Seamanship Quotation

“In political activity, then, men sail a boundless and bottomless sea; there is neither harbour for shelter nor floor for anchorage, neither starting-place nor appointed destination.”
— from Michael Oakeshott's
“Political Education” (1951)
Showing posts with label Affordable Health Care Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Affordable Health Care Act. Show all posts

Monday, July 9, 2012

Supreme Court’s mandate: protect individuals, not other politicians


Except for burying the lead on page 2 of his statement, last week’s decision by Chief Justice John Roberts and four other judges on the Supreme Court to not stop Obamacare was impeccable television news. It happened in one place, on time, and mid-day. It looked like one sane man was making history.

The big story is more complex and scarier.

Half of America’s elected leadership—congressional and state Republicans—asked five lawyers to legislate their political vision for the future of a universal social service, over one sixth of the US economy. Rather than try to sweep the fall elections with the proposition that health reform should be turned over to the states holus bolus, they asked five judges to enshrine that proposition in the US constitution.

Reformers are wondering whether five judges are really enough, whether a super-majority would be best, whether judges should be retired well before they're too old to absorb new, complex ideas. Conspiracy theorists and pop psychologists wonder about Roberts' motives. Was he actually worried about what others might think?
 
Jamal Greene in the New York Times makes a compelling case for term limits along Canada’s lines, and David Dow in the Daily Beast outlines a number or legislative measures to explicitly limit the Supreme Court’s powers.



These reforms, however, will likely have to wait until after the bigger problem is addressed. It’s become reflexive for American conservatives to turn to the US constitution, as written in 1787, to settle arguments with their political opponents.

The point of contention before the Supreme Court was not about infringing the freedoms of individuals. The 26 state Republican supplicants were speaking for the prerogatives of state governments. They were saying that on the issue of health insurance and free riders, reformers must not go to Washington for a solution.

They can debate their ideas in Mississippi and Massachusetts but not, all at once, across America in a nation-wide election.

There is great merit to the argument that the states are underperforming as instruments of social reform. However, using a constitutional court to prevent the federal government from solving social problems the states can’t or won’t fix is a radical challenge to America’s popular democracy.

The American and Canadian federations have bills of rights to protect individuals from ruthless and careless majorities. We don’t ask individuals to wait for popular remorse to correct popular government excesses. That’s the best reason for having accessible independent courts.

However, American conservatives as well as liberals should re-acquaint themselves with an old fashion conviction about their old federal democracy: the electorate and its representatives will, in good time, get around to correcting excessive federal interference—and passivity—in the federal government’s dealings with other democratically elected governments.

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Obama Care Decision: Silver linings in tomorrow’s clouds?


It’s just too tempting to say something optimistic when conventional opinion can’t find anything positive to say. The prospect of the US Supreme Court—nine lawyers—determining the fate of the biggest health care reform in US history, and quite possibly the fate of the incumbent president, is irresistible.

Two positive propositions have emerged: the political center will get more concerned about the extraordinary powers of the court, and Democrats will again get more radical about fundamental health care reform.

On judicial reform, Ross Douthat well expresses the vision of a possible consensus in his column “The Liberal Embrace of Judicial Restraint.”

“But one can disagree with the specifics of the liberal brief against the Roberts Court and still welcome liberalism’s conversion to the cause of judicial restraint. It should be a point of bipartisan consensus that the judiciary is a political body rather than a panel of Platonic Guardians, and it’s a healthy thing for our democracy to have the other branches of government ready to push back when the high court seems to overreach. This pushback can and should include the possibility of reforming the way the court does business: Term limits and supermajority requirements, for instance, are both plausible responses to the weirdness of having our great controversies settled by the timing of an aging justice’s final illness, or the idiosyncrasies of Anthony Kennedy.”


On health care reform, former Chair of the National Democratic Party Howard Dean sees the possible elimination of “individual mandates”—the centerpiece of Obama’s universal private insurance model—as the last best chance to get the single-payer model back into the Democrat’s platform.



Both propositions rely on a more sympathetic political climate in the country and, in particular, in the US congress. The former, however, does have potential appeal to Republicans, independents, and Democrats. The later has no prospect of success without a decisive take-over of the Democratic Party and, then, the US Congress by old-style New-Deal liberals.

Howard Dean may not “give a damn” about Obama’s liberal-conservative health insurance compromise. However, he doesn’t offer any credible way to get a better reform out of a disaster for Obama in the court.

To replace Obama-Romneycare with a nationalized single-payer insurance scheme would require the financial surpluses of Bill Clinton, the left illusions of the 30s, and Lyndon Johnson’s 1964 electoral sweep—with conservatism in disrepute and without such “distractions” as the civil rights movement and the War in Vietnam.

There have been 15 presidential elections and 30 congressional elections since Harry Truman first proposed universal health insurance.

Only Obama’s plan—with its universal consumer mandate—has made it into law. It is the product of trial and error, liberal and conservative economic, health and management ideas. The mandate isn’t “arbitrary.” Broccoli won’t be next. It’s the only instrument 60 years of discussion and votes have found to realize a massively popular idea—assured and reasonably equal access to the full range of essential health services.

