Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Occupy Wall St. Moverment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Occupy Wall St. Moverment. Show all posts

Monday, April 16, 2012

Taxing the worst of the One Percenters

The far right’s brain eventually produced the idea that America’s biggest problem is a Kenyan-born Hawaiian racist. That message was eventually replaced by a more subtle notion: the Hawaiian is destroying job creators.  
The political divide now may be less personal and more about the idea of having ideas. However, the suggestions in circulation are not much better than the crudest slogans of the Occupy Movement and the Tea Partiers.
Conservatives now are not only political optimists—an historical perversion—they believe you can bake into the US constitution a no-tax increase amendment and still finance the greatest country, with the biggest government, with the biggest military in the world, for decades into a tumultuous future.
Social democrats, who lead in the polls in France, hold the balance of power in Ontario and are pushing Obama in the Democrat Party and are convinced the ticket to power is to raise new taxes on millionaires.
They reminisce about the tax rates of the 1950s. Social democrats and liberals—the champions of the mandatory social safety net and the students on the Freedom Buses who knew that fellow white Americans were itching to beat them up at the next stop—now see America’s problems in the vaults of the worst of the One Percent.
A 75% levy on millionaires in France and a 2% surcharge on those making incomes over half a million in Ontario will not violate Charter rights on either continent, immediately enrich real estate markets in London and New York, or kill human ingenuity.
However, along with risking economic growth, these proposals also trivialize the message of social democracy in society as a whole. Relations below the one percent—between public and private workers, pensioners and young people, the poor and the middle classes, union workers and service workers, interns and permanent employees, for instance—are not perfect. The just society isn’t waiting just one further grand bargain with the rich.
Of course, the more affluent can pay a little more, including those affluent who benefit most from public services. That perspective is central to Obama’s proposals thus far and will be articulated in any deal he reaches with the Republicans after the November elections.
However, it’s escapist pandering to suggest that tax reform is only about the rich or that the vast lobby industry of the 20th century didn’t carve out privileges for groups across society that society as a whole not now afford.
You’d have thought the slogan “We’re the 99Percenters” was too smug to be taken seriously. Yet, it seems to be excusing equally smug policy.
Nevertheless, it is a slogan nice people could have waved in the 1930s, people with leaders selling the idea that others—in some other sinful city—were the source of their misfortune and salvation.

Friday, March 2, 2012

Occupy Wall Street Movement is planning a General Strike


While the clowns and amateurs are falling away and millions of American grown-ups are returning to the world’s oldest two-party system to defeat or re-elect centrist Barack Obama, 12,000 Wall Street Occupiers are planning to go nuclear—to hold a general strike, to get in Time Magazine again, in the sunny month of May.
Natasha Lennard reprints in Salon their “painstakingly drafted” call for national paralysis:
“May Day 2012: Occupy Wall Street stands in solidarity with the calls for a day without the 99 percent, a general strike and more!! On May Day, wherever you are, we are calling for: No Work, No School, No Housework, No Shopping, No Banking. Take the Streets!”
A general strike is a damning proposition and not something any incumbent president can abide. Lennard, of course, sees its limitations.
“There is, however, a shared desire underpinning this ambitious call to action – even among those who resist the language of general strike – to disrupt business as usual and for May Day 2012 to escalate a fiercer wave of dissent against our current socio-politico-economic context.
“Among the slogans resonating around the May Day calls is the pithy reminder that 'strike is a verb, not a noun.' The call to general strike, then, is best understood at this point as a brash and ambitious call to action. Writing in the early 20th century, French theorist Georges Sorel argued that a real general strike could only function as a myth and that the myth was all important – the idea of something unattainable, mysterious and indescribable that can drive and inspire revolution. By Sorel’s lights, there can be no successful general strike on May 1, there has never been a successful general strike and never could be one – and that is why it’s all important to call for general strike to invigorate action.”
So, finally—on May 1st—America will also experience a fierce wave of futile dissent.
How French.
Failing at being French, however, is not always an American vice. George Sorel’s fascination with violence and attraction to the radicalizing impact of futile gestures served European fascism, not the 99-percenters.
The American rallies that made positive history were made up of Americans who’d already earned national attention by personal effort and personal courage registering voters, riding buses, and various other acts of persuasive democratic law-making.
In free societies, rallies simply dramatize social change and general strikes often end up making democracies less free.

