Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Ontario. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ontario. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 20, 2013

Looking for Justice? Look at the evidence. (Continued)


Christie Blatchford of the National Post is uneasy about the decision yesterday of Ontario’s Special Investigations Unit to charge Constable James Forcillo with second-degree murder for the shooting of Sammy Yatim.

Warming up on the front page, she notes that charging the “right officer” doesn’t qualify as “a win for justice.” Her peeve, however, isn’t about an obsequious mob about to hang a man because the SIU decided that there was “reasonable grounds” to lay the charge. It seems it’s the annoying source of those “reasonable grounds”—a 139-second YouTube video—that annoys Ms. Blatchford.  

“Much of the tragic standoff was caught on video, which in the modern fashion was promptly posted on YouTube and since viewed, according to CBC News, more than a million times.

“That video, as such video does, made instant experts — on everything from police use-of-force tactics to how officers should deal with the emotionally disturbed — of almost everyone who viewed it.”

Actually, the entire standoff, its violent resolution, and listless follow-up was caught in a steady, unimpeded, uninterrupted film record—thanks to a competent, rather brave Ontarian who simply put online what he was witnessing and, thereby, compelled justice officials and other citizens to do their duty. Spin can’t turn people away from what they’re seeing.

For a glorious moment in Toronto, what was in “fashion” was good citizenship.

Friday, August 9, 2013

How to keep the peace without killing children?


The word "demagogue" would fade away if politicians stopped making pronouncements whenever something tragic happens. Last week in Toronto, a tragedy so miserable and so ugly happened that only an appointed public figure—Ontario's ombudsman Andre Morin—had the intestinal fortitude to take advantage.

A boy stood alone in a streetcar, holding a knife and exposing himself. He had allowed about 20 passengers to get off—in a hell of a hurry, of course. Nevertheless, he didn’t react instantly to instructions by a police officer to drop the knife. So the officer—outside the car, with his buddies standing around him—proceeded to shoot crazy-looking, eighteen-year-old Sammy Yatim to death.

After watching the drama (thanks to eyewitness videos), Morin decided that Ontario’s police forces need to be better trained in how to “de-escalate” dangerous, strange, and annoying situations. He’s called for more training before—and, dammit, they just haven’t listened!

Police representatives and their champions complain that his suggestion was “premature.” That’s not my only problem with him.

Surely, the first order of business is not to look for a gap in a training manual but to determine whether a lethal crime was committed by the police officer who shot Sammy Yatim nine times.

Responsible People in Responsible Jobs naturally fear being accused of rushing to judge. However, turning to policy wonks and educators before justice is done, before we address what the police officer actually did, is creepy.

I’m a big fan of training and helped set up Ontario’s first Ministry of Skills. However, in this civilization, we don’t have to spell out in job manuals that good men and women, including police officers, shouldn’t shoot people who make them nervous or call them “pussies.”

Friday, October 21, 2011

99 Percenters should be equal when they vote

Now with a majority in Parliament, the Harper government looks serious about introducing legislation in the House of Commons to redress the under-representation of Canadians who live in the growing provinces of Canada and the over-representation of Canadians who continue to live in places that were relatively bigger in the past.

(Federal constituencies vary wildly by population—from as little as 34,000 people in tiny Prince Edward Island to more than 170,000 in the most populous district. Some ridings near Toronto have grown so fast over the past decade that they are 50 per cent or more over the national average. In other words, one vote in Markham has half the influence of a vote elsewhere.)

However, redress is a winning and losing business; it makes enemies and needs friends.

It’s not surprising but it’s reassuring that Canada’s most respected national newspaper, The Globe and Mail, remains willing to insist that only one principle should determine representation in the popular assembly of a democratic Canada:

“One person, one vote: It is democracy’s first law. In Canada, representation by population is supposed to give it life, with each constituency having a more or less equal number of electors. The Conservatives must stay true to their previously enunciated principle when they introduce legislation to enlarge the membership of the House of Commons.”


