Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Literary Review of Canada. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Literary Review of Canada. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 4, 2012

Brace yourself: A classic US election is only four months away


While the promise of stable government passes for political discourse in Canada, the Americans are playing out Act One of a classic American drama.

Necessary bipartisan problem-solving will return to Washington with the winners and only a handful of losers will give up and move to Canada. In the meantime, however, Americans will participate in a bitter, high-stakes debate and then a decision about who should guide American power at home and abroad.

The least certain—the deciders—will be swayed by the most certain. So, both Obama and Romney and their campaigns will have to keep raising the temperature.

The prospect of a loud, divisive election is unnerving. Too much shouldn’t be decided on in one day. Also, it compromises good government to tie elected representatives to too many detailed positions in advance of assuming their responsibilities. These concerns have been around as long as mass democracy on this continent. Fortunately, the American public—like people everywhere—quickly tires of loud-mouths and inflexible dreams.

In event, one postponed decision after another and one political calculation after another have forced a big election on America. So, Americans: Enjoy the Fourth of July because the next four months will be hard work.

There’s a school of opinion that extreme language in American politics is uniquely American—that it’s in your character. Writers who want to find something pleasingly different to say about how Canadians practice democracy can be counted on to call us temperate and Americans, less so.

In John Irving’s novel A Prayer for Owen Meany, a character is quoted favorably in the Literary Review of Canada this month saying:

“But don’t you see how your … opinions can be disturbing?” a Canadian confides to him. “It’s very American—to have opinions … as strong as your opinions. It’s very Canadian to distrust strong opinions.”


You can’t overstate the abundance of fresh water up here. But, our reputation for watery opinions is exaggerated. Canada’s persistence as a British Dominion is testament enough to the power of dogged opinion over almost all else. 

What may have caught Irving's attention is our reticence. Yet, that isn’t a virtue in a democracy or in a family of adults.

The faith that energizes America’s extravagant democracy is profound: Americans who are attracted to politics or simply love their country still believe that their fellow Americans are persuadable.

That’s what brings their opinions to the service; that’s the optimism that we should celebrate with Americans today.

Thursday, December 8, 2011

Do political journalists need informal time with politicians?

Certainly, many retired journalists think so. Their memoirs invariably include charming stories about relaxing and recreating with the powerful, and expressions of regret that relations are more formal these days. In his review of the autobiographies of Canada’s Allan Fotheringham and Craig Oliver, Hugh Winsor offers an emphatic defense of the intimate mode.
He dismisses the idea that journalists should only be “peeping Toms, that nothing is off the record and that any personal contact must be confined to the journalist-newsmaker paradigm.” Winsor exclaims:
           “Inappropriate contact? Nonsense!
“Serious political journalists should share with politicians and bureaucrats an interest in the values and overall health of the democratic society in which we operate. That does not mean supporting any particular political or partisan beliefs or taking sides in the game. But our ability to understand, evaluate and describe the game can only by improved if we spend some time in the dressing room as well as watching the play from well above the ice in the press box.
“That means we have to trust that serious journalists will have enough intellectual honesty and judgement to not be co-opted or corrupted by the better understanding that comes from personal contact and knowledge.”
Winsor’s personal civility and integrity are real. His appreciation of what’s going on, however, is worryingly generous.
The politician and the journalist actually don’t get up in the morning to serve the overall health of their democratic society. One gets up to advance his or her political agenda and the other gets up to inform the public. Political leaders would like people to readily agree with them; the good journalists often make that difficult.
This tense picture of their relationship isn’t an artificial construct to keep them out of each other’s beds. It’s in the nature of their very different occupations.
Of course, politicians will take a few risks to win deeper understanding, even a little empathy from journalists. Leaders all want to be fondly remembered and journalists write history’s first draft. Furthermore, incumbents eventually come to think that they will benefit by being better understood—that the most worthy observers will naturally be on their side. As John Adams warned, “Power always thinks it has a great soul.”
Nevertheless, the politician surviving in office doesn’t spontaneously do down-time with the press. The journalist may relax, but the best politicians—the one’s that must be most carefully watched—never stop playing politics; never stop looking for advantage or, maybe, for a decent break on an awkward story sometime in the future.
The danger in Winsor’s point of view, however, is the expectation that that informal time in the dressing room ensures better journalism. That what power grants to the few, makes superior journalists.
Surely, the socially maladroit journalists who secure superb sources, expose skimpy reasoning and falsehood, and literally disrupt the bonhomie of political capitals with substantive leaks are as essential as the well-rounded lovers of the game. 

Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Stephen Harper and the extremes

Some days, it seems that Canada’s reputation for moderate and temperate discourse amounts to little more than the fact that Canadian street protesters and academic wise men often use the same extravagant language, and that we note meticulously paranoid language across the border and tip toe around similar outbursts at home.
This month, the Canadian Literary Review—a vibrant carefully edited magazine of opinion and commentary by distinguished and rising Canadian thinkers—published a post-election essay by Stephen Clarkson, University of Toronto political scientist, author of some fifteen books over forty years, and Order of Canada recipient. He fit the assignment nicely. He wrote biographies of Pierre Trudeau, the most successful modern leader of the displaced centrist Liberal Party, and has written extensively on North American relations and politics.
Here’s his take in his essay "Has the Centre Vanished?” on Canada’s latest majority prime minister, Stephen Harper:
We do not need to find out what the prime minister will do with his now absolute control of Parliament in order to admit to ourselves Canada’s nasty new reality. Stephen Harper has moved Canadian politics into an extreme mode that is driven by three factors. It is guided by his personal, if no longer articulated, extremism. It is buttressed by the significant public support for radical-right populism, expressed municipally with Rob Ford’s mayoralty success in Toronto and, provincially, with the Wildrose Party’s strong poll numbers in Alberta. And it is connected ideationally to such foreign manifestations of neo-fascist resurgence as the nearby Tea Party movement’s flirting with violence in the United States and further away in the Hungarian Jobbik Party’s call to bring back chain gangs for convicts—a policy idea that Tim Hudak picked up in Ontario.
Nothing parochial about this insight, eh?
In one fleeting October, Stephen Harper can be the first Canadian Prime Minister to use a transparent Parliamentary process to appoint two Supreme Court Justices, be the first Canadian Prime Minister to try once more to surrender to the people of Canada his power to appoint Senators, be the only leader in the present Parliament unequivocally committed to legislation to align seats in the House of Commons strictly according to population—and be the first prime minister, in the first year of his first majority, to be called a neo fascist fellow traveler by a Canadian scholar.
Stephen Harper is fond of Canada’s Queen and many Tea Partiers like to dress up in 18th century costumes. He also looks like a cold suburban WASP. However, there is nothing fascist about Harper or the Tea Party’s appreciation of America’s founding constitution or its place in the West. Harper is clearly a small-r republican in his vision of popular sovereignty and, therefore, is a threat to the centralist vision of that has dominated Canadian politics since the Forties.  
In a matter of days, Harper will conclude another agreement with Barack Obama. Professor Clarkson, will that make Obama a neo fascist, twice removed, or just a dupe?

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Conrad Black’s economy-sized rationale for Canada

To our benefit, if not always his, Conrad Black’s entrepreneurial spirit long ago overcame his Tory pretensions. Along with dusty newspapers, he shops for countries, ideas and political heroes; he changes loyalties and passports. Recently, he’s taken a second indulgent look at his bronze Canadian homeland.
In the May edition of the Literary Review of Canada Black offers a new way for ambitious Canadians to settle for an independent Canada. Under the headline “Debunking American supremacy” he asserts:
“In fact there is only one reason for Canada: a better competitive society to live in than the United States. If we cannot do that, we should extract a payoff from the Americans for the treasure house of our resources and close the deal.
“But we can do it.”  
There’s a rationale for Canadian independence utterly outside Canada’s self-deny narrative. Indeed, it resurrects a liberal utilitarian idea that long ago was overwhelmed by ethnic tribes and nationalist romantics everywhere. Rather than merely a refuge for Catholic authoritarians and British traditions too precious to surrender, Canada, Black crows, has simply turned out to be a better bet.
Basing Canada—or any democracy—on superior trade and wellness statistics, however, is pretty fragile. He makes no case for Canada as a political entity except inertia and his critique of the US is as old as the sore losers of the American War of Independence.
Black confides “the correlation of forces has changed” in Canada’s favor. “The great United States became a ponzi scheme itself and the present president . . . the most incompetent holder of that office since James Buchanan.” On the other hand: “With China and India—almost 40 % of the world’s population—having become countries of aggressive economic growth, Canada’s status as a resource-based economy benefits from a seller’s market and has become a position of strength.”
Black’s love of history and its exotic footnotes disguises an impulsive arbitrary mind.
When he gave up on Canada (literally and rhetorically) in the mid Nineties, Canada’s public debt/deficit to GNP ratio was about what America is facing today. Maybe, in ten years, he’ll also regret much of what he’s saying now about America.
Last year, the US restored its position as the world’s second biggest exporting nation, three-quarters of it earned from manufacturing. The Governor of the Bank of Canada Mark Carney pointed out recently that only 10 per cent of Canada’s exports go to emerging economies and our non-commodity export market share in the BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, and China) has been almost halved over the past decade.
 Black sees strategic significance in the fact that the share of Canadian exports destined to the US has declined slightly as globalization intensifies. (Last year, Canada’s share of merchandise exports to the US fell from 75.0 % to 74.9 %.) Most strategic thinkers and self-styled realists don’t skip over a glass three-quarters full when assessing immediate and future circumstances.
However, even if you accept for a moment that the US is in peril and that resources can sustain the Canadian economy and that resource markets will magically favor sellers for decades to come, Black offers no sturdy or honorable reason to persist with Canada.
Why should Canada’s resource winning regions stick with Canada anyway? According to Black’s nationalist rationale, why shouldn’t western Canada go off and be a winning society on its own?  The truth is that western Canada on its own—or, for instance, the northwest US states and British Columbia, so-called “Cascada”—would be a less safe, less influential and less interesting place to live. 
The regions that make up our two countries need a strong United States federation if they are to prosper in the world. Democrats, idealists and entrepreneurs will live more fulfilling lives participating in its fateful decisions than looking for statistically attractive shelters on the margins.