Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Keystone. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Keystone. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Climate movement’s own disrespect for science


The only unifying objective behind the various campaigns to shift humanity away from CO2-emitting fossil fuels is to ensure that the upper atmosphere continues to be able to keep the earth’s surface temperatures bearable.

It is a challenge borne of scientific analysis and a problem that can’t be successfully addressed until all global beneficiaries of the status quo join in.

Climate scientists and the social sciences of persistent human wants agree that it can’t be solved without either a formal global agreement to cut emissions or transformative breakthroughs in energy research and innovation. The environmental movement generally rejects the latter as too optimistic and too slow.

(The world’s fossil fuel industry is highlighted because it is the principal source of the energy we all crave, not because today’s oil executives are ideal campaign targets as robber baron capitalists run amok. Most of the value they generate ends up in consumer and producer governments. Also, they are amon the smartest employers of scientists and engineers in the world. More important, their industry only exists because we all use their products and haven’t found a tolerable way to stop.)

Climate-change campaigners are dedicated to global top-down action. You start with the affluent and enlightened democracies, scold rich skeptics, and eventually plead with Asia, the climate crime’s feisty new entrant.

This is work for unifiers, not dividers.

And, so, you’d think that the urgency of their unifying mission would guide their tactics. That they would set aside unresolved, divisive arguments from those innocent times when we divided over capitalism, socialism, and religion without a care in the world for the upper atmosphere.

Yet the notion of thinking globally and acting locally isn’t working. Local, it seems, is also easier to think about.

Fragmented campaigns using filmable fragments of the planet are dividing even early adopters. Consensus science is being shouldered out of the campaign by sensationalism, ideology, regionalism, and the primitive religious claims of Mother Earth and scene-scape warriors in penthouse cities along our lovely, chilly coasts.  

Three fair immediate illustrations:

Manitoba Transportation Minister Steve Ashton announced last week that his government formally opposes the transportation of Alberta’s oil on an existing rail line across the vast, empty lands of northern Manitoba to the seaport at Churchill — turning his back on the last hundred years of co-operative Western development through that "gateway province." Ashton would close another commercial outlet for a sister province because transporting oil by rail today is “too risky to the environment and the safety of those who live in the north.”

Without bothering with a proper review of the proposal by the Transportation Safety Board of Canada, the Manitoba government embraces this extravagant, untested assertion by Grand Chief Irvin Sinclair:

“One derailment or spill is all it would take to destroy the livelihood of generations," Mr. Sinclair said.

“There goes the wildlife,” he said. “There goes a way of life for everybody if something drastic happens. It would be devastating to the environment.”

Coal mining protest in B.C. is set to erupt, according to The Globe and Mail, because significant commercial deposits of clean-burning coal unfortunately were discovered in the wrong valley:

“Nothing is more sacrosanct to the Tahltan than the Sacred Headwaters – a high, wide valley 400 kilometers just hours south of Alaska. There, the Stikine, Skeena, and Nass salmon rivers that nourished aboriginal cultures of the Pacific Northwest originate in an area known to First Nations as Klabona, or Klappan. According to native myth, the Big Raven forged the world in that valley.”

Ryan Lizza's New Yorker report Keystone XL, a gossipy political update on Obama’s so-called “signature” environmental decision, quotes Kate Gordon, the senior policy/marketing talent behind California billionaire Tom Steyer’s anti-Keystone television campaign. She was a reluctant convert:

“She did see the benefits of the campaign, however: “The goal is as much about organizing young people around a thing. But you have to have a thing. You can’t organize people around a tipping point on climate change.”

Phantom jobs in Canada’s largely uninhabitable north, non-existent gods everywhere, catastrophic scenarios about the resource, pipeline, and rail industries that still are the workhorses of North America, the cleanest economic superpower in history — all have equal place in the marketing tool kit of today’s climate change movement.

None of these divisive fragments — these stories about “things” — has anything to contribute to mobilizing the world to address climate change intelligently.

They put untruths to work, create demons, and invite heads of states and local politicians to tighten other people’s belts.  

Monday, March 25, 2013

Keystone Pipeline: Dare Harper simply wait for Obama’s Okay?


A quirky element in the neurotic power relationship between Canada and the United States remains the uneven significance of saying “no” to the other side. Globe-preening Canadian governments profit inordinately when they can say “no” to the global power next door. On the other hand, saying “no” to Canada can be devastating—whether Washington notices or not.

Last week, former Prime Minister Jean Chretien and his senior Liberal colleagues gleefully reminisced in the national media over the 10th anniversary of their un-bidden public declaration that Canada would reject any request by George W. Bush to support the US-British invasion of Iraq. That decision to not act stands above all the other things Jean Chretien didn’t do during his 10 years in office.

Within as many weeks, Stephen Harper could receive from Washington a “no” of devastating consequences—to his relationship with the US government, his vision of Canada’s future, his reputation in Canada, and his chances of surviving another election.

The theatricality of Obama’s pending Keystone decision is appropriately noted.

There is, in fact, little American substance at stake in the decision. The thousands of US jobs that wouldn’t happen along the pipeline will soon be found elsewhere in America’s dirty fossil fuel Renaissance—and, in any event, their fate pales against the jobs being killed each month by Washington’s symbolic campaign to fix Washington’s balance sheet by the mid 2020s. The environmental movement and its latest campaign recruit, hedge funds magician Tom Steyer, sees the oil sands entirely in marketing terms. 

The lack of showmanship on the Keystone Project by the Harper government, however, crises out for greater attention.

With enemies circling, there’s no way Jean Chretien would have sat still and relied on opposition Congressmen and Congresswomen and dull Canadian lobbyists to make his case in Washington.

The Prime Minister will not be credited for playing by Queensbury Rules in Canada and will enjoy no quarter if he loses like a gentleman in Washington.

(Those of you who think you have deep inside knowledge that the President has Harper’s back can ignore what I say next. Those of you who remain nervous might appreciate the following rather aggressive advice from an Obama Canadian to a quintessentially Canadian Prime Minister standing in the headlights.)

If you’ve got Goliath on your side, Mr. Harper, don’t look for your own David; coach Goliath.

The Prime Minister has the confidence of a big majority in Canada’s Parliament and, as reported by Politico, also has majorities in both the US House of Representatives and the US Senate. It needn’t be repeated that Keystone also has overwhelming support among US business leaders and the technocrats the President relied on to fight the recession. 

Don’t wait to mobilize their support after Obama turns you down. They won’t go back to him after he’s decided. Why not secure a resolution now from Canada’s Parliament, supplementing what passed last week in the US Senate?

The Prime Minister should be able to ask his Parliament to be clearer and more aggressive. Conservative and Liberal MPs, at least, should be able to remind Washington, and the President, of the support they’ve enjoyed since their economy tanked in 2008; of the fragility of the present recovery in both countries; and of Canada’s open hand to jointly tackle climate change, continental security, and economic recovery.

Canadians don’t expect you to need the same face time with the President that the Prime Minister of Israel has enjoyed. However, they wouldn’t think it too pushy if you literally went to Washington to make your case directly to the President—and let it out that you’d be pleased to spell out politely what’s at stake, before a joint session of Congress.

There is no value in downplaying the economic consequences of a “no” simply to bolster jobs and housing starts this spring.

The capital markets, more likely, would probably appreciate the candor; and Americans would definitely listen if the Prime Minister argued: killing Keystone now could abort economic recovery in Western Canada and that could spread across Canada—the United States economy’s best customer.