“Conservatives should not waver on Rep-by-Pop” the Globe’s editorial insisted. What’s unsurprising and sad as well is that the Globe decided to beseech only Conservatives to honor this great liberal principle.

The Globe is a small-l liberal paper and was founded in 1844 by George Brown, Canada’s first great liberal reformer—a lifelong champion of the simple slogan: rep-by-pop. Yet, today, organized liberalism can’t be counted on to know its own mind on this basic democratic principle.

Acting Leader of the Liberal Party Bob Rae stands for secure representation for Quebec, fair electoral reform nationally and, of course, for the 99 Percenters in his park. Rep-by-pop stands shoulder-to-shoulder with other (unrepresentative) considerations. There is, however, no room for more than one liberal principle in allocating House of Commons seats, in a demographically changing Canada.

Smaller provinces and Quebec can be protected with a minimum number of seats in the Commons and, as well, by regional representation the present and, hopefully, in a reformed and elected Senate someday.

Canadian federal institutions and parliamentary democracy serve several objectives: representing individuals, representing founding languages, and individual provinces, and protecting individual and minority rights. However, individual votes in national elections should all pretty well weigh the same.

Friday, February 4, 2011

Majority governments can serve the majority’s agenda as well

It is widely argued that, if good times permit, it’s nice to have minority governments in Ottawa and a divided congress in Washington. For five years, the opposition in Canada warn that a majority Conservative government would impose “a hidden agenda,” while in the US, Republicans successfully rebalanced Washington by campaigning against a socialist coup. Both messages play on the same fear: once one party gets popular enough to be in charge, it will immediately start doing unpopular things.
This prediction is rather illogical and impossible to prove—or disprove—in advance. (Why would a larger caucus of Conservative MPs who won by broadening their message decide to resurrect issues with marginal appeal and low priority?) The alternative circumstance—a majority government with sufficient time and power to implement major reforms that could enjoy popular support or at least broad acceptance—deserves greater attention.
Canadian history is studded with successes accomplished by majorities—a Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the Goods and Services Tax, and Free Trade with the US are contemporary examples. None of these were ideologically extreme, and they remain securely in place whichever party is in power. Nevertheless, not one of them would have been possible to accomplish without the secure tenure of a majority government.
Yes, public healthcare in Canada was legislated by a minority Liberal government in the 1960s. However, that federal government was awash with surplus money; nothing needed to be traded off. Furthermore, public healthcare was both credible and widely popular because the Tommy Douglas government of Saskatchewan had had a majority government five years before, when it first implemented universal public health insurance for the province.
The big issues that can’t get on the agenda of today’s minority parliament don’t seem to get the attention of those that may be “hidden.” Still, they are many: legislating strict representation by population for the House of Commons, reforming unemployment insurance in order to support individuals regardless of where they live, a security agreement with the US that would involve legislative changes in Canada in return for an open US border, and, someday, a tax on C02 emissions in order for Canada to do its part to fight climate change.
These issues don’t necessarily divide people on predetermined ideological grounds—rural versus urban voters, or Eastern Canada versus the West. But, the benefits and the costs don’t fall equally, and entrenched interests would be aroused. Also, workable and sustainable answers also require time and a spirit of compromise that only secure governments can illicit.
Ontarians who worry about Albertans and resent Quebec’s political savoir faire should recognize that a new deal for Ontario will require a majority government in Ottawa.