Tuesday, December 13, 2011

A cynic and a linguist cloud the truth

On the first of the month, Frank Luntz gave nervous Republicans a shrewd list of words to repeat when selling themselves and their American vision in the next election (Click on:http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/ticket/republicans-being-taught-talk-occupy-wall-street-133707949.html).This blog (December 2) complained that his advice was too selective, rather chicken-hearted, and would only corrupt what could be an exceptionally clear-headed fight over America’s future.  
Linguist and left helpmate George Rakeoff takes a very different approach, offering a pretty alternative of his own:  
“Unfortunately, Luntz is still ahead of most progressives responding to him. Progressives need to learn how framing works. Bashing Luntz, bashing Fox News, bashing the right-wing pundits and leaders using their frames and arguing against their positions just keeps their frames in play.
“Progressives have a basic morality, which is largely unspoken. It has to be spoken, over and over, in every corner of our country. Progressives need to be both thinking and talking about their view of a moral democracy, about how a robust public is necessary for private success, about all that the public gives us, about the benefits of health, about a Market for All not a Greed Market, about regulation as protection, about revenue and investment, about corporations that keep wages low when profits are high, about how most of the rich earn a lot of their money without making anything or serving anyone, about how corporations govern your life for their profit not yours, about real food, about corporate and military waste, about the moral and social role of unions, about how global warming causes the increasingly monstrous effects of weather disasters, about how to save and preserve nature.
“Progressives have magnificent stories of their own to tell. They need to be telling them nonstop.”
So, listen carefully progressives: don’t argue, moralize.
Imagine a Moral Market, regulated by angels, where our pension funds grow in double digits and our corporations will make profits just short of “greedy.” Promise a Market for All, except, most likely, in the delivery of public services. Insist that the unproductive rich and their unpatriotic corporations run our lives and that once we’re free of them we’ll be happy to pay—whatever we’re told it will take—to save the planet. Imagine that—without the other side’s corrupt lobbyists—government will be waste-free, that its claims on us will always make sense.
Both Lakeoff and Luntz live in California. Each wants us to pick their illusion; probably each believes that the real world will submit to their story—if it turns out to be a blockbuster.

