Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Iowa caucuses. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Iowa caucuses. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 4, 2012

Mitt Romney’s foreign policy problem

The low hanging fruit in the upcoming Republican primaries—Rick Perry, Michele Bachmann, and Newt Gingrich—are all authentic conservatives; in order to get enough of their votes to win the Republican nomination, Mitt Romney will have to double down as a conservative.

On the economy, this posture carries manageable risks. He can say pretty radical things and still look reasonably safe. After all, Professor Gingrich has already branded him as a “Massachusetts moderate.” And Romney does actually have a solid record as an effective compromiser to defend himself against Obama in the fall. On foreign policy, however, he’s facing growing risks.

Americans already feel rather burned about the last (wink, wink) conservative with a centrist domestic record. George Bush demonstrated with blood and trillions that knowing how to resist unwise economists in Austin or from Boston, for that matter, doesn’t automatically equip a president to fend off foolish and arrogant foreign policy advisors in Washington.

Furthermore, last night in Iowa, Ron Paul exposed two serious immediate campaign problems. Romney and Republican hawks aren’t attracting new votes to the Republican Party, and Paul’s central message—that America cannot afford extravagant new foreign or domestic adventures—is winning energetic support amongst independents.

Ron Paul’s independents and libertarians will not prevail in the upcoming Republican primaries. In fact, Romney will probably escalate his attacks on Obama as an “appeaser” and dismiss Paul as an “isolationist.” Nevertheless, in upcoming Republican debates and, later, conceivably as a third-party candidate, Paul will be re-enforcing the importance of foreign policy amongst the wider electorate in the November election.

It’s arguable that any president can “take America back” to the seemingly happy economic times before the crash of 2008. However, a Mitt Romney presidency certainly could restore the swagger of George Bush’s foreign policy. You can be sure that Obama will grant him that—and, eventually, make a big issue of it.

Tuesday, January 3, 2012

The US presidential election: a bore in the making

The election of 2012, like the elections of 1960 and 2000, may be desperately important historically, but not necessarily very exciting.

It’s conceivable that grassroots Republicans in Iowa tonight will find that reckless courage political junkies everywhere are counting on—and vote for an eccentric or an incompetent, and cripple middling Mitt Romney’s presidential campaign. That, unfortunately, would contradict what those voters have been doing for the last six months: seven times they’re picked a candidate with their feelings—and promptly retreated. Their hearts may be racing, but their heads keep telling them to take it easy.

The Tea Party and the Occupy Wall Street Movement made a lot of news in 2011, but will be sidelined in US politics in 2012. The amateurs made 2011 exciting. However, the professionals—and $billion Obama and Romney campaigns—may turn 2012 politics into an exhausting bore. Tens of thousands of Americans will participate, millions worldwide will watch. But endless calculation and the worried mood of America’s political center will likely subdue the drama.

What to do? For one thing, we should try to be equally as hard on the safe survivors as we are on the more spontaneous challengers. Maureen Dowd offered a nice start in her Sunday piece “She Made Me Run!”

“Ann Romney told CNN’s Wolf Blitzer that she insisted to her reluctant spouse: “You know what, Mitt, you’ve got to do this again.

“Mitt resisted, she said, because “he remembered how difficult it is and what the hurdles were going to be.” Mittens, as her not-so-cuddly mate is called by reporters, knew he was not a natural with voters.

“According to Mitt, their pillow talk sounded like a political ad. “She said, ‘Look, no one else can beat President Obama. No one else has the background to actually get the economy going, understand the economy in a very fundamental way.’ ”


Dowd reports that a top Republican strategist actually thinks that American voters can be talked into believing that Mitt Romney was persuaded to run for President by a self-sacrificing wife. Until otherwise advised, let’s stick with the evidence: Romney has turned himself inside out for most of his adult life to be a political success.

Romney will keep calling Obama too “European” and Obama will keep complaining that Republicans don’t like the “middle-class” until it sinks in that we all know that they are both talking nonsense.