The Canadian federation to the north doesn’t have a national single-payer system. Mr. Dean’s federation is 10 times bigger and its national government is extremely unlikely to create one either.

If the Supreme Court throws out the mandate tomorrow, the only alternative for reformers is to propose a significant, broad-based health insurance tax. That will not be realized in the next four years, whoever wins in November. 

Monday, April 30, 2012

Obamacare or nothing

Many liberal reformers in the US admit to not knowing how to win American elections. In return, however, they think they best understand how the rest of the world works.
This is especially true on their most glaring domestic policy failure: the provision of universal health services that are taken for granted by rich friends and allies, countries that can’t put a man on the moon or win Nobel prizes, even in political economics.
They can live with a Supreme Court rejection of Obama’s individual health insurance mandates because they still believe that Britain and Canada have better health insurance plans, that Obama should have gone for a national single payer system in the first place. Rather than going big, he compromised; by being too cute, he set himself up to be beaten in the courts. Democrats won’t make that mistake next time, whenever that is.
Conservatives tease Obama supporters regularly about their lack of guts and make the same argument. Ronald Dworkin in “Why the Mandate is Constitutional: The Real Argument” notes this line of attack, but isn’t impressed.
“Even the act’s opponents concede that since the Constitution explicitly gives Congress the power to “lay and collect taxes,” it could establish a single-payer national health care system, like the British National Health Service, by imposing a special health care tax and providing medical care itself. Congress relied on the taxing power to make the Social Security program constitutional, for instance. Solicitor General Verrilli noticed the irony: the conservative justices questioned the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act, which relies on private insurance and traditional private medical practice, while admitting that a program that gave the national government much more control over doctors and patients would survive any constitutional challenge. Of course, as the conservatives know, a single-payer system would be politically impossible in the United States now, or in the foreseeable future.”
Liberals serve no one’s interests—let alone the uninsured—imagining that if Obamacare is blown to pieces, America will finally adopt a universal public insurance scheme.
The notion is escapist magic.
Would they propose that Obama promise to nationalize the core business of America’s trillion dollar insurance industry? Do they have any idea how they would recruit, elect, and whip a filibuster-free Congress to pass the necessary legislation—legislation they’ve refused to pass for generations when the bill would have been half what it would be today? Have they any idea where they’d raise the hundreds of $billions legally necessary to compensate private insurers? Would they borrow the money or would they take it out of other priorities, like physical infrastructure and R & D?
The silliest excuse for keeping this option alive is the illusion that it’s already in place and working in Canada—the other affluent federation to the north.
In fact, if the Canadian Parliament now tried to create a single national health insurance scheme—rather than paying for less than a quarter of ten increasingly restive provincial plans—you’d have a national unity crisis in both Quebec and the Canadian West. (Certainly, the exchange markets and the conservative Wall St. Journal, which has adopted Canada as conservative economic laboratory, would have a nervous breakdown.)
In truth, there is no central public insurance scheme in Canada to inspire American centralizers.
Obama’s plan gets America to universal coverage without distorting American federalism beyond recognition. Liberals with their feet on the ground should defend it with passion.

Tuesday, April 10, 2012

David Brooks’s defense of Paul Ryan’s budget

David Brooks’s column offers one thing to those few radical Republicans who hope to be on the Republican ticket with Mitt Romney in November—he’ll moderate their extremism and, thus, offer the promise that they can be marketed as credible potential vice presidents this fall.
Last week, in a column entitled “That Other Obama,” Brooks provided a profile of a strikingly domesticated Paul Ryan, the author of a Republican budget that—in his own words—will give America an entirely new America to choose this fall.
Of course, Ryan is not a traditional conservative; his prescriptions are invariably radical and his tactics usually are designed to radicalize—to drive American politics to the extremes.
Brooks confesses that he finds that Ryan’s budget includes “disturbing” weaknesses: disruptive cuts in support for science and poor kids, and regressive tax cuts, for instance.
Brooks will not rescue Ryan by defending the substance of his extraordinary budget. He’ll find moderation, however, in Ryan’s dogged nature. He complains that Obama is uncharitable about the major reforms outlined in Ryan’s budget.   
Obama, unfairly, won’t let Ryan be a fiscal moderate, even if Brooks is the only conservative in America who wants him to look like one.
Brooks's biggest task is to make palatable Ryan’s plan to turn universal public healthcare for seniors into a financial assistance program for seniors seeking their own health insurance. It’s indisputable that Ryan’s plan would ultimately end Medicare as we know it. And there’s no reason to expect Obama will stop pointing that out. However, Brooks's rhetorical game is smaller. He aims to turn Ryan’s think-tank abstraction into a cozy done deal:
“The Ryan plan would slowly phase in a premium support option, in which the government would give people money to buy insurance. This general idea was embraced by Bill Clinton’s bipartisan Medicare reform commission. It follows a similar design to the prescription drug benefit. Its effectiveness is unproved, but it’s a time-tested and respectable proposal, with expert support.
Time-tested, please. Time is no more a conservative selling point for a 20-year health insurance proposal than is moss on the north side of a 20-year-old tree.
Time tests actions, not white papers or draft budgets in Washington. Bad ideas don’t improve with time; and good ideas don’t need to wait another generation.
In the 16th century, Michel de Montaigne wrote:
“I look on the present as no less credible than the past, and I would as soon quote my neighbour as Aulus Gellius or Macrobius, and what I have seen as readily as what they have written.  Just as virtue is not more virtuous for having flourished longer, so I hold a truth is no wiser for being older.”
Ronald Reagan escaped persistent questioning of his faith in the medicinal value of massive tax cuts with that affable slap-down available to an older man: “There you go again.”
Can young Paul Ryan handle his critics that way as well?