Friday, November 11, 2011

Crony Capitalism—as if

There’s probably an angry slogan lurking out there that will capture the rage against the economic order of the last three decades. It will have to be very good—and new. Globalization, free trade, deregulation, and the resurgence of traditional laissez faire values have fundamentally changed both the have and have-not worlds. Furthermore, the changes can be reversed.
“Crony capitalism,” however, doesn’t work. Indeed, it’s wildly off the mark.
It’s not surprising that this accusation has popped up on cardboard signs at OWS parks, especially near major financial centers. It’s been used to damn bailouts and egregious corporate bonuses. Also, the term goes nicely with an excellent slogan used in 1972 by one of Canada’s last socialists David Lewis—“corporate welfare bums.”
As an ideological concept, “crony capitalism” expresses the dark side of economic nationalism, the military-industrial complex, and the industrial strategizing that, we were told, would push Japan Inc, Germany Inc, and, now, China Inc. to the forefront. The dark side includes those hidden taxes we pay to support powerful entrenched relationships—higher prices and fewer opportunities for innovators and outsiders generally.
The reaction that changed the world wasn’t Cleaner Cronyism, but Neo-liberalisms.
Starting with Jimmy Carter, not Ronald Reagan, in the late 1970s, US and soon Western European policy consciously favored breaking down barriers for traders, investors, and individuals as the best way to create and share the wealth—and diminish the influence of crony relations.
Neo-liberalism was successful enough to more than double world trade and free half a trillion from severe poverty. It has made it easier for Americans to buy high-quality inexpensive goods and travel around the world. It has made it easier for American businesses, universities, and laboratories to attract talent globally and to drive down the costs of doing business. It has made it easier for young people without connections to break into and make money in American business. It has pushed us closer to a meritocracy that lavishes the winners and leaves the middle class on a treadmill.
Neo-liberalism has been around long enough to experience its first great crash.
Nevertheless, the scramble to stabilize the world economy in the winter of 2008 represented not the logic of the new order but a surrender to the past—a past of state-business crisis management on the right and state-business economic planning on the left.
Bailing out Wall Street and two auto companies should be seen as emergency measures to halt a recession—and keep alive the financial mechanisms that have facilitated globalization and intensification of capitalist development.
These measures were not designed to undo the gales of competition. There was nothing more “crony” about what happened than what happens when a fire crew puts out fire before finding out who is to blame.
Of course, a measure of good cronyism within a competitive mixed economy—of business and government people collaborating with one another to accomplish together what they can’t accomplish alone—should be welcome.
However, we’re a long way from the days of the gentlemen barons from Boston or New York telling Washington officials what to do. Cronyism doesn’t need 17,000 registered lobbyists in Washington.
Indeed, the term “panic capitalism” would best describe the erratic and shortsighted involvement of billionaires and CEOs in the recent legislative and political dramas in Washington and in their biggest booster, the Republican Party.

Monday, October 17, 2011

Occupy Wall Street Movement—no elixir for big government advocates

Braving lashing rain, a full house of Toronto’s non-commercial elite—retired and active writers, broadcasters, academics, and public administrators—gathered at The Gardiner Museum last Wednesday to hear Canada’s highest ranking retired public servant, former Clerk of the Privy Council, Alex Himelfarb.

Something exciting, it was thought, might happen: his presentation was advanced as a thinking person’s war-cry:

“How did ‘taxes’ become a bad word?”

The brochure elaborates, “Was it our loss of trust in the government, in one another, or does it run even deeper: a loss of trust in the future? ‘When we believe progress is not possible, we live in the present, and we lose our commitment to tomorrow,” Himelfarb says.”

We were in for a bracing lecture.

Indeed, his introducer effused about the “bravery” of the presenter. However, Himelfarb quickly invited the entire room to relax. He would take sides—their side on almost every sighed cliché since the financial crisis of 2008.

He compared Canada favorably to “anti-tax” America. Apparently, Canadians—unlike Americans—are smart enough to understand Oliver Wendell Holmes’s observation that taxes are the price we pay for civilization.

He identified equity as the focus of his concern, repeating the phase “The very rich and the rest of us.”

(The demagogue hidden inside a very smart man who ghosted for politicians for 30 years must have got the best of him. In the version of his speech that was printed in The Globe and Mail, he dropped the two words “of us.” In the Globe, he asserted in closing, “All great change starts outside conventional politics and right now the ‘other 99 per cent’ are saying no to more of the same on Wall Street, in the oil sands and beyond.”)


Himelfarb argues that neo-liberals (in particular, America’s Milton Friedman) corrupted public tolerance for taxes and support for positive government over the last thirty years and that unless this is challenged “we will sleep walk toward a smaller, meaner Canada.” In his remarks, he gives Friedman direct responsibility for the ridiculous winsome lie: “Tax cuts are free.”

Neo-liberals and neo-conservatives haven’t monopolized the public square over which Himelfarb helped govern for the last thirty years and are they are quite able to defending themselves, and their Nobel Laureate, Milton Friedman. However, there is much that Himelfarb said about the nature of today’s problems in public trust and public finances that ill-serves constructive debate.

