Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label IRS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IRS. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

David Brooks’ American nightmare: the “unmediated man”


Men of action who successfully interrupt the mini-dramas of Washington can drive Washington’s insiders nuts, especially ones as self-consciously cerebral as David Brooks. Edward Snowden doesn’t prick his conscience. Rather, he inflames his off-the-rack high Tory prejudices. Here’s a taste from the introduction of his column, The Solitary Leaker:

“From what we know so far, Edward Snowden appears to be the ultimate unmediated man. Though obviously terrifically bright, he could not successfully work his way through the institution of high school. Then he failed to navigate his way through community college.

“According to The Washington Post, he has not been a regular presence around his mother’s house for years. When a neighbor in Hawaii tried to introduce himself, Snowden cut him off and made it clear he wanted no neighborly relationships …

“Though thoughtful, morally engaged, and deeply committed to his beliefs, he appears to be a product of one of the more unfortunate trends of the age: the atomization of society, the loosening of social bonds, the apparently growing share of young men in their 20s who are living technological existences in the fuzzy land between their childhood institutions and adult family commitments.”

Enough?

Snowden can’t be a hero or even a serious traitor; he’s not qualified. There’s no way David Brooks would accept a brown envelope—or a lesson in American civics—from a high-tech, high school dropout.

Snowden isn’t a "product" of Yale—one of those mediated gentlemen that gave us Iraq or the son of one of those team players from Harvard that gave us Vietnam. He’s the “product” of a Time magazine cover: the atomized society.

If only Snowden had taken off his designer glasses and hoisted an AK-47. If only he was angry about the IRS and had a parent in the Tea Party. Then Brooks could have put him to music on a familiar complaint: the annoying "no-nothings" who don’t appreciate the imperatives of our complex society.

Brooks, at one point, graciously submitted to the obvious; the NSA programs that scare Snowden “could lend themselves to abuse in the future.” For now, however, Brooks has other worries:

“But Big Brother is not the only danger facing the country. Another is the rising tide of distrust, the corrosive spread of cynicism, the fraying of the social fabric, and the rise of people who are so individualistic in their outlook that they have no real understanding of how to knit others together and look after the common good.”

Americans are divided and individualistic and its politics have been contending with that for well over 2 centuries. Brooks seems to think, however, that the overriding business of 21st-century American politics remains to prove America’s 18th-century critics were wrong.

Of course, whether a "tide of distrust" is too high, or just right, is always a subject of empirical and ideological dispute in a gigantic democracy. Personally, I favor a rather high level of distrust; I just wish it was a little more evenhanded and less partisan.

The "common good" is also a moving target—and no longer reliably passed on in the best families or even in our best institutions. For those reasons, politics are bracingly significant these days.

Big Brother, however, is technically feasible today and—without unmediated troublemakers like Edward Snowden around—will prevail in those solemn bureaucracies dedicated to serving the COMMON GOOD. 

Friday, May 17, 2013

Scandalous Client Service at the IRS


A superpower and a gigantic capitalist democracy can’t work unless certain necessary and unpopular functions of government are performed objectively by professionals.

The policy machinery of the State Department can change its hue before and after elections. It can, for instance, become intensely interested in the oil sands of northern Canada and soon forget that Alberta is a Canadian province.

The professionals who manage America’s nuclear deterrent and money supply, however, must be above suspicion. Otherwise, it would be less easy to sleep at night. The IRS is also one of those institutions that must be widely trusted. Americans are free to dislike the IRS, especially at tax time. But they must believe that it’s not organized to favor the ins and harass the outs.

Trust in, if not affection for, the IRS is central to the “honor” system that efficiently and peacefully collects most of the tax revenues Washington needs to function.

Consequently, the recent allegations that IRS officials have consciously “targeted” Tea Partiers and rich Republicans deserve immediate attention. Indeed, it was appropriate and not suspicious overkill for Obama to use the word “outrageous” every time the allegations are raised.

Politicians on both sides of the aisle needn’t restrain themselves in their efforts to find out what happened and take whatever action is required to restore the credibility of an essential agency of modern government.

However, since neither American democracy nor American lives were lost, we should be able to have a little fun with the victims in this story. Jeffrey Toobin in the New Yorker offered up the possibilities rather quietly.

“It’s important to review why the Tea Party groups were petitioning the I.R.S. anyway. They were seeking approval to operate under section 501(c)(4) of the Internal Revenue Code. This would require them to be 'social welfare,' not political, operations.”


It’s just possible that the political illiterates at the IRS—like first year students facing an exam question on a lecture they skipped—tripped over what these strange, angry groups were actually proposing.

The aggrieved, so-called conservative applicants for 501(c)(4) status loathed George Bush’s “compassionate conservatism,” were determined to stop Obamacare, and, at least in their dreams, also repeal Social Security and Food Stamps. As well, they thought that in his heart Obama was still a “social worker.” Nevertheless, they wanted the benefits that go with being designated a “social welfare” organization by the IRS. They weren’t run-of-the-mill Republicans and they didn’t want to be seen as merely ad-hoc groups of Americans mobilizing primarily to take America back from an African socialist.

Since these organizations existed to do things and, in this case, spend a lot of other people’s money, IRS anthropologists probably did ask a lot of questions—certainly far more questions than busy libertarians like to answer. Congressional investigators will determine, however, whether or not their conduct was partisan and inappropriate: whether or not this new force for social progress faced systematic harassment, or widespread, or only localized curiosity.

The wider allegation that the IRS systematically audited and intimidated outspoken Republicans needs further fleshing out. However, in that exercise, we should recall that the Obama presidency has left the rich far richer than they were the day he was sworn into office. It will also be remembered as an era of extraordinarily outspoken, extreme, and bitter partisan rivalry.