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Newt Gingrich and Jeb Bush’s explosive advice on state finances

Jeb Bush—a moderate in a family that invariably goes radical to win—and Newt Gingrich—a radical who calls himself a conservative—have designed an intricate new device to inflame American politics and corrupt representative government.
In “Better off bankrupt,” an article that appeared in the Los Angeles Times a few days ago, they propose new federal bankruptcy legislation to help California, Illinois, New York, and other states address their looming financial circumstances. The legislation is strangely seductive.
Those states that are carrying “staggering” deficits and extravagant pension and benefit obligations would be able to declare bankruptcy. Indeed they make it tempting. By a simple majority, state legislators would be able to throw themselves at the mercy of the court. And, at the same time, the court would be restricted from questioning the legislature’s reluctance to raise taxes or find other means to honor state government contracts and creditors.
Bankruptcy’s grim literal meaning—to be destitute, to surrender your estate, and to have your affairs administered by others for the benefit of your creditors—is neatly circumscribed. The bankrupt state’s sovereignty is effectively left intact: the taxpayers (who elected incompetent state governments) are left untouched and the federal government is not allowed to interfere. Indeed, Bush and Gingrich conclude on a soothing note: “Congress must allow a safe, orderly way under federal bankruptcy law for states to reorganize their finances.”
Bush and Gingrich take as given that dire action will be necessary. What Germany will not dare let happen to Greece, the US Congress should facilitate for California. Yet, there is no domestic American emergency to dignify their idea.
Probably a good majority of Californians now loathe many of the collective agreements undertaken by previous California governments. The article reported that some 12,000 state and municipal retirees will get $100,000+ pensions this year. However, it’s laughable to suggest that California doesn’t have the means to pay its bills.
California is one of the richest places on earth. Its GNP is 3.5 times greater than the province of Ontario. And Ontario also has a deficit of over $20 billion, along with an excellent credit rating.
Since the villains are identified as bullying union bosses and pandering politicians in largely Democrat states, it is fair to infer that Bush and Gingrich are looking to excite fellow Republicans. Fine. But let’s stop calling them conservatives. Conservatives don’t finesse the breaking of contracts. 
Reagan’s conservatism was disputed by many economists and fellow Republicans when he insisted that tax cuts would pay for themselves. These two gentlemen are peddling something far more mischievous: “If you don’t want to pay for what we’ve done, with the authority you granted us with your votes, we’ll simply declare bankruptcy and leave you scot free.”

Monday, December 6, 2010

A necessary bridge doesn’t get built

Canada and the United States are winding up the biggest public capital-spending boom since the Great Depression. Yet, the most important strategic project for both countries—a new bridge between Windsor, Ontario and Detroit, Michigan—didn’t even get started. Ironically, being in the interest of both countries, rather than wholly in the interests of one, may be the problem.
Today, the old Ambassador Bridge conveys $150 billion, or one-quarter of Canada-US annual trade. It is congested, old, and stands alone. It adds to the costs and risks of cross-border trade. If it was obstructed, bombed, or shut down, hours, if not days, would be added to the movement of vital industrial goods and components.
Despite unanimous support in Canada and a Canadian government offer of financial assistance, Michigan still hasn’t agreed to support a second bridge. Barrie McKenna neatly spells out one of the causes of delay: Manuel (Matty) Moroun, the owner of the Ambassador Bridge, who wants to keep his commercial monopoly. 
Moroun’s importance, however, doesn’t dramatize the power of one citizen as much as he does the low priority that American decision-makers assign to building a more integrated (and therefore more world-competitive) North American manufacturing heartland. Free trade is still a good progressive idea, but not that persuasive when American governments are busy creating American jobs.
American automotive and other large manufacturers likely favour and certainly would benefit from the proposed $5.3 billion (US) Detroit River International Crossing project (DRIC). However, in politics, local spending trumps international spending even if it would generate benefits on both sides of the border.
This impasse isn’t another precious example of anti-Canadianism or American protectionism per se. It is a simple illustration of political arithmetic: a $billion spent in Detroit on its infrastructure will be seen as a $billion benefit to American voters. The Ontario Government made the same me-first calculation when it set a strict buy-Ontario procurement requirement for subsidized renewable energy projects.
Public money is relatively scarce, and so the existence of the border—and, consequently, separate electorates—will continue to militate against this strategic investment and other ideas to make our economies work more effectively together.