Rather than talk about our civilization and how strong governments and a robust free markets can work better, rather than even demonstrate that there is a structural deficit that needs new taxes in Canada, he adds his voice to the inchoate protests in the park—modern government is hostage to the one-percenters and their extreme good fortune caused the perilous state of US public finances and stagnating middle-class incomes throughout the developed world.

The notion that stagnating middle class incomes is caused by right-wing governments and, therefore, can be reversed by ramping up taxes on one in a hundred and redistributing income via central governments is as fanciful as anything assigned to Milton Friedman.

The central problem of reconciling a more open and peaceful world economy with rising middle-class incomes in the most highly developed societies has not been solved by laissez faire right-wingers or interventionist leftists.

The middle classes are just too big to be bailed out by the state, whether the wealth of the top 1 percent is more heavily taxed or not. The middle classes and the lumpy new 99% are open to lies from either side of the ideological spectrum. And Himelfarb is on the mark when he calls out those who keep promising even further tax cuts to make up for stagnate incomes.

However, it’s passing strange that an experienced pragmatist like Himelfarb would suggest that we need a new movement outside of conventional politics when the economic problems today so clear require compromise, collaboration and technical discipline—skills the existing machinery of modern democracy still have the capacity to deliver. It delivered political change in 2008 and it also rescued the world economy from possible collapse.

While the powerless sidewalks of Wall Street were the focus of world attention last week, the US Senate was left largely scot-free to block a job-creation package that would have relieved some of the hardship faced by millions.

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

Hang around Wall Street and you’ll end up in a Republican commercial

A few union leaders and numerous Democratic politicians looking to impress their children have opined gently on the Occupy Wall Street Movement. Soon everyone will be expected to take sides on this formless melodrama. The growing number of protests around the country—hell, why not around the world—will be duly reported. Already, this so-called movement is being caricatured as the left’s response to the Tea Party.
Naomi Klein, the J.K. Rowling of outlandish non-fiction, blessed the protests last week. She saluted her New York audience’s most extravagant conceit: that they speak for 99% of humanity. She congratulated them for having a fixed address and a fixed target: the greed of the other one percent. Klein praised a gathering that answers to text messages and has no agreed program—except admiring their own empathetic qualities—as “horizontal and deeply democratic.” She closed on a sentiment that must have been inspired by the towers of Manhattan: “Let’s treat this beautiful movement as if it is the most important thing in the world. Because it is. It really is.”
All this is indisputably entertaining but it’s not smart politics. And the sooner the adult in the White House and his ancient political machine—the Democratic Party—addresses that fact, the better their chances of not being humiliated in next year’s election.  
America’s boisterous public square can be frustrating for political strategists. Spontaneous, anarchic sound-bites can out-shine mainstream politicians and can drown out the subtle, careful utterances of elected politicians. Still, genuine democrats can’t hesitate to defend the right to protest in unorthodox, peaceful ways. The suggestion by Herman Cain that these people are “un-American” shouldn’t go unchallenged. A great democracy doesn’t have a dress code or fixed set of beliefs.
Nevertheless, activists who elected Obama and decades earlier, campaigned for Gene McCarthy, Robert Kennedy George McGovern and Bill Clinton adopted a vision of America and a vision of American politics that are very different from those expressed by Naomi Klein. They understood that just saying that you speak for the people is easier than bothering to win democratic elections. But they knew that elections allow for real change.
When they won elections, they compromised; they pursued a higher standard not just a “better” standard of living for Americans. They were all market democrats and insisted they could better manage a capitalist society than their more ideological opponents. And when they lost, the new age politics of Ms. Klein accomplished nothing.
After the wondrous summer of 1967, tens of thousands of young people settled down and “got clean for Gene.” They entered mainstream democratic politics with a vengeance, driving a war president from office. Conversely, the darlings of the media then, the counter-culture that shunned the old politics, produced nothing of lasting consequence except alarming film footage of social disorder that helped elect Ronald Reagan and Richard Nixon.