Tuesday, April 3, 2012

Consultant rhetoric: the genius of the data-man

Mitt Romney spent a lot longer than Barack Obama learning how to behave like a trustworthy WASP. For an ambitious outsider, that was a good political investment. You may not want to drink beer with him, but you’d probably still prefer to let a good WASP dock your boat.

Romney is dangerous politically because he’s better at being a WASP than the two authentic WASPs Obama beat in 2008. Specifically, he can be believed when he’s telling whoppers and he can sound genuine when he’s on pilot.

The New York Times provided no asides or embellishments when it reported his pitch to The Faith and Freedom Forum of Pewaukee, Wisconsin. Really, we should be allowed to let down our guard when the secure Republican front-runner addresses an audience of Americans assembled under the sacred words “faith” and “freedom.” You’d expect a little extra care and respect for the truth. Don’t make be mistaken about this man.

Here’s Romney’s studiously boring and extravagantly dishonest take on Obamacare:

“Government at all levels – federal, state and local – today consumes about 35 percent of our total economy, that we think of ourselves as a free market nation,” Mr. Romney said. “Thirty-five percent is spent by government. And when Obamacare – if it’s allowed to stand, if it’s allowed to stand – I hope the Supreme Court does their job and strikes it down. And if they don’t I will.”

He added: “But with Obamacare, that would take government to almost half of the total economy.”


In truth, US government activities consume between 15% to 20% of total US income. Over half of the income governments receive in taxes and charges is immediately transferred back to individuals—many individuals, for instance, who were listening to Mr. Romney on Saturday morning. Furthermore, the provision of private health insurance for the uninsured would not measurably increase consumption of tax dollars by government. It would not “socialize” America.

Romney’s dishonesty isn’t fascinating for its magnitude or originality.

Demagogues and paid lobbyists with dead-end careers have been saying as much from day one. What is interesting is his conviction that he can get away with it — that, in fact, he can give it extra force by being specific, by being Mitt the data-man.

Raw information—data—will be readily available for analysis and exploitation, to enlighten and confuse the issues during the presidential election. Romney intends to use it voraciously. It will be left to others to keep him honest

Thursday, March 29, 2012

For the good of America, eat your broccoli

If liberals didn’t scare so easily, they’d have savored the pure nuttiness of US Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia’s slippery slope affection for the case against making individuals pay in advance for necessary future health services.

“The argument got going when Justice Antonin Scalia asked Solicitor General Donald B. Verrilli Jr. if the government could compel Americans to buy health insurance, could it also mandate that they eat healthy food, like broccoli. “Could you define the market — everybody has to buy food sooner or later, so you define the market as food, therefore, everybody is in the market; therefore, you can make people buy broccoli?”

“Mr. Verrilli tried to put the question behind him, saying, “No, that’s quite different. The food market, while it shares that trait that everybody’s in it, it is not a market in which your participation is often unpredictable and often involuntary.” But the justices returned to the example again and again.”


Let’s, for a moment, take broccoli as seriously as the US Constitution takes Antonin Scalia.

Imagine a Supreme Court case on Affordable Broccoli-Care.

Let’s assume that Scalia was using broccoli as a broadly reasonable substitute for nutritious food, rather than candy or colored wood pulp. And let’s assume that there was widely accepted evidence that millions of Americans—including thousands of pregnant women—were not eating/buying adequate amounts of broccoli/nutritious food to sustain life.

If Congress passed legislation to interfere in the broccoli/nutritious food market to favor life over immediate pleasure or the perfect operation of the price system, would Scalia and Roberts as easily ask: Will bicycles be next?

Would Republicans just as easily side with Pro-choice advocates or Pro-life advocates—who, on this question, might recall regrettable but widely accepted state interventions like food stamps and ration books?

The Court isn’t being asked to liberate seniors from socialized medicine or the destitute from socialized medicine when they show up at emergency wards. The Justices are being asked to worry about a precedent—to protect bicycles and automobile consumers from state interference.

Surely, this slippery slope argument can be entrusted to the good sense of the electorate and the desire of politicians to get re-elected. Surely, the government doesn’t have to socialize the entire medical industry to ensure universal access while avoiding a dangerous precedent for other markets.

Incidentally, no one’s taken the Patriot Act to the Courts suggesting that Congress will soon mandate that Americans install picture windows on all new housing.