insists that they would increase revenue without reducing incentives to work, save or invest.
Most important, another eminent conservative Republican has abandoned Santa: growth and spending cuts will not be enough to right America’s damning chronic federal deficit.
Yesterday’s temporary tax cut compromise may nudge the economy toward further short term growth and ends Obama’s oft-stated opposition to extending “Bush’s tax cut for the rich.” Nevertheless, the new Congress and the President will have to turn to the Bowles-Simpson deficit reduction package in the New Year. Thanks to Feldstein and other conservatives, there will be many Republicans ready to compromise rather than hold their breath for another two years.